News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A steep rise of Hacker News in Google rankings by dang on Monday February 19, 2024 @04:12AM (#39427599)
I think I'd include those under "lame". Misinformed comments aren't lame if they're curious and (therefore) open to correction, but when they are categorical statements (usually some form of denunciation or grandiose generalization), yeah that's lame.

> This ratio has steadily gotten worse over the past years

I'm not sure. Everything has always been getting worse, or feels like it has. You'd have to discount for this universal tendency to get an accurate reading of whether things have really gotten worse, and no one really knows how to do that, nor really wants to. It's more satisfying to feel the decline of civilization setting in as one ages. Yes, that's a grandiose generalization and therefore lame.

Or, to flip it into a positive, you're more experienced and informed than you used to be, so more comments appear misinformed or inexperienced.

Re:A steep rise of Hacker News in Google rankings by tptacek on Monday February 19, 2024 @03:16PM (#39434260)
Some titration of open-minded misinformed comments is probably vital to the functioning of the site; without them, a lot of interesting true stuff is buried as shared subtext among the specialists here, and sails over the heads of everyone else.

This is a problem I've seen in specialist forums elsewhere; the conversation runs out, because nobody's poking the community with wrong stuff, and correcting a wrong statement is intensely more motivating than just making a plain factual statement for its own benefit (also: when you do that, the rest of the community will go "uh, yeah, and?").