Things like this need good signal to noise ratio to survive. Just throwing your hands in the air and saying anything goes doesn't work because users don't want to search through 10 billion mislabelled things to find the right one.

that’s what’s going to happen though

Unfortunately the majority of it will be malware or illegal porn in the blink of an eye without a good way to separate it.

street smarts

community indexer

why download anything from a list of torrents, okay use the same set of rules