Usually the second option is more lucrative because it feels more attractive to customers, and if someone buys from a cheaper-to-ship location or buys multiple products you save more on shipping without passing the savings to the customer.
VCs and many others did the same in Uber, UberEats, scooters, etc.
Then they stopped when the Fed started raising rates, as they expected (correctly) that expectations were changing and revenue now mattered more than expected future trajectory.
It was an attempt at market dumping using investor cash in order to capture the market.
And it kinda worked. Taxi companies took a serious hit.
Now we’re seeing more realistic market prices, and investors are getting hit hard. Because they didn’t succeed at getting the monopoly they wanted.
That’s the larger picture, IMO.
I keep my costs to the bare minimum. I started it because I wanted decals no one else was making. I cannot justify feee shipping.
In the UK I eat the cost as it is about £1 to ship UK wide. Posting to the US is now around £7. I need to send tracked thanks to the selling platform.
It honestly pains me to have to charge shipping - but I could’t do it any other way. I can only imagine the costs that are associated with this for bigger outfits. Heck. Even Amazon has a logistics company now (but I suppose that’s where the Prime premium comes in!)