News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Science fiction authors were excluded from awards for fea... by int_19h on Sunday February 18, 2024 @05:11AM (#39417790)
I concur on all your points. The writing was so bad - basically middle of the line fanfic level - that at first I thought that it was a low-quality English translation; but I was assured that it was faithful to the original. When it was announced as Hugo winner, I was speechless.

I should also add that as reasonably hard sci-fi goes, the very notion of "sophons" (and their mechanics) as presented are not even wrong. In general, when it comes to most sci-fi elements of the book aside from the titular concept, it felt like someone just clipped whatever sounded cool from a popular science magazine and then tried to write a segment of the story around it - i.e. some things, like nanowires/sheets, are introduced not because they make sense in context, but solely for the cool factor.

Re:Science fiction authors were excluded from awards for fea... by adastra22 on Monday February 19, 2024 @12:30AM (#39426501)
It’s crazy how much people adore that novel though, despite the OBVIOUS flaws.
Re:Science fiction authors were excluded from awards for fea... by humanlity on Monday February 19, 2024 @08:38AM (#39429579)
I think Liu's writing is not bad (Chinese version), but the economics may not be good
Re:Science fiction authors were excluded from awards for fea... by eyeris on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @08:07PM (#39449054)
Funnily enough, in his interview with Jim al-khalili, Liu Cixin describes roughly what you conjectured as how he gets inspiration for his works