News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by flappyeagle on Saturday February 17, 2024 @02:21PM (#39412513)
I’m hiring for 2 positions. We have 400 candidates that our recruiters need to filter through. By the time they’re done we will have 200 more.

The instructions I give these recruiters are designed to whittle the number down to a manageable amount that I can go through in detail.

I don’t think today’s LLMs with good fine tuning and prompting would perform any worse than the nontechnical humans doing this particular task. I’m actually shocked our ATS doesn’t have this feature already.

Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by ZephyrBlu on Saturday February 17, 2024 @02:32PM (#39412635)
LLMs not performing worse than non-technical people isn't a good thing. Non-technical people also filter out the best candidates.

"[whittling] the number down" is generally not a good way to find the best applicants, because it is purely focused on reducing the number of applications rather than picking out potentially good ones. It's a safe, low-risk approach that reduces variance.

Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by ip26 on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:26PM (#39413214)
Whittling out chaff does help you get a better view of the average quality, and there’s no point reading 400 resumes if 200 of them are basically resume spam.
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by ZephyrBlu on Saturday February 17, 2024 @04:41PM (#39413808)
Why do you care about average quality? You're hiring a specific person. These kind of things should be rule-in, not rule-out. You also cannot tell the difference between resume spam and a potential candidate until you read the resume.

400 resumes @ 1min per (Which is generous) is ~7hrs.

400 resumes @ 10sec per is only ~1hr.

Recruiters might be useful at filtering out obvious spam, though I don't feel like can help with much past that and I think they're also liable to put legitimate but unconventional candidates in the spam pile.

Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by flappyeagle on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:51AM (#39420023)
Average quality matters because you need to be realistic with the talent level you’re able to attract
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by flappyeagle on Saturday February 17, 2024 @02:46PM (#39412780)
It depends on what instruction you give. You’re making a lot of wild assumptions.
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by ZephyrBlu on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:05PM (#39412991)
What instructions do you provide then? It's not a wild assumption when easily 95% of people/companies operate like this.
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by flappyeagle on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:48AM (#39420002)
I provide instructions that are specifically tailored to the role I’m hiring for
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by SantalBlush on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:21PM (#39413154)
I think the idea is that any set of rules or principles for filtering applications can and will be gamed.
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by esafak on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:31PM (#39413265)
The candidates don't know your filters.
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by liquidpele on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:00PM (#39412926)
Well, agreed, but letting the recruiters filter has always been terrible and they always filter out talent more than they find it. It’s perhaps the most bone headed thing you could do in hiring.
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by srackey on Saturday February 17, 2024 @02:35PM (#39412660)
So does everyone apply to 200 job postings? Or is tech in a massive recession?
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by xanderlewis on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:08PM (#39413025)
PhD positions (at least in the UK) are similarly in demand: about 100 applications for 5 places. And, inspired by your calculation, it’s definitely not true that each person is applying to 20 places. I guess a lot of people just don’t get in. It does seem like a lot of people I know are genuinely struggling to find a job.

There are probably more than enough lower paying, lower prestige jobs on offer, but they don’t require academic qualifications and so university graduates feel they deserve better.

Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by yunwal on Saturday February 17, 2024 @03:44PM (#39413380)
> There are probably more than enough lower paying, lower prestige jobs on offer, but they don’t require academic qualifications and so university graduates feel they deserve better.

There’s also the issue that people will get dismissed as “overqualified”.

Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by xanderlewis on Saturday February 17, 2024 @08:24PM (#39415235)
I guess, but it's hard to believe you'd be turned down for a job on a supermarket checkout because you've got a degree.
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by BrandonWatson on Saturday February 17, 2024 @02:47PM (#39412788)
It's slightly different than that.

It's the low "cost" of publishing a job post to various boards, and the low "cost" of applying to jobs that are posted.

The combinatorial math has exploded the number of applicants per position, but the talent pool has not expanded by that much.

The net result is companies are abdicating agency to ATS systems in an effort to filter the "best" resumes.

Candidates are responding by feeling disillusioned by the ghosting, non-responses, and 400 applications within 24 hours to any new job posting.

Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 17, 2024 @02:51PM (#39412841)
A lot of job sites make it easy to apply to arbitrarily many jobs, so if a candidate wants to they can fairly efficiently apply to every job on the site. It's not hard to imagine that there are at least 200 such people.
Re:AI hiring tools may be filtering out the best job applicants by flappyeagle on Saturday February 17, 2024 @02:47PM (#39412789)
I don’t know. They are remote positions so there are a lot of geographies that can apply