News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by Vt71fcAqt7 on Friday February 16, 2024 @02:03PM (#39401501)
It's great that Godot keeps improving. AFAIK it is still mostly for indie devs though. I don't know why valve isn't open sourcing Source 2. They barely even make games anymore and it would make them money in the long term if it means games could be made cheaper and better. UE5 on the other hand is leaps and bounds greater than both Source 2 and Godot judging from the few games that have released with it so far. There's also O3DE which last I checked isn't ready.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by jsheard on Friday February 16, 2024 @02:26PM (#39401782)
Valve doesn't try to make general purpose engines, they make engines that suit their own games, so unless you happen to be making a game which is shaped very much like HL:Alyx or CS2 you would probably be underwhelmed with Source 2. That includes platform support, Source 2 doesn't officially support any of the consoles because Valve hasn't needed it to, having only ever shipped it on PC and (briefly) Android/iOS.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by snoutie on Friday February 16, 2024 @02:43PM (#39401983)
Then again there is s&box which I would not consider being close to either, well the games that can be made with s&box at least. But I agree that it would probably be hard to build something like Teardown inside the Source 2 Engine. On the other hand: Teardown does not use Unity either.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by jsheard on Friday February 16, 2024 @02:46PM (#39402015)
S&box licensing Source 2 is a bit of an enigma to me, I get the impression that they're having to rewrite huge swaths of the engine so I don't know what they're getting out of it. They've gone to the lengths of integrating C# scripting from scratch rather than using the scripting facilities that Source 2 comes with. Nobody else has licensed Source 2 in the 4 years since s&box adopted it, so they're the lone outlier in any case.

Respawns use of Source 1 was a similar story, they ended up rewriting practically everything in the course of developing Titanfall and Apex Legends, to the point that it's almost unrecognisable as Source at this point.

Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by jna_sh on Friday February 16, 2024 @06:16PM (#39404326)
I don’t think there is (or needs to be) much more to it than Garry’s personal history and success with Source
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by meibo on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:42PM (#39405473)
Garry has publicly expressed regret over choosing Source 2 for this reason, but they might be in too deep now. Generally, the tooling is really great, so I guess that's the primary benefit.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by Rohansi on Friday February 16, 2024 @10:24PM (#39406042)
Do you have a source for this? S&box used to use UE4 in the past but as soon as Source 2 became an option immediately jumped ship. There has been a ton of progress since then and I don't see why he would regret switching to Source 2 when no other engine would have made as good of a base for S&box.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by Rohansi on Friday February 16, 2024 @10:20PM (#39406029)
S&box has rewritten many parts of the engine in C# at this point. Gets rid of lots of legacy code and makes this easier to change in the future. Using the scripting facilities built into Source 2 would have restricted what could be written in C# and slowed the team down.

If you haven't taken a look at S&box recently it's looking a lot more like Unity now. https://sbox.game/news/scene-system

Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by pests on Friday February 16, 2024 @04:30PM (#39403229)
Valves doesn't make games anymore because they are making piles of money running a platform.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by rowanG077 on Friday February 16, 2024 @05:21PM (#39403733)
That and the skin trade is literally a multi billion dollar business. It boggles the mind.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by andrewmcwatters on Friday February 16, 2024 @04:43PM (#39403375)
Valve does not have a great reputation with its licensees anymore or its former mod developer community. This is probably a large part of it.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by krapp on Friday February 16, 2024 @02:14PM (#39401639)
The AAA industry is eating itself right now. Indie seems like a good place to be.

Also, indie games are a billion dollar market. Maybe it's time to stop using it as a synonym for "not serious." The consumer doesn't care that Undertale was made with Game Maker.

>There's also O3DE which last I checked isn't ready.

Literally no one cares about O3DE.

Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by freedomben on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:59PM (#39402887)
I don't think "indie" is synonymous with "not serious," at least if people use it that way I think they're wrong and I think there a lot of people who use it the same way I do.

To me "indie" is usually more a reflection of budget, which heavily impacts graphical sophistication, size of the game (as in how many levels, how many hours of play, etc), and usually means the price of the game will be between $5 and $30. AAA I expect $60 and 100+ hours of playable content. Indie game I expect 5 to 6 hours and I'm pleasantly surprised when it's more. When it comes to choice of game engine, that usually means they prefer less flexibility but more simplicity and "free stuff" from the framework, whereas a AAA game might prefer maximum flexibility, but that comes with complexity. As in all things it's a budget (time & money) tradeoff, not necessarily an "are we serious" tradeoff.

Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by filleduchaos on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:38PM (#39405448)
> AAA I expect $60 and 100+ hours of playable content. Indie game I expect 5 to 6 hours and I'm pleasantly surprised when it's more.

My experience is much more the opposite, with plenty of indie games providing many hours of actual gameplay (including replayability) and plenty of AAA games inflating their runtime with long cutscenes and other fluff (or milking people for all they're worth through live service).

Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by freedomben on Saturday February 17, 2024 @11:36AM (#39410963)
Thank you yes, fair point. the cutscenes can get quite outrageous, and I refuse to play the games that do in app purchases and the like, so I have an unrepresentative sample in my experience.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by genocidicbunny on Saturday February 17, 2024 @04:33AM (#39407887)
> AFAIK it is still mostly for indie devs though

There was a time when Unity was the 'indie game engine' as well. Give Godot some time (especially since it's progress seems to be picking up steam.)

> UE5 on the other hand is leaps and bounds greater

UE5 has the benefit of standing on the shoulders of giants, not to mention giant-sized pockets of cash to spend on developing it. UE has been around since 1998, so we're talking a quarter of a century of development leading up to what UE5 is today. It also has the added benefit of having been used for a huge number of different games, so there's an additional level of refinement in the toolset that it offers, since it's had to adapt to suit so many games.

Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by Narishma on Saturday February 17, 2024 @05:59AM (#39408355)
> There was a time when Unity was the 'indie game engine' as well.

That's still the case, depending on how you define indie. I'm not aware of any major AAA game made with Unity.

Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by genocidicbunny on Saturday February 17, 2024 @06:36AM (#39408546)
I don't know if it's quite considered AAA, but Cities Skylines was made in Unity, and that was a pretty big game.
Re:GPU synchronization in Godot 4.3 is getting a major upgrade by naet on Saturday February 17, 2024 @02:55PM (#39412882)
Not sure how you define AAA, but a lot of popular games have been made with Unity. Some major studios have used Unity for mobile games related to bigger properties too.

Some Unity games I know of:

Genshin Impact (maybe the closest to "AAA")

Rust

Fall Guys

Escape from Tarkov

Cuphead

Fallout Shelter

The Elder Scrolls: Legends

Magic: The Gathering Arena

Super Mario Run

Mario Kart Tour

Hollow Knight

Untitled Goose Game