News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What you need to know about the future of Mozilla Hubs by wkat4242 on Thursday February 15, 2024 @09:18PM (#39392314)
I've considered using it at work but it wasn't really great. There was only a web client.

I think it was a weird tangent for Mozilla, but the product itself is not bad at the core. Probably some more specialised org will take over management of it like what happened to Mozilla's other abandoned products.

Re:What you need to know about the future of Mozilla Hubs by a_bonobo on Thursday February 15, 2024 @10:19PM (#39392795)
Yes, let's hope! The strategy has worked out sometimes - Google shut down 'Google Refine' 10 years ago, it got turned into 'Open Refine', last release five days ago. https://github.com/OpenRefine/OpenRefine

It's a hugely useful tool if you're working with messy Excel-scale data, i.e., most biologists or social scientists.

Re:What you need to know about the future of Mozilla Hubs by dale_glass on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:56AM (#39394726)
I think of the weird things that Mozilla does, this one made sense. It's a web-based environment. At the very least it's useful to push Firefox to do 3D better.

If you're looking for something desktop based, by the way, I work on such a thing.

Re:What you need to know about the future of Mozilla Hubs by wkat4242 on Friday February 16, 2024 @09:07AM (#39397167)
> I think of the weird things that Mozilla does, this one made sense. It's a web-based environment. At the very least it's useful to push Firefox to do 3D better.

Fair enough, good point.

> If you're looking for something desktop based, by the way, I work on such a thing.

Oh I've tried several. Spatial (which is now more general metaverse and less businessy, sadly), Arthur. Immersed. And now we're using MS Mesh. Mesh kinda sucks (it works, but you can't do anything and even the meeting host has no control over the instancing). But it's free with O365.

Mesh is basically a rebadged AltSpaceVR by the way, but with most of the features removed, curiously.

I'm kinda curious which one you're working on though :) I know there's more than the above but I haven't tried them. The biggest problem of all of them though is the usecase. The why. Even though Mesh is free now, I have a really hard time justifying why to actually deploy it.

The whole convention thing is not really worth it IMO, and not many sites bother with WebXR anymore. Personally I'm a huge VR enthusiast and just hanging out is a perfectly good reason for me but I have bosses that are a lot more critical :)

Re:What you need to know about the future of Mozilla Hubs by dale_glass on Friday February 16, 2024 @09:48AM (#39397746)
> I'm kinda curious which one you're working on though :) I know there's more than the above but I haven't tried them.

I'm on Overte, an open source fork of the dead commercial High Fidelity.

We don't have WebXR right now, but we could grab that functionality off another fork quite easily. The main reason we didn't is that we're desktop VR focused and that the readily available code is slow and buggy. But we do have a pathway there should there be enough interest.

> The biggest problem of all of them though is the usecase. The why. Even though Mesh is free now, I have a really hard time justifying why to actually deploy it.

Our deployment process is extremely simple. Both the client and server can be compiled trivially, there's no complex dependencies.

Our usecase is doing whatever you want. Unlike most everyone else we've got a distributed model where we don't control what you do with it. It's a bit like a 3D webserver in principle.

The software is very suitable for massive environments though.

Re:What you need to know about the future of Mozilla Hubs by gfodor on Saturday February 17, 2024 @05:56PM (#39414331)
The team that build Hubs was also part of the team that built AltspaceVR.
Re:What you need to know about the future of Mozilla Hubs by loloquwowndueo on Friday February 16, 2024 @07:34AM (#39396104)
Everything is a web client. Just because they wrap it in Electron and peddle it as a “native client” doesn’t usually make it so.
Re:What you need to know about the future of Mozilla Hubs by SahAssar on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:14AM (#39396524)
I don't think most other "metaverse"/VR-chat type stuff is electron. Mozilla wanted this to be a web client presumably to be a good demo/killer app for webXR and related tech.
Re:What you need to know about the future of Mozilla Hubs by moron4hire on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:24AM (#39396657)
That's how it started, but then Mozilla laid off their WebXR team. I never understood why they did that but kept Hubs. And there were weird things, too, like Hubs would work on the Quest in Meta's WebXR-compliant fork of Chromium, but not on desktop in Google Chrome with all the same necessary WebXR features. Truly bizarre priorities.