News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by MichaelZuo on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @12:45AM (#39354877)
To be honest this just sounds like a bunch of talking points stuck together, can you write a credible argument based on known case-law/precedent/etc... if you have a legal angle to critique?
Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by mtsr on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @01:20AM (#39355067)
Society isn’t shaped just by current laws, but also by where we want things to go. If the current situations is undesirable, changing laws and regulations is the way to change it. (Of course actually enforcing current laws and regulations can also go a long way in many cases…)
Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by killingtime74 on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @01:44AM (#39355210)
Sounds like it's just undesirable to you. (I don't own any Nvidia stock). Their growth to their current position in the market was organic. You don't just break down big companies for no reason other than them being big. If we did, there's a long line of companies ahead of Nvidia to be broken up first.
Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by benreesman on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @10:34AM (#39358546)
I don’t see what being organic has to do with market failures (if in fact there were no shenanigans, which seems a stretch to posit at zero).

A market failure is a market failure.

There’s a big lobby on HN who want to defend or minimize or justify leaving market failures be, which is weird given they’re really bad for most people on HN, it’s a free country.

But let’s call it what it is.

Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @01:56AM (#39355268)
So what changes to the law do you propose? None of the little annoyances that Nvidia is occasionally creating amount to anything that could have resulted in their current dominance in AI processing.

They made a good product. The competition is responding too slowly. And they got lucky with this crazy (in a good way) AI boom. I don't see how this could possibly be outlawed or why you would even want to. It will resolve itself on its own given enough time.

Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by panick21_ on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @05:14AM (#39356237)
How about right-to-repair. How about forcing better access, documented, attributable firmware. Open Drivers for Linux.

The government as a big costumers could demand these things, even without having a low. The military should demand these things to be open for various reasons.

I think Nvida can still make plenty of money in such a world.

In cases where an interface has absurdly high value for society if its a standard, the government could also 'buy' that and open it up. Just like they do with other infrastructure.

One could make the argument that the x86 interface should be public domain as it amounts to infrastructure that most of society builds on. How such a thing would exactly work is of course up for some debate. But the concept of the government 'liberating' common interfaces makes sense from a society perspective.

Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @06:05AM (#39356606)
>How about right-to-repair. How about forcing better access, documented, attributable firmware. Open Drivers for Linux.

How would that have stopped Nvidia from dominating the AI market?

>The government as a big costumers could demand these things, even without having a low. The military should demand these things to be open for various reasons.

I agree that governments should use APIs with multiple competing implementations (or one truly open source implementation) where possible. This could make a difference in some cases, but I doubt it would have had a big impact in this particular case as demand for GPGPU is overwhelmingly coming from the private sector.

>In cases where an interface has absurdly high value for society if its a standard, the government could also 'buy' that and open it up. Just like they do with other infrastructure.

Agreed, but is there a legal reason why AMD and others are not allowed to create a clean room implementation of CUDA? Haven't they done exactly that with ZLUDA (which they have now defunded)?

I thought not supporting CUDA was more like a failed strategic move by competitors to prevent CUDA from becoming an industry standard.

I think we agree on all the relevant principles. I just don't see how any of these principles make a big difference in this particular case.

Also, I don't see the Nvidia situation as particularly problematic. They are not too entrenched to unseat. Some of their biggest customers (themselves huge oligopolists) are shaping up to be their biggest competitors.

Most of AI processing will be inference, not training. Bringing the costs down is absolutely key for broad AI use. My bet is that the hardware margins will end up being slim.

Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by benreesman on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @05:39AM (#39356405)
I’m saying that we have “deregulated” big-cap tech to the point of not enforcing laws that we enforced even a decade ago. This is analogous to the last time a sector 100% captured the regulators which was high finance in the Greenspan era last time. Ended poorly.

The likely height of big-cap tech regulation was the regulated monopoly of ATT/Bell Labs/Western Digital all through the 20th century.

I prefer the outcomes in that era to the present status quo.

You can agree or disagree, and disagreeing is simple: “I prefer these outcomes because…”. I welcome such disagreement. And FWIW I’m not one of the many people who downvoted you: but they were justified in doing so because you moved a comparison of policies and their outcomes into a more abstract space of 1-bit generalizations, e.g. “talking points” vs “law/precedent”. I gave examples, it’s public record and trivially Googleable.

You didn’t fail to understand my point, you didn’t like it and took a cheap shot.

Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by MichaelZuo on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @06:31PM (#39364351)
I never claimed to have “fail to understand my point” ? Are you sure your not misreading something?
Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by benreesman on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @06:50PM (#39364496)
Le sigh. I said big-cap tech used to get in trouble with the DoJ a lot, but has gotten finance-good at lobbying and so they don't get slapped hard anymore. You said that I was stringing together talking points and not citing concrete examples.

Let me (start to) Google that for you:

https://www.sec.gov/enforce/sec-enforcement-actions-fcpa-cas...

https://www.justice.gov/atr/antitrust-case-filings-alpha

https://www.csoonline.com/article/567531/the-biggest-data-br...

https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/24/doj-files-second-antitrust-l...

https://www.channele2e.com/news/big-tech-antitrust-regulator...

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/23/technology/justice-depart...

... scads more law stuff and a decade ...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...

... scads more law stuff and a decade ...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....

Re:Nvidia is now more valuable than Amazon and Google by MichaelZuo on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @01:40PM (#39373466)
What does 'Le sigh.' mean?

And I never mentioned 'not citing concrete examples.', if your confused about the ask, I'll repost it: "can you write a credible argument based on known case-law/precedent/etc... "

i.e. Can you write down the actual argument that you propose to advance?