People don't let their country dissolve because a distant adversary has a slightly better GDP per capita. It goes much deeper than that.
In 1989, Boris Yeltsin literally could not believe the variety and abundance of food at an average American grocery store.
https://www.chron.com/neighborhood/bayarea/news/article/When...
And yes, it sucks that the most comfortable one is more expensive. But ...
USA undoubtedly had better access to a wide variety of groceries due to its geography and agrarian economy. Russia doesn't have a California or Mexico (the best candidate, Turkey, was part of NATO).
That doesn't mean USA also didn't have a vastly superior propaganda ecosystem, from Hollywood to the NYT.
As I've said elsewhere in this thread, the people who tore apart the USSR did so because the USSR didn't work. That he went on to be instrumental in the ultimate dissolution of the USSR is not evidence that his shock and awe at the abundance in the US was staged.
> USA undoubtedly had better access to a wide variety of groceries due to its geography and agrarian economy. Russia doesn't have a California or Mexico (the best candidate, Turkey, was part of NATO).
Your parent commenter is talking about the reactions they got from people visiting Finland.
> That doesn't mean USA also didn't have a vastly superior propaganda ecosystem, from Hollywood to the NYT.
The USA had a better propaganda system if you include the facts they had at their disposal as part of that system. If we instead look at how well each country did with the facts that they had, you are living proof that the USSR's propaganda system was incredible.
Faced with the fact that people in the USSR starved by the millions while people next door in Finland had abundance, you somehow manage to place the blame on geography instead of on the human systems that the Soviets put in place.
But I agree that there's nothing more to be gained by continuing this conversation.
Basic goods like sausages, stockings and toilet paper - which had constant shortages - aren't some high tech that only a selection of countries are able to produce, geography permitting. It was USSR's choice to focus so much and so wastefully on the military that western stores looked like an unbelievable dream to Soviet citizens who lived their entire lives deprived of most mundane consumer goods.
Who even needs a propaganda ecosystem, when western plastic bags with graphic prints were such a luxury item in 1980s USSR that people proudly paraded them around in the public, then came home, carefully folded them (some even ironed with a cold iron to get rid of wrinkles), and put away for the next time - until the bags became completely faded.
Nobody in the west would've believed the sheer absurdity of everyday life in the USSR.
I'm not saying it happened because we had a slightly better GDP, I'm saying it happened because their system legitimately sucked. To try to attribute it to western propaganda does a disservice to the people who actively worked to end communism in Eastern Europe because they were tired of the abuse.
If you are under the impression that communism didn't have "prison slaves" or gross mistreatment of ethnic minorities, then it seems pretty clear that their propaganda system was at least somewhat effective.
Joseph Stalin alone signed off on multiple genocides [0]. Tatars, Cossacks, Ukrainians, Poles, Jews, there were plenty of ethnic groups that the Soviets identified as the enemy and purged or deported en masse.
The US is far from perfect, but the whataboutism isn't very effective when Stalin alone has a body count numbered in the millions.
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_massacres_in_the_Sov...
Whataboutism is asking "what about" and take something unrelated. This is taking the exact example given by a commie and pointing out that leftist propaganda and reality were VERY different. And here you are ... defending the propaganda, demonstrating exactly what is going wrong here.
There are actually some aspects of Soviet life where Western states were on the whole worse than Soviets (e.g. pure science education, or labor participation and independence for women) by current moral standards. But not many, and frankly, mostly not for good reasons.
Of course we all know that this was true in nearly all cases. Obviously some Russians (e.g. state employees) had it better than some American groups. Although even there it turned out they often preferred American lifestyles.
If by propaganda you mean "having a demonstrably better quality of life", then yeah, the West had a better propaganda machine which successfully persuaded many in the Soviet Union that maybe our system wasn't so bad after all.
But if we take a more narrow definition of propaganda that doesn't include actually having a better lifestyle, the Soviet Union propaganda machine had a lot more work on their hands in order to persuade a substantial portion of the West that their system worked. Under that definition of propaganda I think it's no contest which propaganda machine was more effective—to this day we have people in the West who will insist to an Eastern European's face that life in the Soviet Union wasn't so bad.