News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cloudflare defeats patent troll Sable at trial by paledot on Monday February 12, 2024 @08:07PM (#39353006)
Somehow the winning ticket in popular discourse is to be a patent troll: at best, "sell my idea" to some big company (troll); at worst convince a court to give you a pile of money because someone "stole" your idea (in advance). It is a rare person who dreams of coming up with a good idea and then working hard for years to make it a reality.
Re:Cloudflare defeats patent troll Sable at trial by freejazz on Monday February 12, 2024 @09:45PM (#39353695)
How many patent trolls do you know? As compared to people that you know who would/could be an inventor on a patent? I'm a patent litigator and it's still the latter for me. This narrative is a bit histrionic.
Re:Cloudflare defeats patent troll Sable at trial by djmips on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @07:45AM (#39357096)
Hmmmm, I mostly know people who worked for big companies who got BS patents for bragging rights and one from a small startup with one obvious idea but they wanted to try and protect themselves since the idea was essential to their core business. The former don't seem much different from trolls while the latter should not have been granted a patent since it was so obvious IMO.
Re:Cloudflare defeats patent troll Sable at trial by paledot on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @10:58AM (#39358848)
As a software developer, I'm not exactly representative, nor are you. The point was about ambition/popular perception, not the reality. If your "maybe someday" dream prominently features being issued a patent, it's not because you'll use the patent responsibily to defend the idea that you're actively developing and marketing. If your "maybe someday" plan involves developing and marketing an idea, patents might be a factor somewhere way down the list of how to get there, but that's a very different ambition.

(That's not to say that the reality isn't also broken, just that popular perception is even more broken.)

Re:Cloudflare defeats patent troll Sable at trial by freejazz on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @11:15AM (#39359132)
> The point was about ambition/popular perception, not the reality.

What a silly point then. Who cares what people's perceptions are when they are not based in reality.

> If your "maybe someday" dream prominently features being issued a patent, it's not because you'll use the patent responsibily to defend the idea that you're actively developing and marketing.

I see, so nobody can get a patent because nobody will use a patent "responsibly".

There's no point in furthering this conversation.