Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t...
by flom on Friday May 04, 2012 @03:39PM
(#3929984)
You make a good point. In my earlier post, replace "universe" with "solar system." Then, I can represent the states of the solar system in some subset of the universe, and I'll place this computer sufficiently far from the solar system so it doesn't interfere. Now I should be able to predict what happens on earth, unless you think that variables outside of our solar system significantly affect activities on earth, right?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t...
by olalonde on Friday May 04, 2012 @06:29PM
(#3930615)
1) Don't underestimate the butterfly effect. 2) We can already predict the future to a certain extent. 3) What you wish the universe was like is irrelevant. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wishful_thinking
Re:Roger Penrose Says Physics Is Wrong, From String Theory t...
by flom on Saturday May 05, 2012 @12:58AM
(#3931393)
Re 2: There should be an obvious qualitative difference between being able to predict where a ball will land if I throw it, and predicting who the passengers riding a particular train in 15 years will be.
Re 3: I was commenting on Roger Penrose's assumption that quantum must be "wrong" because it's "unintuitive" by expressing my opinion that I think quantum is more intuitive than deterministic theories. Indeed, Dr. Penrose and I are both using "wishful thinking," as did Einstein when he hypothesized that the speed of light is "constant in a vacuum." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_light#Special_relativi...