I mostly liked Cryptonomicon and Anathem--but I probably wouldn't push a reader into the latter as an introduction.
But all in all. His take on that culture seems accurate. Not exaggerated that much for satire.
I concur that it's probably his worst novel that I've read. And that Anathem probably shouldn't be anyone's introduction to his work.
Seriously: life is too short.
(I say this as a huge NS fan)
It’s not high art, but I probably enjoyed it in my top 5 books of the year.
Different people have different tastes, I just find it funny when people make generalized statements like “this book is so bad, no one should ever read it.”
REAMDE was ok, except the sections about the MMO which frequently left me catatonic with cringe. In Fall, the whole book is that cringe.
However I disliked Reamde enough that I didn't start Fall. Is it better?
But I would read the phone book if NS wrote it.
This was so true in SEVENEVES. There's a whole section about debris avoidance by a constellation of orbiting spacecraft and it was so tedious. I felt like I was reading someone describing an academic paper they'd recently read.
Snow Crash - most story / style / MEMORABLE characters
Diamond Age - same but with a very dramatic evolution from traditional Cyberpunk
Anathem / Seven Eves - virtually no memorable characters, interesting concepts and science though
Cryptonomicon - I couldn't.
EDITED TO ADD: I just figured it out. My iPhone presumably thinks I'm taking about an obsolete Apple product. Doh. I'll let my error stand as a monument to not trusting everything a computer says.
I would also note that most of what we seem to be discussing is whether his writing is good or not. Spelling, I'll give him. The opinions on editing seem to be a little more divided.
He’s also largely absolutely shit at writing female characters.
Still enjoy his work, but it’s fun to find the common threads.
A great deal of content about whatever Neal Stephenson is nerding out about at the time he's writing the book that forms the world-building (The metaverse in Snow Crash, MMORPGs in REAMDE).
There will be random digressions about other things he's nerding out about that don't amount to enough to be a major feature of the world (volcanic glass knives in Snow Crash, tuck-pointing masonry in REAMDE) that he nonetheless works into the story.
Some plot happens in this world, followed by an ending of highly variable quality. He ties Snow Crash together fairly well, as I recall. REAMDE, I was less impressed by.
For context, I've read everything of his except the Baroque Cycle up to Seveneves. He's pretty consistent in sticking to this format.
In my opinion his best writing is In The Beginning Was The Command Line[0]. I particularly like the quote "I use eMacs, which might be thought of as a thermonuclear word processor." It makes me smile despite the fact that I'm a vi person. It's also uncharacteristicly short for his work.
[0] https://smorgasborg.artlung.com/C_R_Y_P_T_O_N_O_M_I_C_O_N.sh...