News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by roenxi on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @06:57PM (#39282661)
> The Oregon group’s setup generates essentially as much chlorine gas as it does iron

I'd much rather be dealing with industrial quantities of CO2 than Cl2, if that stuff gets into the atmosphere in bulk I doubt it'd end well. The article seems to suggest that the chlorine can be solved commercially so the argument seems to be that it is economical to sequester the chlorine rather than the carbon dioxide.

There are some obvious risks of being left with large amounts of Chlorine to try and find a home for, but the idea is at least plausible on face value.

Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by s0rce on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @08:00PM (#39283142)
Isn't Cl gas commercially valuable, people are making it. edit: the article says that this process would make too much...
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by kijin on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @11:54PM (#39284642)
The process results in a lot of sodium hydroxide as well. Mix it with chlorine and water, and you're back to what you started with: seawater.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by dmurray on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:02AM (#39286627)
And energy! Maybe you can even recover some of the energy from your new warm seawater.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by jszymborski on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @07:24PM (#39282891)
I imagine Cl2 being way easier to capture by virtue of its weight. It is also a very useful byproduct for downstream applications.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by XorNot on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @09:06PM (#39283602)
It's also incredibly reactive, so it's going to be a lot easier to recover in general.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by pwarner on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @07:03PM (#39282720)
I mean people are intentionally making industrial quantities of chlorine, via electrolysis, and have been for an century.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by DennisP on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @10:38PM (#39284181)
I did some quick searches thinking I'd find we produce vastly more iron than chlorine, and we surprised to learn that we only use sixteen times more iron.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by fnordpiglet on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @11:44PM (#39284585)
Being so reactive I imagine. If chlorine were much much cheaper we would find many more uses.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by lucioperca on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:24AM (#39285957)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyvinyl_chloride

Big use-case, problem is that in case of fire lots of dioxins are produced.

Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by HarryHirsch on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @10:41PM (#39284203)
Yes, and chlorine is the stuff that no one wants, so it's turned into polyvinylchloride, which isn't really useful unless with copious quantities of plasticizer.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by refurb on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:02AM (#39286625)
For something nobody wants it costs several hundred dollars per ton to buy
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by incrudible on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @08:50AM (#39288504)
The price of chlorine though is much lower still and it has been very stable until recently. How elastic is demand for PVC?
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by sharemywin on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @10:13PM (#39284013)
but at scale? how much cl2 are we talking about?
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by wolverine876 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:06AM (#39284726)
> I'd much rather be dealing with industrial quantities of CO2 than Cl2

The costs of CO2 - the real costs, not the subsidized ones - are extraordinarily high, possibly leading to the worst global catastrophe in human history. What is the cost of Cl2?

Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by ReptileMan on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:34AM (#39285649)
Parts of your lung flying out of your mouth. It was the first chemical weapon for a reason.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by lostlogin on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:41AM (#39286054)
Is gassing the frog or slowly boiling it crueler?

With the passing of time the answer might not be so clear.

Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by IMTDb on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:31AM (#39289743)
Well, you gas your frogs and I put mine in 2 degrees warmer ponds and we see which one are happier ?
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by roenxi on Saturday February 10, 2024 @07:19AM (#39325629)
Time for some dark humour! After careful analysis of the situation...

The frogs in the 2 degree warmer pond will be complaining a lot more than the other frogs, so that must be worse.

Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by concordDance on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:44AM (#39286067)
Last I checked (many years ago) the estimated long term cost from climate change due to all CO2 so far released was only in the low trillions (making WW2 a much bigger catastrophe), do you have an updated figure?
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by ulrikrasmussen on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:19AM (#39286749)
You talking about the area under an initial section of a hockey stick curve.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by pjc50 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @04:11AM (#39286272)
Swapping all the CO2 in the atmosphere for Cl would kill us all within 30 minutes (at 400ppm). It's way more dangerous.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:56AM (#39287014)
I realise this is a silly thought experiment but the point of comparison should be, at the very most, the human industry generated CO2, not all natural CO2. The CO2 from this particular process is probably more relevant and since this process generated 1 ton of Cl per ton of Steel and the normal process generated 3 tons of CO2, we should give it a 66% discount.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by Shrezzing on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @06:21AM (#39287175)
> I realise this is a silly thought experiment but the point of comparison should be, at the very most, the human industry generated CO2, not all natural CO2

The pre-industrial levels of CO2 were around 280ppm, while the current CO2 levels are around 440ppm.

For Cl2, in occupational-health situations the permissible exposure is around 1ppm per hour, or 3ppm for 15 minutes. So the 160ppm we'd throw into the atmosphere in this thought experiment (or even the 52ppm at the suggested discount) is going to cause some pretty big problems pretty rapidly.

Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by Workaccount2 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:10AM (#39289475)
Arguably the most deadly part of CO2 is that it kills sooooooo slowly. Vent CO2 and nobody blinks. Vent Cl and everyone is gonna hate you immediately for immediately present negatives.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by wolverine876 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:43PM (#39293257)
That's not the alternative option; nobody is suggesting swapping. Swapping CO2 for fission waste products would also kills us. Swapping it for H2O would drown us!
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by Tenemo on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:55PM (#39293411)
I think there's like 3 orders of magnitude more water in our atmosphere by weight than CO2, so a swap wouldn't drown us. But the point you were trying to make is clear.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by wolverine876 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:41PM (#39295323)
Yes, but as long as we're having some fun with the concept: The problem with CO2 isn't the absolute CO2 in the atmosphere; most(?) of it was already there. It's the changes caused by the added CO2.

The problem with H2O wouldn't be the absolute amount, but the changes brought on by the added H2O. For one thing, it would rain pretty much 24/7 in Florida. :) (Yes, I know it's not at all that predictable.)

Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by samus on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:44PM (#39295347)
It won't necessarily accumulate though - there's a reason it was quickly abandoned as a chemical weapon. I would rather worry about its compounds, as it would quickly react with anything it touches.
Re:Making steel without emitting CO2 by photochemsyn on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @01:13AM (#39285124)
You can avoid any CO2 production in the iron production process via replacing the natural gas inputs to the Direct Reduced Iron (DRI) method with hydrogen. To compare DRI with carbon vs only hydrogen:

with carbon and hydrogen from natural gas/coal gasification: CH4 + CO2 -> 2CO + 2H2 Fe2O3 + 3CO -> 2Fe + 3CO2 (exothermic in >50% H2 environment)

with water-sourced hydrogen: 2H2O -> O2 + 2H2 Fe2O3 + 3H2 -> 2Fe + 3H2O (endothermic, requires energy input)

There are two issues with using hydrogen, which can be overcome:

>"The energy balance of the shaft furnace is affected by the absence of the exothermic carbon monoxide reduction. . . Thus, it is necessary to add energy to the shaft furnace to carry heat in the burden."

>"The second issue is the resulting DRI carbon content; the DRI will have 0% carbon with pure hydrogen. The majority of DRI is used in EAFs, and EAF steelmaking practice generally employs carbon addition... Under current melting practices, it will be necessary to add hydrocarbons at some place in the process to achieve the desired carbon level... However, this added carbon will then be converted to CO2 in the EAF... Alternatively, carbon from a renewable source (like biomass) could be used."

https://www.midrex.com/tech-article/ultra-low-co2-ironmaking...