News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by smoothjazz on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @11:30AM (#39276365)
TikTok has been a very valuable tool for learning about Palestinians during Israel's attack on Gaza and the West Bank. It seems to be the only social network that's not being heavily censored in favor of Israel. I think it's never been more relevant than right now.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by resters on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @12:02PM (#39276939)
I urge people not to downvote the parent's comment out of political disagreement with the Palestinian cause.

There has been an outrageous amount of censorship of the Palestinian story in most of the US media, and frankly also a lack of nuanced explanation of the dominant Israeli perspective (which is far more nuanced than the typical American perspective).

In general, I recommend the following rules for propaganda hygeine:

- If someone uses the word "terrorist" or "terrorism", subtract a point of credibility. The word is an emotionally charged label that removes clarity.

- If someone refers to the desire of preserving "stability", subtract a point of credibility. This phrasing is typically used to mislead/misdirect.

- If you discover that important information (such as the charges brought before the ICJ) is being suppressed, subtract a point of credibility. Fairly important international law developments that ought to focus the discussion on concrete issues and considerations.

- If someone does not accept the label of apartheid as having a common literal meaning and insists that the word only applies to S. Africa, subtract a point of credibility. Things like Apartheid, ethnic cleansing, etc., are part of many nations' histories. It does not do any good to pretend that these things are impossible today.

There are very credible arguments in favor of both sides in the conflict, but increasingly people seem to believe that suppressing information is the best way to make the world a better place.

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by drstewart on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @12:11PM (#39277077)
>In general, I recommend the following rules for propaganda hygeine:

Here's another: if someone gives you a list of rules that are carefully crafted to only apply to those that are against their preferred narrative, subtract a point of credibility

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by resters on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @12:22PM (#39277290)
Point taken. It's a difficult issue indeed.

A few more:

- If both US political parties agree on it, it's probably a bad idea.

- Any time we are told that a foreign leader is insane or unstable, it's propaganda intended to dehumanize and discredit democratic forces in that country (even if the country is not a strict democracy).

- Logically, asymmetric conflict is going to necessitate different tactics. Don't fall for the idea that smart bombs are civilized but stones thrown are barbaric.

- Don't assume the US or its allies are the good guy. Countries make mistakes and rarely course-correct.

- The humanitarian justifications for war/conflict/killing are rarely the real story. Often there is a national interest-driven motivation, but but making it about a hard-to-disagree-with moral cause the debate about what is actually the national interest is suppressed.

- If someone tells you that it is disrespectful to question your own country or political leaders' competence or motivations, subtract several points. Democracy is a consensus mechanism, not a guarantee of consensus. Dissent is part of the recipe.

Please add more!

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by mrguyorama on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @12:37PM (#39277549)
>If both US political parties agree on it, it's probably a bad idea.

This is just such a childish take.

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by resters on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @01:19PM (#39278188)
> This is just such a childish take.

It certainly lacks eloquence compared to a tactic such as name calling...

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by dogman144 on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @11:47AM (#39276669)
To note - the platform’s content is steered for information operations shaped at the demographic of the scroller re: foreign policy goals from CN.

So what you’re seeing is a good content, but worth considering when you get shown policy-charged content - when and why is this in my feed.

Edit - or, to put it more simply, you should try to answer the second part of your comment - why is a state-sponsored social media company the only one showing me this right now?

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by basil-rash on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @12:10PM (#39277060)
To increase distrust of the US Government, especially when it comes to warmongering. Great alpha for the country sitting at the top of many DOD lists.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by rightbyte on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @03:06PM (#39279808)
That sounds like a cherible cause?

I think TikToks initial succes was mainly due to a "fair" feed with no algorithmic nudging.

Facebook used to be like that but somewhere around 2012 to 13 posts or articles could not go viral anymore, in the organic avalanche way it would earlier. Facebook wanted you to pay up for the reach I guess.

If TikTok nudge people they will lose their edge.

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by dogman144 on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @04:31PM (#39280934)
They’ve been nudging since 2019 at least and built an edge vs lost it.

There is a lot of politics around the TK bans but one true aspect is the Natsec angle. It’s as if FB’s newsfeed was optimized for patriotism, vs ads.

But bc TK pays well and Has a office in SV… blind eye. Blows my mind that westerners work there. There’s bad jingoism and then there’s considering your role in a global power struggle directly based on technology and these companies.

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by basil-rash on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:33AM (#39289008)
It’s a perfectly fine cause, entirely in line with what I’d expect from them.

Just as nudging their own youth into practicing guerrilla warfare techniques while nudging ours into questioning their gender is in line with what I’d expect from them.

To claim they don’t nudge is laughable.

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by smoothjazz on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @12:42PM (#39277627)
Whatever the platform's intent, the end result is that I get to see content that is censored on other platforms. If China's foreign policy goal is to help the Palestinians, then they're aligned with my views.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by dogman144 on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @04:39PM (#39281037)
Worth considering that’s not all they’ll steer at you, and considering if you’d know it was happening.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by smoothjazz on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @04:55PM (#39281251)
Whatever they're doing is super benign compared to the propaganda I'm exposed to day in and day out as a US citizen with nearly every media outlet working to influence me either commercially or jingoistically. A single media platform with a different point of view is healthy, especially when it will host content the other platforms censor.

Social networking hasn't influenced my point of view, but it has allowed me to access voices that I've always wanted to hear from, there was just no way to get to them before.

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by dogman144 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @12:06PM (#39304446)
There is a significant amount of research and public intelligence community discussion to indicate your points are incredibly misguided. Social networks have very likely influenced your point of view. Try spending a month off them and see if your views change, for instance.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by neuromanser on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @12:44PM (#39277646)
> what you’re seeing is a good content, but worth considering when you get shown policy-charged content - when and why is this in my feed.

That's always a worthy, necessary even, consideration.

> you should try to answer the second part of your comment - why is a state-sponsored social media company the only one showing me this right now?

You may be right in this specific case, and I tend to agree - though mostly out of lack of knowlege.

But I gotta object the insinuation that private media is somehow more reliable. Every outlet has an agenda. Al Jazeera English is by far the best journalistic TV I know (disclaimer, haven't watched in a few years). Funded by the government of Qatar…

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by dogman144 on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @04:34PM (#39280977)
Last part is a fair point - making no claims in reliability across other media.

Specifically just making a claim on if you vet reliability by national security/global politics topics that we all see playing out in the news, then it’s worth considering your specific role in it as a user or tech employee of TK.

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by pferde on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @11:49AM (#39276700)
There's plenty of that, possibly even more on Mastodon/Fediverse, you just have to go look for it and follow relevant people and/or hashtags.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by ok123456 on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @11:52AM (#39276756)
Nobody is on those except very online people. You might as well be saying that there's a lot of information about it on IRC and Gopher.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by timeon on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @12:19PM (#39277225)
> except very online people

While those glued to TikTok are very offline people.

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by ok123456 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:10AM (#39290254)
Virtually everyone on the planet knows what TikTok is. How much time online would you have to spend to know what Mastodon or Bluesky are?
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by pferde on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @02:57PM (#39279668)
What does "very online" mean? I thought being online was like being pregnant - you either are, or aren't.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by silveira on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @11:36AM (#39276461)
In my personal feed and algorithm, it was showing content from Gaza initially. I started following some of the victims and journalists. Then it stopped, not a single content from Gaza anymore.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by tokai on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @11:37AM (#39276474)
Are you sure that the people you followed are still alive?
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by PurpleRamen on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @12:09PM (#39277049)
The problem is, because they don't censor much, it's also a breeding ground for misinformation and fakes. It's really insane how fast low hate spreads on that platform because of some poor information or misconception, especially with more complex topics.
Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by justrealist on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @12:02PM (#39276935)
> TikTok has been a very valuable tool for learning about Palestinians during Israel's attack on Gaza and the West Bank.

> Israel's attack on Gaza and the West Bank.

This is true in more ways than you think.

Re:TikTok Is Destroying Itself from the Inside Out by AbrahamParangi on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @02:44PM (#39279507)
I think viewing virality optimized content as informative in a meaningful way on any social media platform is a road straight to hell, to be honest.