News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by sokoloff on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:40AM (#39263169)
Shocking that a “Scholastic Aptitude Test” or “American College Test” would predict future scholastic achievement at the collegiate level.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by magicalist on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:57PM (#39264273)
Yes, as a USA patriot, this is why I've always supported the USA PATRIOT Act. I don't get why anyone would bother looking into it.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by ryukoposting on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:57AM (#39263417)
I know. Being good at taking tests in high school is a positive indicator for being good at taking tests in college? A staggering discovery.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by zeroCalories on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:22PM (#39263744)
I don't know if you're trying to make a point about test taking, but you're aware that college GPA is composed of more than just being a good test taker? Better way of putting it might be: someone that scores highly on an IQ proxy is good at everything.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by asdff on Monday February 05, 2024 @04:50PM (#39267735)
The vast bulk of your GPA is due to testing. In major classes its pretty common to have your entire grade be from two or three exams. Increasingly in nonmajor classes they are weighing things like labs and assignments less and increasing the weight on exams. Especially in this era where you have to be at least a little suspicious of every submission you aren't in the room to see.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by ryukoposting on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:44PM (#39264067)
Not in my experience in the Big Ten. For any math/science class, the plurality of the final grade was made up by exam scores - typically 45-60 percent, to my recollection.

60ish percent is a very particular number, because it's the highest weight that doesn't make it possible to pass the class by doing almost nothing except the exams. At 65 percent, you're giving students an easy way to game the system.

Some classes had a substantial lab component, but it was relatively easy to score well on labs. Labs were graded by TAs, who were consistently more lax than the professor. I don't think there's some coordinated effort by TAs to lower the bar; they were simply too busy with their own studies to provide a thorough criticism of every lab report they received. In most classes, labs were effectively a curve.

English courses were different, since those had essays instead of exams. However, I'd argue that it's feasible to write a paper "to the rubric" in the same sense that one can shape their studies "to the test." Given the audience HN caters to, I'd imagine that we're more interested in the science/math/engineering stuff anyway.

Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by zeroCalories on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:02PM (#39264356)
Yes exams are heavily weighted, but labs/assignments are not usually easy in stem courses. You're delusional if you think that you're gonna get a 4.0 by half-assing course work, and even more delusional if you think someone like that will average over 90% on their exams. The SAT covers fairly basic topics that nearly every student should know, that's why it's like an IQ test. When I was in school freshmen would take it just to see what it was like, and many would score well on their first try.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by asdff on Monday February 05, 2024 @04:57PM (#39267803)
The labs at least are not designed to be challenging. They are designed to safely demonstrate some topic. I have been graded on yield and purity in chemistry before but it was only on a sliver of a percentage of the write up grade. Things can go sideways on you in lab all the time the last thing they want is for you to be worrying about that and dropping glassware full of chemistry. Lecture component was always the ugly beast that demanded all your focus. The lab, you show up, you do your writeup, you get a great grade on that section generally. If they have a lab specific exam at the end of the semester its a mole hill compared to the mountain of the chemistry lecture exam.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by zeroCalories on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:09PM (#39268496)
Well we definitely didn't have the same experience. Labs and course work often made up between 25%-50% of the grade. This has been the case in both undergrad and grad school at a top school. If you did sloppy work and got Bs all semester you weren't magically going to turn that into an A with some good exams, even if it was theoretically possible. The points definitely weren't free either.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by ryukoposting on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @02:23PM (#39361636)
Nothing you've said refutes my argument that exams are the most important component of a college GPA. Yes, homework can be hard, but it's rarely a plurality component of a final grade. Yes, labs can be a major component of a final grade, but they're rarely difficult enough to constitute anything more than a soft curve.

> You're delusional if you think that you're gonna get a 4.0 by half-assing course work

Nobody employing such a strategy was trying to get a 4.0 in the first place. In fact, setting the benchmark GPA for rigorous postsecondary education at 4.0 is itself delusional.

> The SAT covers fairly basic topics that nearly every student should know, that's why it's like an IQ test

Having taken two IQ tests administered by two different psychologists, I can confidently say no. The SAT does not resemble an actual IQ test. The SAT doesn't test short-term memory, and it only indirectly tests associative thinking.

That said, there's probably a correlation with IQ test scores, because smart people are smart, and so they perform well at tasks designed to test intelligence... just like how being good at taking tests in high school, means you'll probably be pretty good at it in college too.

Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by thfuran on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:33AM (#39289014)
So you think performance at each of those other things is negatively correlated with test performance?
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by doctorwho42 on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:23PM (#39263747)
I would argue that it is even more so in college, where tests make up the bulk of your grade.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by NegativeK on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:46AM (#39263258)
Those are marketing terms, though.

It's not trivial to go from performance on a single test to performance throughout the year, which will include long-form writing, lab work, and other forms of learning.

Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by tomtheelder on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:59AM (#39263447)
SAT/ACT for high achieving students means months of prep/studying and practice test taking. It ends up being a ~somewhat~ similar experience to a college class. Not really similar to humanities classes that depend on discussion section and papers, but if you squint enough it kind of looks like some STEM classes.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by grdgyredb on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:19PM (#39263702)
You are right it’s not trivial, but on the other hand if you simply try to make such a test you’d do better than completely uncorrelated pretty easily I’d suppose.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by sokoloff on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:21PM (#39263725)
SAT has has been around almost 100 years and ACT around 2/3 of that, so they've had pretty long to hone the tests as well. This is far from their first stab at it.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by grdgyredb on Monday February 05, 2024 @09:42PM (#39270142)
And indeed they seem to have produced a test that is correlated with success.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by sokoloff on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @03:53PM (#39280433)
Absolutely! Some people seem to find that correlation to be inconvenient and/or threatening.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by bigbillheck on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:47AM (#39263273)
You can't wish nominative determinism into being.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by Scubabear68 on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:26PM (#39264770)
I know. Sarcasm aside though, there is a growing movement of HS and elementary school teachers looking to remove all KPIs from schools. It is very worrying that this protected class of workers are arguing they are special compared to every other problem in the world and their performance and those who they are teaching should never be measured.
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by asdff on Monday February 05, 2024 @04:46PM (#39267693)
Except that the test is pretty clearly perverted. You take two kids, same education, give one an after school testing program their parents pay money for, and they score better. Is the wealthier kid more worthy of receiving a college education? What does that say about how we educate our society then, and what we are actually valuing and giving privilege?
Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by closeparen on Monday February 05, 2024 @05:54PM (#39268355)
They score very slightly better, not really meaningfully.

https://slate.com/technology/2019/04/sat-prep-courses-do-the...

Re:SAT (and ACT) scores are highly predictive of academic ac... by hirvi74 on Monday February 05, 2024 @09:05PM (#39269887)
> Is the wealthier kid more worthy of receiving a college education?

Not to mention, what about us test-disabled people?

I didn't know I had ADHD and its "friends" when I took the ACT, and I could have potentially benefited greatly from the reasonable accommodations the test allows for. However, it's not like every child is required to have some kind of psychological evaluation while in school.

I find all of this standardization in testing to be nothing more than Goodhart's Law in full swing.

Just what we need, more "Teaching to the Test" and route memorization in our education system...