News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by nonrandomstring on Sunday February 04, 2024 @02:03PM (#39253247)
It was never "scientifically sound" for reasons of unfalsifiability.

Was it ever a useful tool? Here and there maybe.

Has it had a massive infuence on culture and the world? Absolutely.

So I was chatting with a clinical psych/therapist recently who said "Since it could only be validated from the _inside_ wouldn't it be hilarious if advances in AI validated Freud?" Like GPT10 comes on and says " I want to kill my father and fuck mum, pass me the cocaine!"

Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by wolverine876 on Sunday February 04, 2024 @03:24PM (#39254039)
> Was it ever a useful tool? Here and there maybe.

What makes you quantify it like that? I'm not sure I could quantify it, but it's certainly been used, directly and indirectly, extraordinarily widely.

Re:Psychology, a Failed Discipline: Flawed Paradigms, Method... by nonrandomstring on Sunday February 04, 2024 @04:12PM (#39254537)
Other than that I lived in Hampstead momentarily, Freud only appears to me as side effects. My psycho-friends, as I call them, are all into Bowlby and Winnicott and whatnot. And I did a study on Bernays in some military work. Wherever you look, there's Freud. No escaping the chap.