News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by throwawayfans on Saturday February 03, 2024 @02:31PM (#39243890)
Throw away account for obvious reasons.

My wife and I run an onlyfans account, a manyvids account and a few other related accounts. I can tell you from extensive networking with other onlyfans creators the number of them using chatters is pretty small, probably less than 1%. I personally have never interacted with someone that uses them. I also run a discord and telegram support server for creators so I interact with a lot, but certainly have not made any kind of scientific measure.

Some higher tier models use agencies to run their stuff and that's usually where the chatters come into play.

The general consensus is to avoid agencies or managers for obvious reasons.

While I personally think it's kind of shady, I very much doubt it's illegal, but ianal. There is one fans platform that I know of that has integrated AI chat bots so shrug

Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by starkparker on Saturday February 03, 2024 @02:43PM (#39244010)
> Some higher tier models use agencies to run their stuff and that's usually where the chatters come into play.

If this suit is real then I think that's who it's targeting anyway, since that's where the money is.

The whole thing seems spurred on by the WaPo article from November about Bryce and Brian Adams, which opens with their $120,000 driveway and piles on the mentions of how much money they make from there. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/interactive/2023/o...

> but ianal

Cheeky.

Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by nickthegreek on Saturday February 03, 2024 @02:51PM (#39244093)
My anecdotal evidence is the opposite. One couple I know, the male does a lot of the botting for his partner. One of my aging model friends switched from having an OF to running other girls. 3rd model friend use to employ their friend to run around 60% of their operation but the quality suffered a bit and the lost a whale. I recently did a little demo for a friend on how ChatGPT could be used to create Twitter copy for various market types to push OF.
Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by gavinray on Saturday February 03, 2024 @06:06PM (#39245692)
My experience similarly points to partners or paid acquaintances doing a lot of ghost-chatting.
Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by almatabata on Saturday February 03, 2024 @03:00PM (#39244177)
> While I personally think it's kind of shady, I very much doubt it's illegal, but ianal.

If they disclose that the fan interacts with a bot or a random employee its probably legal. Its the fact that they are not disclosing it that smells illegal to me. I do not know if its closer to false advertising or to fraud.

Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by redsoundbanner on Saturday February 03, 2024 @03:10PM (#39244244)
>I can tell you from extensive networking with other onlyfans creators the number of them using chatters is pretty small, probably less than 1%

1. Why would anybody believe you?

2. Why would you believe other "creators"?

3. What is the percentage of customers and/or revenue generated by the 1% of "creators" using Chatters?

Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by HeatrayEnjoyer on Saturday February 03, 2024 @03:23PM (#39244378)
For #1 and #2, what reason is there to doubt them? I have a couple of friends doing OF/SW and this isn't incongruent with their experience or what gets discussed in the community. I generally trust what people say in communities of people in the same domain sphere (i.e. discussion on HN about which software platforms are easier or harder to implement).

Most people don't subcontract their job either, even if it could increase their overall income.

Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by prepend on Saturday February 03, 2024 @06:18PM (#39245782)
The same reason there is to doubt anything a stranger says on the internet. People have egos and sometimes tell lies to inflate their egos.

I generally distrust anything people say in communities that supports some personal cause (ie positive comments about their employer, or negative comments about their enemy, etc)

Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by HeatrayEnjoyer on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:46AM (#39260174)
That didn't really answer my question.

Misanthropic attitudes are not useful or actionable.

Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by breakfastduck on Saturday February 03, 2024 @02:42PM (#39244005)
> probably less than 1%

Probably a significant overlap with the 1% of the highest earning creators though, I'd bet.

Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by jokethrowaway on Saturday February 03, 2024 @03:16PM (#39244302)
Plenty of average models use OF agencies. They're quite prevalent! Maybe your circle is more random people hacking it on their own and doing it as a side gig but they move little money and little followers.

It's a simple model for agencies:

1. Get broke girls to produce photos and videos

2. Post some content to free account

3. Post some more content to paid account

4. Post some teasers on reddit nsfw subreddits

5. Get 3rd worlders as chatters to upsell some of the content

6. Ask girls for the occasional custom request

Re:OnlyFans Paid Chatters Lawsuit by redder23 on Saturday February 03, 2024 @03:21PM (#39244357)
I do NOT take your word for it, in fact, I am calling total BS on your 1% number. You and the people you interacted with may not do it, or tell you they don't, that does not prove any 1% number whatsoever. It's a common practice, especially for the immoral people who do OF to extract as much money from people they detest as many vapid OF models do. And the higher their earnings and chats go, the more they get overwhelmed by the volumes of incoming messages, so if they have not done it already they are more likely to get into paying chatters when the demand raises.

I would never ever pay even 1 cent for any porn and I think people who are doing this are sad and lonely and pathetic and think they get anything from "chatting" with some OF girl. I would feel so pathetic doing that, in fact to me, it would not even matter that much if it's some guy in Bangladesh or the real girl, it amounts to the same waste of money.

I support this effort anyway because it is legal fraud what they are doing.

OF owner is a jew who donates to Israels effort to massacre even more Palestinians, btw. What a shocker. It's like immoral on multiple levels. Porn is not very healthy on its own but what OF does is it fakes a social and emotional connection that does not exist, that makes it 100x worse than just jerking off to free porn, closing it and moving on with your day. OF is immoral without chatters, they just make it worse.

Even if the percentage of people who do it be low, the really hot, successful and popular girls are the ones that are taking in the millions while the average girl on OF makes below $100 a month I believe. So you need to look at the CONSUMER numbers, not the creator numbers. The consumers are the ones being defrauded by these high level girls that have millions of subs!