News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by foxmoss on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:10PM (#39197265)
It's odd ICANN has such a control to effect an countries income just by choosing a good abbreviation. I doubt the creators of the DNS system had any idea that domains would arbitrarily give some countries an extra form of income, profiting from people who could care less about the country it was created for. Why didn't ICANN just charge a flat fee for any string to resolve to an IP?
Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by wolfgang42 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @07:10PM (#39197896)
The whole point of the ccTLDs is that ICANN doesn’t really have any control over their contents—they’re “sovereign soil”, so to speak, and each country can do whatever it wants with its namespace. Which brings us to the answer to your question:

> Why didn't ICANN just charge a flat fee for any string to resolve to an IP?

Because ICANN doesn’t control what strings resolve! They delegate to registries (by putting NS records in the root resolvers), and for ccTLDs it’s up to each country to set policy and infrastructure to taste. If anything, the existence of gTLDs (like .com) where policy is set internationally is the unusual aspect of this arrangement.

Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by Spray3610 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:16PM (#39197338)
ICANN does not pick the abbreviations. ISO does.
Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by actionfromafar on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:33PM (#39197516)
It's odd ISO has such a control to effect an countries income just by choosing a good abbreviation. I doubt the creators of the DNS system had any idea that domains would arbitrarily give some countries an extra form of income, profiting from people who could care less about the country it was created for. Why didn't ISO just charge a flat fee for any string to resolve to an IP?
Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by dharmab on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:41PM (#39197608)
ISO created the country codes in 1974, prior to the invention of DNS.
Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by feelandcoffee on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @07:10PM (#39197898)
It's odd Time has such a control to effect an countries income just by choosing a good abbreviation. I doubt the creators of the DNS system had any idea that domains would arbitrarily give some countries an extra form of income, profiting from people who could care less about the country it was created for. Why didn't ISO just charge a flat fee for any string to resolve to an IP?
Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by actionfromafar on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:43PM (#39197637)
Haha, this is both informative and deadpan. Thanks. :)
Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by reactordev on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @07:08PM (#39197875)
This is what tech debt looks like when it’s middle aged and has kids of its own.
Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by pcthrowaway on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:44PM (#39200038)
Surely some of these country codes have come about after the dawn of DNS.

I wonder if we'll see newly formed countries angling for names that will get valuable abbreviations

Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by sdsd on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:55PM (#39197743)
i get why people are downvoting this, because it is snarky, but i laughed so hard. so thanks for posting this, despite the hit to your internet points
Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by srhngpr on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:22PM (#39197400)
Re:.ai website registrations are a windfallf for tiny Anguilla by 8organicbits on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @10:45PM (#39199587)
Think about the original TLDs, there was value in separating commercial, military, and government content. Unfortunately .gov is US government only and .mil is US military only. So each country would presumably want a .gov.[country-code] and .mil.[country-code] suffixes for those same reasons (and many do).

Opening up registration for non-citizens / non-residents is an option each country has. Some restrict registration more than others.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Internet_top-level_d...

There's also an important angle that countries can set the terms of service for their ccTLD to match their laws. It's one way to ensure a country has some legislative and enforcement ability over their corner of the web.