Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr
by evbogue on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @05:17PM
(#39196664)
Bitcoin uses secp256k1, Nostr uses secp256k1. I was surprised as anyone to learn that when you exchange money using Nostr clients it is not directed at the private key that you use to sign Nostr messages.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr
by crotchfire on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @05:49PM
(#39197029)
I'm surprised by this too.
Bitcoin was developed just barely before ed25519 was finalized, which is probably why it uses secp256k1. Unless intended mainly for government users (FIPS), almost every new cryptographic system uses ed25519 -- except Nostr.
I always assumed Nostr chose secp256k1 so you could send bitcoin to another Nostr user without some extra "payment address request protocol" bolted on the side. Very surprising that this was not the motivation!
Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr
by RIMR on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @05:37PM
(#39196896)
I cannot say that I am surprised at all to learn that you were sending and receiving Sats over the LN with zero understanding of what keys were actually associated with your funds. This is exactly the level literacy I expect to see of anyone dealing in cryptocurrency.
Is there a reason to think that two different keys for two different protocols are actually the same key just because they use the same ECDSA? Not if you possess even a modicum of understanding of cryptography, but I digress, we are talking about Bitcoiners after all.