News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by ecf on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @05:12PM (#39196592)
Nostr is everything that fediverse social networks claim to be, but aren’t.

I was shocked to find out that the Lemmy instance I signed up on was blocking dozens upon dozens of other instances, which defeats the entire purpose of a federated network.

Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by AlphaCerium on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @05:18PM (#39196674)
Then switch to a different one, the point of a federated network is that anyone is able to talk to anyone, not that they have to.
Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by iteratethis on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @07:25PM (#39198022)
In which case the point is useless. It's a pie in the sky statement.

Fediverse instances being too trigger-happy in blocking other instances means the network as whole is less open in comparison to a centralized social network. So, why bother? You have little to no control over whom you can connect to.

Also, "switching" is an alien concept to normal social media users. You never have to "switch" and you never lose your content or followers, exceptions aside when you get yourself into serious trouble.

Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by ecf on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @05:36PM (#39196876)
You must realize that the moment you say “just switch to another” you’ve lost 99% of your potential user base.

It took me signing up for Lemmy to realize why Lemmy is still a completely dead network.

Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by noman-land on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:32PM (#39197503)
Decentralization/federation is not about "potential user base". It's about diffusion of control. People need to learn to fish because the SaaS model is a precarious foundation to build a culture on.

We are having this conversation in a more mainstream way now because more people found out how precarious their online cultural foundations are. Your Facebooks and Reddits and Twitters will get ruined by changes of ownership or on the whim of billionaires. You data will be sold out from under you. You will be squeezed for every penny.

The point is to either host your own instance, or use the instance of someone you trust and/or whose moderation policy you align with. It's not to amass a large user base and watch your charts go up.

Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by account42 on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @05:20AM (#39202073)
> The point is to either host your own instance, or use the instance of someone you trust and/or whose moderation policy you align with.

This should be the goal but will never happen with an activity-pub-based fediverse. It just doesn't scale to everyone or even every small group having their own instances because. Current fediverse software is also too complicated and too resource hungry for even most technically inclined people to self host.

You really need a better foundation that is designed for efficient communication between millions of hosts from the start.

Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by noman-land on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:00PM (#39323453)
It's a step in the right direction towards diffusion of control. The corporate, SaaS alternatives are untenable. Full stop.
Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by account42 on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @05:14AM (#39202041)
Except once instances block other instances for not going along with their blocks. Then you really cannot talk to anyone from a single idenity. This makes the whole system not much better than a bunch of independent sites.

Then there is the fact that you once you choose an instance your identity is bound to that instance. Why would anyone invest in such a dead end network.

Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by RIMR on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @05:26PM (#39196769)
This is a strawman argument. The biggest advocateds of federated social media are not promising a fully decentralized and censorship-proof network. Federation is built on trust, and blocking untrustworthy instances is a critical function of any open federated system.

There is another side of the Fediverse that operates on the principles you are talking about (eg. Poast, Baest, Spinster, Gleasonator, NoAgendaSocial, NicecrewDigital, et al). That part of the Fediverse, like Nostr, is covered in Lolicon, gore, and Nazi memes because that's the userbase you get when you promise that nobody can stop you from posting whatever you want.

More and more I am learning that the people who desire censorship-free social spaces are the kind of people that others rightfully exclude from polite social spaces, because these are people who lack respect and want to say and do horrible things without opposition.

Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by ecf on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:12PM (#39197302)
If you think only untrustworthy instances are being blocked then I really don’t want to debate about Lemmy with you.
Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by rakoo on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:35PM (#39197535)
By definition, an instance will only block instances it doesn't trust, so yes, only untrustworthy instances are blocked by an instance that doesn't trust them

The mistake is believing that all instances behave the same and block the same. The whole point of federation is that every instance chooses who it wants to block.

Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by iteratethis on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @07:27PM (#39198041)
That's not how it works at all. Admins pressure other admins in apply the same blocks, or risk getting defederated. The entire thing is ran by power hungry bullies.
Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by NortySpock on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @09:29PM (#39199026)
Sure, but at least this time it's more than one power-hungry moderator. In the forums of the 90s, if a forum moderator banned you from the server in the middle of a flamewar, that was it.

Now at least there could be (in theory) regional blocs of federated servers that share content. I heard some people are proposing a common account interchange format, so you could migrate accounts? (not being in the fediverse yet, I don't really know...)

Re:Gitstr: Send and receive Git patches over Nostr by rakoo on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @06:09AM (#39202406)
That's not how it works at all (see, I can do exactly the same).

1) I, as an admin, have never been pressured by anyone to do anything and can federate with whoever I want. Thousands of instances are the same. The only ones who are pressured are the biggest ones, who also happen to host the worst content (xenophobic, racist, gore, pedo content).

2) You are not owed an audience. Not everyone wants to ear what you have to say. Moderation at scale needs to happen if we want marginalized communities to thrive, and unfortunately since the internet is mostly hostile to those the most efficient way to do this is to block. But if you're not ok with the blocking policy of your instance, change it. That's the whole point of federation. You'd do the same with Nostr: you disconnect from a relay if you don't like what comes from them, connect to another one, except with Nostr you can't totally be sure the bad content will be filtered out.