News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by ethanbond on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:21AM (#39191948)
IMO traffic violations should be punished way, way, way more severely than they are. In the US, licenses do need to be easy to get otherwise you lock people out of society (unfortunately), but they don't need to be easy to keep and you should drive with constant awareness that you will be taken to the cleaners for mishaps.

Automated enforcement tech should be widespread and incur license revocations and salary/wealth-adjusted fines left and right.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by giantg2 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:27AM (#39192034)
"licenses do need to be easy to get"

This is what allows the situation we have. People either don't get caught, or only get caught after injury has occurred.

"traffic violations should be punished way, way, way more severely than they are."

It depends on the infection. Many are already severe, such as being arrested for racing, going 25+ over the limit, DUI, etc. DUI is a factor in about a 3rd of fatalities and is already punished severely. Seems like the punishment focus isn't working. The preemptive education portion is more promising.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by acdha on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:49AM (#39192331)
If education worked, we wouldn’t see stats going up contrary to the rest of the world. The problem is that enforcement has declined radically and drivers have learned that there will be basically no consequences for anything short of a fatality and often even then it’ll be minimal.

One of the big problems is that the early signals are ignored: the guy saying the dead pedestrian “jumped in front” of his truck now almost always has a history of things like speeding and signal tickets, parking violations, etc. but as long as that doesn’t interfere with their ability to drive, they’re just being trained not to treat it seriously.

What I’d like to see is a progressive escalation of natural consequences: more than one speeding or light ticket in a year and you can’t keep your license without showing that your car has a speed/acceleration governor installed, more than a few in a year and your license is suspended for a month, etc. The focus should not be on money but reinforcing the idea that driving is dangerous and if you refuse to be safe you will lose that privilege.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @12:02PM (#39192560)
China has 10x the road traffic fatalities per capita than we do. People ask if China is safe, and...they never really look at traffic fatalities numbers which are way more significant than getting stabbed to death by some guy at a drum tower. Beijing is the only place I saw someone die before (bicycle ran a red light, taxi was speeding through the intersection at a yellow light, its weird how everything goes at slow motion at the point).

I've actually had pedestrians jump in front of me before at green lights in North Seattle on Aurora, which is famous for traffic fatalities. In this case, the problem aren't bad drivers, but fentanyl. Sometimes the pedestrians really are at fault. Also, we design our streets like ass; e.g. encouraging pedestrian and car traffic at the same time along with ample pedestrian-obscuring on-street parking (you really can't have both!). In this case, yes, the cars need to do the right thing, but that's made difficult enough that tragedies occur way too often. We need to get the Dutch to teach us how its done.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by giantg2 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @12:21PM (#39192850)
Pedestrian fatalities in the US involve alcohol about 50% of the time by at least one party. 38% of pedestrians killed have BACs over .08.
Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by s1artibartfast on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:19PM (#39194369)
Similarly, 16% of pedestrian fatalities were on freeways. 59% were on non-freeway arterials, while 22% were on local streets.

It seems like individual pedestrian can do quite a bit of risk mitigation by staying sober and out of traffic.

These stats match my anecdotal experience where I have had numerous close calls as a driver due to pedestrians where they shouldn't be (eg people on the freeway), but no close calls while walking sober on Surface streets.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @12:24PM (#39192902)
I wonder if they have tracked fentanyl yet? It seems like the numbers would evolve just substituting one substance for another.
Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by giantg2 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:59AM (#39192496)
"If education worked, we wouldn’t see stats going up contrary to the rest of the world."

This isn't really true. Most other developed nations have much stricter licensing with much lower fatality rates.

Yes, enforcement is definitely an issue too. Progress penalties and fines tied to income levels (or vehicle values) would be a good start.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by acdha on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:35PM (#39193841)
It is really true. There are various causes being debated but we’re the only rich country where the fatality rate is moving in the wrong direction:

https://static01.nyt.com/images/2023/12/10/briefing/oakImage...

The source article covers why some of the theories can’t explain the difference on their own:

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/11/briefing/us-traffic-death...

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by giantg2 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:54PM (#39194826)
I can't read your pay walled article.

"It is really true. There are various causes being debated but we’re the only rich country where the fatality rate is moving in the wrong direction:"

I'm not sure we're on the same page with what I'm taking issue with. The requirements to get a license are a joke in the US. The other nations with lower fatalities have stricter licensing. Yes, it won't explain it on it's own, but it is highly correlated and supported by studies around stricter licensing in other nations and graduated licensing in the US.

But your claim that if education worked the stats wouldn't be going up has no basis in anything you've posted. The overall licensing has not improved in the US. The jurisdictions in your chart have much stricter requirements.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by acdha on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @08:23PM (#39198508)
The graph is not paywalled, and that’s really most of it. You can use IA for the rest:

https://web.archive.org/web/20231211115919/https://www.nytim...

The general point, however, is simple: neither the US nor our peer countries significantly changed licensing requirements in the last 10-20 years. We didn’t suddenly stop doing public safety campaigns, either, but the United States is the only country where the fatality rate suddenly started going back up. The licensing hypothesis could explain why our numbers are higher in absolute terms but not that stark, sudden increase in legality – even if we made the license exams much easier in the mid-2010s, that wouldn’t affect the majority of drivers who already had their licenses by then.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by cooper_ganglia on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:50AM (#39192336)
DUIs are not punished nearly severely enough. I used to work with an alcoholic who had been arrested multiple times, for all sorts of things: Fighting, property damage, indecent exposure, racing, going +100 MPH on a suspended license, etc.

He was arrested for his 4th DUI and was upset because, according to him, he "got the book thrown at him". His sentence? 6 months in county jail, with 5 days per week of work leave. He only spent evenings and weekends at the jail. A few months in, he faked some letterhead for a landscaping company and sent a letter to the judge, claiming to be the company, saying they just hired him and they were requesting a 6th day of work leave. The judge allowed it, so now this guy would just leave jail on Saturday morning and hang out with his elderly parents all day.

He saved money while in jail because he would work all week and then sleep at the jail, so he had no rent to pay. He was arrested for his FOURTH DUI, and came out financially better than when he went in. He was practically rewarded for it.

In my opinion, a DUI should mean 5 years in prison with no possibility for a shortened sentence, your second DUI gets you 10 years, and your third is an instant life-sentence. I've had too many people in my life killed or paralyzed by inebriated drivers. I have literally not one single drop of empathy for anyone who drinks and then gets behind the wheel. In the case of an accident, I think it's actually immoral that they are provided any level of medical care at all. If they caused the injury or death of someone else on the road, leave them in the ditch to crawl out themselves. Let them take accountability for their actions, because obviously 6-months in county jail isn't fixing the problem.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by giantg2 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:56AM (#39192458)
Some states are more strict than other. That seems extremely lenient. They are generally misdemeanors or felonies that would cause many people to lose their jobs. Your part about faking work release is really a separate issue - did you report them?

Most states will not issue you a license if you have multiple DUIs. So he should have been on a suspended license, which should have drastically increased the penalty in most states. It seems the judge may have been ignoring sentencing guidelines if it was so lenient.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by cooper_ganglia on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @12:47PM (#39193201)
When he was arrested for his 4th DUI, his license had been suspended. Because of this, his dad bought him a car so he could get around (doesn't make sense to me either, haha). So he had a suspended license, no insurance, he was drunk, and driving 100+ MPH down an empty country road when he was arrested. I know all this because I bought his car from his mom, and I'd drive him to work from the jail on Mondays and Tuesdays and he'd complain about how unfair his life was.

But therein lies the problem. It shouldn't be up to a judge's opinion on how much time someone with a DUI should receive. Just make it a flat 5-year sentence across the board so we don't have to worry about how the judge felt that day.

I don't see the work release issue as a separate issue. People with DUIs should have no single recourse of action to leave state custody until their sentencing is complete. You've proven you're a danger to society, it would be irresponsible to toss you right back in. There should be no work release, no reduced sentence, nothing like that. If you voluntarily risk the lives of others on the road, you give up 5 years of your own life if you're caught. I think that's exceedingly fair.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by giantg2 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:09PM (#39193504)
"There should be no work release,"

I would say that about half of the people in county who had a job and didn't lose it get work release. That's not specific to DUI.

My main point is he provided fake documents about landscaping. That should have been reported.

"If you voluntarily risk the lives of others on the road, you give up 5 years of your own life if you're caught. I think that's exceedingly fair."

I think the system most states have in place is fair today - usually one diversionary program with probation, fine/costs, interlock, etc if nobody was hurt and there was no property damage. Penalty tiers based on BAC level. Progressive sentencing based on details like not your first time, someone got hurt, property damage, etc.

Plenty of things depend on the outcome for the severity of the punishment. I do think that is fair to increase penalties based on the circumstances and results. What we really need is better education. Although stricter penalties or education aren't going to help people like the guy you say thinks his life is unfair. Perhaps rehab as his attitude sounds like an alcoholic.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by cooper_ganglia on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @06:20PM (#39197387)
These are fair points, but I personally still want more punishment. I'll admit I probably don't have the clearest mindset when considering these things either, because I've had too many people around me injured, paralyzed, or killed because of drunk drivers. I'm at the point where I am literally incapable of feeling any level of empathy for anyone who voluntarily drinks and then gets behind the wheel because of how much it's affected my life, directly and indirectly.

My grandparents, my high school girlfriend, another girlfriend just a couple years ago, my best friend's brother, a coworker, 2 great uncles... All people in my life who were either injured or killed by a drunk driver. Hell, one of my uncles was literally run over outside of his car by a drunk driver. He survived but lost his leg, and he couldn't ever breathe right after the accident...

That's not to mention all the indirect drunk-driving deaths that I've dealt with via mourning friends and family. It's very difficult not to be incredibly calloused at something that is so, so destructive and yet so, so easy to prevent. Like, literally if you had just called an Uber my friend would still be alive, I'm sure glad that you saved $20!

...Y'know? No easy answers, at this point I'm just venting a little bit. :) Thanks for the response and for reading my spiel!

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by torstenvl on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @12:42PM (#39193143)
Going 15mph over is a crime in a lot of states (like NC), which is bonkers.

By contrast, DUI is not nearly severe enough. It should only be a misdemeanor if it's <= .10. Anything over .10 should be a felony.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by giantg2 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @12:59PM (#39193358)
In my mind, just increasing penalties will have little effect (except excluding more people from society adding an overall drag). They need to do better at educating to avoid it.
Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by ethanbond on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:04PM (#39193429)
What on earth does "educating" mean in this context?

Do people not know how to read a speedometer? Do they not know how to read a speed limit sign?

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by giantg2 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:14PM (#39193562)
I'm talking mostly about DUI. But yes, even with speed limits. A stricter licensing program with better education could fix a lot of the issues. Most people don't understand vehicle dynamics. If they had some basic understanding about stuff like 2x speed is 4x stopping distance, it might wake them up. Most drivers do risky things without realizing they are risky because they are so ignorant, even when following the speed limit. Many other developed nations have lower fatalities and stricter licensing (even when speeds are unrestricted like the autobahn).
Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by jahewson on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:26AM (#39192010)
License revocations are only effective for people who respect rules.
Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by ethanbond on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:50AM (#39192342)
There are tons of "minor" infractions committed by people who see themselves as perfectly responsible and law-abiding. And they are to the degree that they wouldn't drive without a license and would be legitimately deterred by that threat, but they just view various infractions as a normal part of driving (because they are, as our enforcement schemes make clear!)
Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by acdha on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:51AM (#39192362)
Or who fear consequences. That means enforcement has to be effective enough that people know there’s a high risk of consequences - for example, if driving on a suspended license means your car is sold at auction, people will care a lot more about following safety rules.
Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by lesuorac on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:23PM (#39194423)
Meh, having a suspended license doesn't actually stop you from being able to drive.

Both physically you don't have to swipe in to drive but also legally you can still drive [1].

[1]: https://www.graciamintz.com/blog/2021/march/how-to-get-a-har...

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by marcosdumay on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @12:05PM (#39192596)
That won't get you anywhere. If you require cars, you'll get misbehaving cars, as they come in no other format.

What fixes this is creating collective transportation. Multimodal and capillary transportation options that people can use. And after that, you just phase cars outside of the city.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by ethanbond on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:04PM (#39193436)
Obviously not true. There are gradations of strictness in driving behavior. Driving in Germany, for example, is a totally totally different experience from anywhere in the US.
Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by ultrarunner on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:46AM (#39192291)
> licenses do need to be easy to get

Only if society continues to be centered around cars.

Re:Safetyism Killed Playtime by ethanbond on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @11:48AM (#39192310)
Yep, but if we can change that then the problem as a whole gets mitigated quite a lot.