News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by Sniffnoy on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:20PM (#39181066)
> The theory, which Romeo relied on partly to guide his search, suggests that when Earhart crossed over the international dateline during her 20-hour flight, her navigation system became inaccurate and misdirected her by about 60 miles, potentially leading to a tragic end.

How would this happen? It's not like her plane would have contained a misprogrammed computer.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by jameshart on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:06PM (#39181740)
Journalistic misinterpretation of what an expert told them leading them to write something dumb.

Earhart’s “navigation system” was Fred Noonan, an almanac, and a chronometer.

Fred looking on the wrong page of the Almanack because he forgot which side of the dateline they were going to be on is what’s implied here.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by wolverine876 on Monday January 29, 2024 @05:16PM (#39183512)
'Navigation system' could be paper, maps, compass, etc. It's modern bias to assume that means 'computer' or 'electronic'.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by pests on Monday January 29, 2024 @09:27PM (#39185695)
Exactly. Just like I have an organization system for my clothes. That doesn't mean I have a computer controlled robot organizing my clothes. It just means socks go in the top left drawer.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by jameshart on Monday January 29, 2024 @10:07PM (#39185955)
Right, but if a reporter is trying to write a story why all your t-shirts turned pink, and after you explain that system to them, they write:

"When the clocks went back at the end of daylight savings, pests' organization system became inaccurate and misdirected a red sock into the whites wash,"

... they might have misunderstood what you were trying to say. They certainly aren't doing a good job of explaining to their reader how your clothing organization system works.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by wolverine876 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:33AM (#39187331)
What evidence is there for your accusation against the journalist? I don't see any at all but your personal interpretation of 'system' (which many disagree with) and your personal imagination of how it got into the article.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by jameshart on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @07:24AM (#39189272)
Call it ‘Gell Mann Lucidity’ - the experience of having seen reporters make mistakes before and remembering to apply that knowledge to critical reading of news stories. The opposite of Gell Mann Amnesia.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by wolverine876 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:19PM (#39194379)
Notice that's just fabrication, and for the same reasons people have always fabricated things - their preconceived notions, their prejudices, etc.

There's a reason that rationality depends on evidence, and that is applied so strictly in science, law, and reporting. What would you say about a reporter who made claims like yours?

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by jameshart on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @04:42PM (#39196279)
Allow me to carry you back to the top of this thread, to a post made by a presumably reasonably well educated member of the Hacker News community, in reaction to this article on the professionally written and edited, reputable website, businessinsider.com.

That user wrote:

> > The theory, which Romeo relied on partly to guide his search, suggests that when Earhart crossed over the international dateline during her 20-hour flight, her navigation system became inaccurate and misdirected her by about 60 miles, potentially leading to a tragic end.

> How would this happen? It's not like her plane would have contained a misprogrammed computer.

So you see, what we have here is a sentence written by a journalist and published by their editor, which says “her navigation system became inaccurate and misdirected her”; juxtaposed with evidence of a reader being confused and trying to work out what the writer was talking about, because the implied technical failure mode seemed anachronistic for Amelia Earhart’s era of flight. Because the way that sentence is phrased certainly sounds like the kind of sentence one would write to describe an automatic system failing when taken outside its design limits, like a millennium bug type of error.

You seem to be suggesting that the only fault here lies with the reader, who should have understood that by ‘navigation system became inaccurate’ the writer expected them to understand that to mean the processes and procedures followed by the crew suddenly stopping working when crossing the dateline - since obviously that would be the sort of ‘navigation system’ used.

That’s a wonderfully generous position to take but I’m sorry it doesn’t pass the sniff test for me. The ‘navigation system’ Earhart was using couldn’t ’become inaccurate’ when crossing the dateline. It could be misapplied; human error could lead to it producing inaccurate results; but the system (looking up celestial ephemera in a book then doing math) was valid and worked.

Writing that the system ‘became inaccurate’ when crossing the dateline communicates to me that the writer misunderstood the system being used as being one which could systematically fail under those circumstances. Such misunderstandings are common! It’s understandable! Writers are reliant on interpreting expert quotes and rephrasing them, dumbing them down, or occasionally adding their own interpolation! It is one of the most common error types you will see in journalism about topics you understand well to see a journalist extrapolate from what they were told and say something completely wrong.

If the writer had understood the dateline theory more thoroughly they would likely have written that Earhart’s navigator made an error in accounting for crossing the dateline, rather than attributing the error to ‘the system’. There was a human being in the plane! You don’t need to ascribe the fault to the weakly passive ‘system became inaccurate’ source. Someone who understood that would not write this sentence in that way.

My attribution of the error here to the reporter is an application of Occam’s razor. The expert sources who found the sonar echo of a plane in the pacific definitely know how Earhart navigated. The reader who was confused on HN when reading something that implied a ‘systemic’ navigation failure at the dateline had a reasonable instinct that such a failure seemed unlikely for the time period. So the issue is with the reporter, who misinterpreted what the expert told them, didn’t realize before the filing deadline that what they were saying made no sense, and so wrote a sentence that caused confusion.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by paulddraper on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @07:51PM (#39198243)
It's a modern article though
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by Rebelgecko on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:39PM (#39182190)
Navigators used tables to determine the longitude that depend on the day. The theory[0] is that because their flight involved multiple day changes, Noonan might've done some on the fly calculation that plugged star positions into the wrong day's table, putting them off by 1 degree of longitude.

[0]: http://www.datelinetheory.com/, no idea how plausible this is

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by bb611 on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:07PM (#39181757)
No computer (device), but definitely a computer (person who computes) the location of the plane and destination in a formula that relies on the correct date for accurate long distance navigation.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by Jgrubb on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:32PM (#39181239)
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by ciscoriordan on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:29PM (#39181195)
An electrical issue could cause a gauge to misreport. E.g. vibrations cause a bad ground.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by Sniffnoy on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:01PM (#39181652)
An electrical issue wouldn't be caused by crossing the international date line.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by WalterBright on Monday January 29, 2024 @05:07PM (#39183397)
Crossing the equator causes the sun to flip around and go the other way in the sky.

Source: When I went to Australia, the sun went the wrong way. It was curiously unsettling.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by dtgriscom on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:48PM (#39183171)
Maybe the Bermuda Triangle is on walkabout?
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by chernevik on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:57PM (#39181601)
Probably a polite way of saying she screwed up.

She had a reputation as an indifferent navigator and aviator which is consistently downplayed.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by bb611 on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:13PM (#39181832)
Fred Noonan was hired as the navigator specifically for this leg of the flight because of his navigation skills, which he proved by establishing Pan Am's transpacific routes, so it's not obvious to me why a navigational error would rest on Earhart's lack of skills in that area.