News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by verisimi on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:37AM (#39173737)
> Fiction masquerading as journalism is nothing new, but in the age of Google Alerts and plagiarism checkers, it seems like it ought to be impossible to sustain a year-long series of audacious lies. How can a writer still pull off a con like this? And given the endless opportunities for scamming anonymously, why would anyone undertake such revealing and labour-intensive deceptions?

Well, I think this is far, far more common than people realise, because no one personally verifies much, to confirm the truth of the matter for themselves.

There is the reproducibility crisis in science. There is 'journalism' which is basically propaganda served by AP and Reuters, as if there were ever independent journalists chasing down stories and getting them published. History is written by the victors and continuously redrafted. So a history of nonsense (with only tangential relation to truth or reality), plus we now have ai to generate even more, from what has already been set down and said to be 'fact'. And then schools pump out the self-serving governance propaganda as if it were truth.

In my opinion, the individual is best off ignoring all of it, and dealing with their actual lives, rather than taking any of the distracting and manipulative stories seriously.

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by 082349872349872 on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:30AM (#39174053)
> ignoring all of it

That's one approach.

A different approach would be to encourage people to double check or at least smoke test.

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by mike_hearn on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:21AM (#39174368)
That would be great but the message from government, media and academia is overwhelmingly that people who double check ("do their own research") are fringe crazies who to be mistrusted and ideally silenced. Before getting to the point where people are actively encouraged to double check, we'd have to get to the point where people aren't actively ostracised for it!
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by moomin on Monday January 29, 2024 @05:54AM (#39174930)
The problem is that skepticism on its own isn't a route to the truth. An embarrassing number of people "doing their own research" are doing on reddit, not e.g. arxiv.
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by 082349872349872 on Monday January 29, 2024 @06:10AM (#39175022)
Sorry, I had been assuming that the HN readership would assume that double checking tertiary sources involves consulting (at least) secondary sources, secondary sources primary, etc.

Just as well-founded loop variants help avoid nontermination, making strictly closer-to-ground double checks helps avoid echo chambers.

(and frankly, "do your own research", to me, is a clear sibboleth translating to "enter our echo chamber")

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by usrusr on Monday January 29, 2024 @08:50AM (#39176202)
True. Naive skepticism is what lies on the path to "can't see the earth's curvature from an airplane!"
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by mike_hearn on Monday January 29, 2024 @08:52AM (#39176224)
If the problem you're trying to solve is Dan Arielys or journalists reporting non-replicable academic papers, restricting your review only to arxiv isn't going to help.
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by moomin on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:07PM (#39178820)
You're not wrong. Sometimes you're better off on a random sci-blogger's site. But there's always a level where we have to take things on trust. Understanding who is actually trustworthy I'll leave as an unsolved problem.
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by verisimi on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:11AM (#39174310)
I say either personally verify it or do not repeat it as true.
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by hilux on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:14AM (#39173965)
It's very sad, but you're completely right.

The Dan Ariely scam (reveal) changed everything for me. But it's clear, he's not special at all.

A good moment to remember Gell-Mann Amnesia.

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by verisimi on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:32AM (#39174070)
Thank you for sharing about the Dan Ariely scam. From his wiki:

> Ariely is the author of the three New York Times best selling books Predictably Irrational, The Upside of Irrationality and The Honest Truth about Dishonesty.[3] He co-produced the 2015 documentary (Dis)Honesty: The Truth About Lies.[4]

You have to say, this guy has chutzpah! He's fine to promote himself as a bastion of truth and rationality, and all the while he's making up his studies! Lying through your teeth gets you "three New York Times best selling books"!

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by ithkuil on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:16AM (#39174331)
It's so meta.

It reminds me of Frank Abagnale

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by moomin on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:21AM (#39174367)
One of these days they should make a movie about him (one that isn’t based on his own testimony).
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by ithkuil on Monday January 29, 2024 @05:32AM (#39174791)
And call it "The Liar's Paradox"
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by MrBuddyCasino on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:43AM (#39174150)
> There is 'journalism' which is basically propaganda served by AP and Reuters

It has always been like this, we're just starting to notice now. The fascinating thing to observe is that they're still continuing to lie as if nothing changed, even though they get called out for it on Twitter via community notes or quote tweets. Not even a reaction, apology or correction. They just continue lying.

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by moomin on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:22AM (#39174375)
Not quite true: it’s amazing how many mainstream media figures have nasty things to say about social media.
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by verisimi on Monday January 29, 2024 @06:28AM (#39175132)
This is true. And what it tells you, is that they are unapologetic about the lies. They are acting in bad faith.

When an honest man discovers he is mistaken, he will either cease being mistaken, or he will cease being honest.

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by MrBuddyCasino on Monday January 29, 2024 @07:15AM (#39175403)
Its hard to tell sometimes, there are certainly a lot of midwit true believers, and the capacity of man to hold contradicting beliefs at the same time seems boundless.

But yeah, at some point one gets really disillusioned.

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by verisimi on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:07PM (#39178822)
Being disillusioned sounds bad... but it's also necessary to live in truth. You can't be subject to illusions and live in truth.
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by IHEARTANAL on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:14AM (#39173964)
> In my opinion, the individual is best off ignoring all of it, _and dealing with their actual lives_, rather than taking any of the distracting and manipulative stories seriously.

Yes, yes, and yes. And now observe how many clickbait and fear-mongering articles people tend to react to.

Don't gey sidetracked by topics pushed by other people.

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by 082349872349872 on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:33AM (#39174084)
One way to get useful signal is to ask oneself "Why might $SOURCE want me to read this particular $CLICKBAIT?"

(of course, one then gets into the rabbit hole of source attribution, a topic already known to be difficult even before the internet era)

see also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39093409

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by somedude895 on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:55AM (#39174572)
> the individual is best off ignoring all of it, and dealing with their actual lives, rather than taking any of the distracting and manipulative stories seriously.

Hard to do when you're in school. And yes, there is some serious indoctrination going on, as you mention.

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by Angostura on Monday January 29, 2024 @05:12AM (#39174679)
> In my opinion, the individual is best off ignoring all of it, and dealing with their actual lives, rather than taking any of the distracting and manipulative stories seriously.

That’s one way to remain entirely ignorant and unengaged with anything that happens in the world beyond your immediate vicinity. This feels a rather high price to pay to avoid the occasional egregiously fraudulent piece of journalism

Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by andy99 on Monday January 29, 2024 @06:41AM (#39175205)
I wouldn't say it's best to outright ignore so much as not take seriously, or at least not use for anything actionable. You can read the news and magazines etc. if you find it interesting, just make sure to do some independent verification in line with the importance of any decisions you are making.
Re:A writer fabricated a series of stories for Atlas Obscura by usrusr on Monday January 29, 2024 @08:45AM (#39176146)
> In my opinion, the individual is best off ignoring all of it, and dealing with their actual lives, rather than taking any of the distracting and manipulative stories seriously.

Sounds like the thing Russian propaganda aims for: "we are lying, q.e.d., and if we can get away with that much lying, would you expect others to be much better? Truth does not exist, just pick whatever lie you feel most comfortable with."

Looking back at the most egregious lies of the last decade (the Bush/Blair Iraqi WMD deception), I'd say media was pretty good at calling it out as a lie. Unfortunately not successful to the point of tangible consequences, but it's not like anyone really believed them.