Re:Japan's precision moon lander has hit its target, but app...
by smeej on Thursday January 25, 2024 @11:59AM
(#39131754)
I think I was including "landing" in the relevant part of "pinpoint landing," not just the pinpoint element, which was what made it amusing. It did (apparently) "land" and not "crash" (or at least that's what I'm assuming from the fact that it isn't crushed/doesn't look like it made primary impact on some part that was not intended for impact), but "landing and falling over" doesn't normally earns a perfect score in any other common context.
Re:Japan's precision moon lander has hit its target, but app...
by johnwalkr on Thursday January 25, 2024 @09:16PM
(#39138199)
I work in the industry and "pinpoint landing" refers to the accuracy part. If he was talking about landing in general, the sentence would be something like "the landing didn't go as expected, but we achieved a pinpoint landing".
Re:Japan's precision moon lander has hit its target, but app...
by mathrawka on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:08PM
(#39133586)
Actually Japanese quote from the Project Manager, Sakai-san, is:
> いろんな意味で新しい扉が開き、今後、これまでできなかったようなミッションができるようになるのでは。そこが一番の意義ではないか
I'm far from a translator... but it is not "We opened a door" but "A door is open to do missions that were not possible before". And he says that might be the most important takeaway from this project.
https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/08a8bfdd7a41486140a97a8570...
Re:Japan's precision moon lander has hit its target, but app...
by lmm on Thursday January 25, 2024 @04:44PM
(#39135808)
> I'm far from a translator... but it is not "We opened a door" but "A door is open to do missions that were not possible before".
You're being overly literal. Omitting the subject is normal in Japanese; translating that to a passive-voiced sentence in English is usually misleading.
Re:Japan's precision moon lander has hit its target, but app...
by mathrawka on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:21PM
(#39152146)
Yes, but... 新しい扉が開き vs 新しい扉を開き
Re:Japan's precision moon lander has hit its target, but app...
by lmm on Sunday January 28, 2024 @05:28PM
(#39170459)
Again, not a distinction that carries the same nuance that it would in English. The whole animate/inanimate distinction just isn't there in the same way in non-indo-european languages.
Re:Japan's precision moon lander has hit its target, but app...
by mathrawka on Monday January 29, 2024 @10:04PM
(#39185938)
新しい扉が開き
が makes the subject the door, not JAXA. Plus it would be very uncharacteristic of a Japanese person in that position making such a bold claim. It goes against Japanese society norms.
Re:Japan's precision moon lander has hit its target, but app...
by atahanacar on Thursday January 25, 2024 @08:12PM
(#39137746)
>Opening a new door in many senses (or "in different ways" if you want to take some liberty), from now on, missions that couldn't be done until now will become possible. Isn't it the most important (thing)?
Translation for those wondering.
The context of the comment in the article referred to the “pinpoint landing” aspect of the landing. They narrowed down the landing range from 10,000m (10k) to 100m… two orders of magnitude.
From the the article, emphasis mine:
> For the pinpoint landing, Sakai said, he would give SLIM a "perfect score."
> "We demonstrated that we can land where we want," Sakai said. "We opened a door to a new era."
I don’t know if this comment was made in English or Japanese, but I could see how a very specific comment about the pinpoint aspect of the landing in Japanese could be vague when translated into English.
I don’t think anyone is disillusioned enough to think the overall landing was perfect.