News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by TravisCooper on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:56AM (#39118036)
Just put this out there:

The higher the stakes, the less we should trust what we're "told". Esp if we're told to "believe and don't question".

It won't always be obvious to you directly, why something is wrong or corrupt, rather this is a sense we have to develop over time: question the people and ideas that we're supposed to "trust".

Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by dweekly on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:10AM (#39118227)
Blind mistrust can lead to even more foolishness than blind trust because it presumes the individual alone to have the power to fully discern the systems of the world independent of the inputs of others. This framing is how you get things like flat earth, holocaust denial, etc. Healthy skepticism is appropriate - and god bless investigative journalism to find holes in things* - but generally speaking, people try to do the right thing.

* I'd suggest a donation to the Center for Investigative Reporting if this resonates

Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by gjsman-1000 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:27AM (#39118443)
Meh, blind trust is equally dangerous, if not more dangerous. Blind trust in Hitler caused the Holocaust. Blind mistrust merely causes denial that it happened.

Why should I trust a scientist? Because they have a few fancy letters next to their name? There’s no scientific evidence, according to themselves, that they are any less likely to be sociopaths, psychopaths, immoral, or irresponsible than the average population.

Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by pasc1878 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:55PM (#39120402)
However if they something about the science they specialise in they are much more likely to know more that you, scientists not in their field let alone the general public.

yes they will lie as much as anyone else but when they do not if you take the expected value of what a scientist says in their speciality it is much more likely to be correct.

Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by wolverine876 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @02:30PM (#39121627)
> Why should I trust a scientist? Because they have a few fancy letters next to their name?

That's not why people place trust in some scientists. Can you think of other reasons? How do you evaluate anyone's trustworthiness, unless you know them or research them personally (something we don't have time for)? Otherwise, you are stuck with blind mistrust, as you say.

> Blind trust in Hitler caused the Holocaust.

Blind loyalty, perhaps, and following the crowd and avoiding conflict, and amorality.

Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by wolverine876 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @02:25PM (#39121569)
Also, blind mistrust usually is connected with blind trust ... in someone else. Some 'disprupter' or influencer says 'X is all wrong, they are liars, ...' and goes through the usual diatribe. Something in Internet culture results in a significant number of people trusting them, regardless of any facts, their credibility, the credibility of their target, etc.
Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by swayvil on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:12AM (#39118252)
Independent thought/action is alien to most of us. We need an authority to tell us what's what. Directly from the media nipple or indirectly via consensus. We might even be pressured to conform against our will.

So obeying the loud science guy on tv is going to happen no matter what. And if all your friends cut off their nose then so will you.

The solution? I dunno. Quit your job and do drugs.

Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by shitpostbot on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:31AM (#39118496)
For those of you who read this and immediately started wondering what crazy stuff this guy believes, it's "Evolution is a hoax"
Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by nequo on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:04AM (#39118141)
You’re posting your conspiracy theory under the wrong article. This one is about paper mills, not the manipulation of public opinion in high-stakes cases.
Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by coldtea on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:13AM (#39118267)
You're posting the "trust the system" apologetics under the wrong comment.

The observation the parent makes about "high stakes" is fully compatible with the article, and it's just a general observation about similar shit on all domains. The same shit that happens when there are high stakes (products, money, careers, grants, etc.) on the table for scientists/journals is also true for politicians, journalists, regulating bodies, and so on.

It's also not a conspiracy theory: just basic life experience.

Re:Scientific journal publishers and editors say they are be... by nequo on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:16AM (#39118307)
Paper mills are not usually the prestigious journals. Those are usually obscure outlets whose sole purpose is to publish questionable research.

Leading the public opinion is happening elsewhere.