Re:Java creator James Gosling: 'Google totally slimed Sun'
by vibrunazo on Monday April 30, 2012 @02:50PM
(#3910725)
IANAL, but wouldn't that be a problem of trademark infringement, and not copyright claim as Oracle is suing them for?
Re:Java creator James Gosling: 'Google totally slimed Sun'
by beagle3 on Monday April 30, 2012 @02:58PM
(#3910798)
If they did call it Java, it would be. That's why they didn't. So Oracle can't monetize Java from Google by claiming a trademark infringement.
That's why they are claiming copyright on APIs and such. Whether or not this has any merit - is what the court case is all about.
Re:Java creator James Gosling: 'Google totally slimed Sun'
by falling on Monday April 30, 2012 @05:20PM
(#3911561)
Even with the TCK license, I think the major problem was licensing of the JVM.
Google wanted to make Android open source, but the JVM license requires the GPL, which Google and a lot of companies using it now won’t touch with a pole.
So they had to use more liberal license, like the one they use in most of their other projects and the only way to do that was to write their own new VM (this probably also allowed them to more easily tailor it for mobile use).
Re:Java creator James Gosling: 'Google totally slimed Sun'
by ZeroGravitas on Monday April 30, 2012 @05:56PM
(#3911756)
I don't think a GPL'd JVM would be a deal-breaker. It's at about the same level as Linux, probably less likely to be tweaked by device builders. Not having the classpath exception on the libraries would be a no go though.
Re:Java creator James Gosling: 'Google totally slimed Sun'
by dedward on Tuesday May 01, 2012 @12:44AM
(#3913025)
the main point of a gpl version, copyrights held by google, is to let people hack away, and if they wantdifferentlicense terms go to google.
If a distro doesn't pass the TCK, it can't be called Java.