Re:German Court Fines Security Researcher for Reporting Comp...
by radu_floricica on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:39PM
(#39107633)
An edge case would be a hidden URL. Publicly accessible, but not publicly available. That's more or less the same as a rope tied between posts, with the posts maybe felled by the wind. It's a good argument that it's a misunderstanding whether it's private property or not.
A password is not that.
(and to be frank, to anybody in the know even a passwordless phpmyadmin is clearly private)
Re:German Court Fines Security Researcher for Reporting Comp...
by TheNewsIsHere on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @10:11PM
(#39113158)
I assume that this situation is why government systems will often have a notice that says something like “absence of access controls is not authorization for access.”
To follow your fence analogy, they've ruled that any fence is important, but ignored brick walls and rope tied between posts – i.e. they've picked something overly specific, but poorly fit to the behaviour they are actually trying to classify.
While I'm sure that ruling against fences doesn't rule out a future ruling against walls or ropes, it probably complicates getting those rulings in the future, as one could use a defence of "if they wanted to protect it they should have built a fence" to imply security.