They were waving CCP flags, so making that sounds like some kind of race blindness is a bit wild.
> but this is a common courtesy and basic politeness every semi-professional vlogger understands.
The way they acted when asking not to be filmed was very impolite.
> Taiwan/ROC
And then people keep pretending they don't understand what's all the fuss between PRC and ROC is even about.
Its a PRC flag. I don't think "CCP" flag is even a thing. CCP or Chinese isn't a race, so I don't get the "race blindness" bit at all.
> The way they acted when asking not to be filmed was very impolite.
Was it? I see a woman carefully approaching the guy and calmly and quietly asking if they were in the video, trying to communicate that they don't want to be. There is a clear language barrier and the guy mocks her when she tries to approach in different ways.
I'd say the guy is clearly behaving like a dick and is actively looking for conflict.
Ironically the very next video YT suggests on this channel is named "security goons try to ban music and failed", suggesting that the guy really has a certain way about himself.
I don't personally believe in the "bigger dick" narrative when the whole point of trolling is provoke someone to loose their cool. The piano guy spend good few minutes poking those asian people, making fun of them and even tried grabbing one of them.
The biggest dick is the one who is looking for conflict, not the one whom they found during their trolling quest.
I don't know about the racism though, it's possible but he might simply not like the Chinese government and political system (and assume that waving a Chinese flag means supporting it, which was probably the case).
The pianist actually did try to grab that woman, look at the video.
I can't even say if the asian guy overreacted because I can't imagine myself being in the same conversation and not busting the pianist's nose or balls - and that's what would have probably happened if the pianist gave the same attitude towards a random white British girl off camera.
> I don't know about the racism though, it's possible but he might simply not like the Chinese government and political system
He was calling them "Japanese" while cracking jokes about "Chinese government" and mocking their language skills, while the woman he tried to grab was explaining to him that she is actually British. That's clearly racist.
One's political preferences is never an excuse of such a behavior towards individuals - a lot of people tend to forget that.
> and assume that waving a Chinese flag means supporting it, which was probably the case
Tourist groups often use flags in order to keep track of the group members. Thousands of people use the Union Jack or the US flag as a mere garage decoration.
There are myriad of possible reasons a person could be holding some nations flag other than to show support for a certain political force within that nation.
Although his hand can't be seen, it definitely seems he just came closer to the flag or hand
It's for sure extremely unlikely he was assaulting, which is what the scream of the Chinese implied.
---
> He was calling them "Japanese" while cracking jokes about "Chinese government" and mocking their language skills, while the woman he tried to grab was explaining to him that she is actually British. That's clearly racist
That's compatible to just not liking the Chinese dictatorship, and it's typical for the Chinese government to accuse of racism anyone who criticizes them.
There might be racism here though.
---
> There are myriad of possible reasons a person could be holding some nations flag other than to show support for a certain political force within that nation.
I'm not Chinese but I don't think I'd be happy to hold that flag if I didn't support the CCP system. After all the biggest star represents the CCP.
But it might well be so that in some occasions (e.g. sport events) you genuinely use it with good intents.
Actual racism towards Asians is in any case very rare, in my experience
Anyhow, Chinese citizens are mostly victims, and you should indeed not treat them in that way for what their government does.
> He was calling them "Japanese"
Due to a misunderstanding. He had just talked with another guy who was expecting a Japanese crew to show up so they could do some filming. He thought the Chinese people were the Japanese crew.
What countries require to "blur people in the background"?
He was threatened and only escalated to be a dick about it after they were a dick to him. He is also quite well within his rights, trying to intimidate him to stop doing it is pretty fucking evil as well.
Have we watched the same video?
It was hysterical, but I don't see how is this evil, more like being protective. And it happened way past the point of conflict
> He was threatened and only escalated to be a dick about it after they were a dick to him.
How was he threatened? These people were barely speaking English, which the guy started mocking from the very beginning of the conversation, before he could even figure out what they were even asking for.
> Have we watched the same video?
Honestly asking the same question. Am rewatching 9:00-10:00 how the lady tries to ask the guy not to film, but he just mocks her: "No disco? No disco? Whot, the ChInEsE GoVeRnMeNt will jail us?"
How is this not being a dick?
At about the 10:00 another asian guy steps in and says "basically we ask you, whatever you do, don't publish our faces on TV, we will appreciate that"
The piano guy responds: "What happens if I don't?"
The asian guy responds: "We'll just really just appreciate if you do. We are very sensitive to this kind of thing. Sorry, we really like your music, yada-yada".
The asian guy clearly tries to deescalate and ask nicely, while the piano guy is all like "oh yeah? Watcha gonna do?"
How is this threatening?
> He is also quite well within his rights
So are people who listen to loud music when a baby is sleeping next door. They are quite within their rights, but this hardly makes them any less terrible people for doing it just to make a point.
Don't grab women.
That said, In film school, we were taught that we can film anyone in public and that's our right, and also taught that if you film someone in public and they come up and tell you it's a problem, it's polite to not publish their likeness/delete the image. I always did do, but quite a few kids in class couldn't care less.
Different strokes.
That's my point, that's just basic politeness.
If someone asks you not to publish their faces, especially after you were the one to approach them first in the first place, you just do it. Period. All it takes is a single note and 30 seconds of time during editing.
But the pianist is probably deep into "free speech", "auditor" and generally right-wing bs
"CCP members threaten British public piano player", right.
I get that some countries still don't have a legal requirement to blur people in the background (or at least when they asked you to), but this is a common courtesy and basic politeness every semi-professional vlogger understands.
Just don't be evil.