News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by georgyo on Saturday January 20, 2024 @04:32PM (#39072578)
I used to think this way as well, but then I started doing the actual math.

My last power bill was ~$103 for exactly 256kw, or put another way about $0.40/kwh. For context this is in NYC. I'm sure other people have cheaper power elsewhere.

0.01kw * 24 hours * 30 days * 0.4 $/kwh = $2.88 a month or about $35 a year.

If something is going to be on constantly, the ROI on a 10watts savings can quickly out pace the initial investment.

And that is every 10 watts. Something using 100watts continuously is 10 times that.

This affected a bunch of my other thinking as well. Having a raspberry pi in my home as always on server costs as much a small linode instance and much less reliable.

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by Macha on Saturday January 20, 2024 @04:50PM (#39072774)
Similarly, I upgraded the GPU in my server from a decade old formerly high end gaming GPU to a modern lower-mid range because I wanted new video encoders, and a smoother Linux driver experience. But it's idle 99% of the time. The difference in idle consumption (80% lower on the new GPU) works out to €50/year, which means even if I didn't use any of the other features of the GPU, it would pay for itself in 3 years.

Video encoding power draw is also 86% lower and even if I found something to max the new card out, it's still 40% lower than maxing out the old card (for a lot more compute power than the ten year old card).

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by paulmd on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:18PM (#39074854)
Note that this trend isn’t always downwards - upgrading from rdna2 to 3 or from intel CPUs to AMD CPUs could result in increased idle power, sometimes significantly so.

Also, just in general, the product focus on efficiency varies across vendors. NUCs are quite efficient, because they put a lot of focus into it to win those corporate contracts back in the day. A random minisforum mini pc probably is less efficient than an old nuc. Connectx-5 is much less efficient than connectx-4 even when running at lower speeds. Ssds generally pull much more power than the HDDs they replaced. Etc.

Not saying you didn’t look at it, but you have to look at it specifically and newer is not automatically better, sometimes product tiers increase over time too. And it’s certainly always a product-by-product thing.

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by MuffinFlavored on Saturday January 20, 2024 @05:47PM (#39073264)
> or put another way about $0.40/kwh.

I pay $0.16/kwh net of everything (all taxes + fees). That's insane.

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by blagie on Sunday January 21, 2024 @08:31AM (#39078263)
I seriously doubt that. "net of everything" would include HVAC.

* In the winter, my computer means I run my space heater less by every watt it puts out. It's free.

* In the summer, the costs are several times higher. Every watt put out by my computer means several watts of running the AC.

It's actually a rather large difference. If I were in Alaska, computer power would be nearly free. If I were in Mexico, it'd be very, very expensive.

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by unethical_ban on Saturday January 20, 2024 @05:17PM (#39073006)
Wow, that's a lot of money. I thought my electricity was high because it's gone up a lot to 0.12 in South Texas.
Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by oakesm9 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:14PM (#39073501)
That’s amazingly cheap to me if it’s a unit price per kWh.

In the UK for me unit prices from April to July last year were £0.50/kWh (USD$0.64) and that was with the government implementing a price cap and subsidising it.

It’s down dropped to a more reasonable £0.29 (USD$0.37) but that’s still with the government capping the maximum rates that can be charged, but no longer subsidising energy companies as the UK wholesale rate is lower than the cap.

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by sys_64738 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:37PM (#39073698)
You have to remember that in the US we have deregulated electricity so power charge and delivery charge are separate. That 12c might only be the electric cost. Delivery charge is about 60% of the cost of the whole kwh for me. 40c is probably the delivery + cost of electricity itself.
Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by piperswe on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:43PM (#39074219)
In central Texas, my power rate is about 9.4 cents per kWh, inclusive of "wires" and "energy" (as my bill breaks it down).
Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by ssl-3 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:02PM (#39074340)
Indeed. Everyone would do well to remember that kind of thing in the US, but only some people actually do. That's why these discussions almost always quickly devolve into irrelevant things like "What? I pay $0.05 cents per kWh! It says so right on my bill under 'Price to compare'!"

And then the discourse diverges into yet-another discussion about how billing works, and power deregulation, and other things.

But the only number that matters is the total cost per kWh -- including delivery, distribution, generation, taxes, fees, grift, and whatever else might be included in the bill total.

And that's easy to figure out: Total dollars billed divided by total power consumed, for any given billing period.

The result is a number, in US dollars (or whatever local currency), that neatly and inclusively expresses what a person was actually-charged, per kWh, for electricity in their home for that period.

---

So, for example: My most recent electric bill was, in total, $176.26.

I used 1,111kWh during that period.

$176.26 ÷ 1,111kWh = a cost of $0.158 per kWh, plus or minus a rounding error, for the power I used last month.

---

Only now can I extrapolate that if that my total cost per kWh remains static over time (it will not, but it is likely to be close), then: A 10 Watt difference in 24/7 power consumption is equivalent to ~$13.85 per year, for me.

I can now also evaluate that cost in more practical terms, wherein: I can see that using an extra 10 Watts on a 24/7 application costs me less than one decent beer per month, or one twelve-pack per year. And I'm pretty far from wealthy, but I can see that drinking one fewer beer per month isn't going to make me wealthier in any practical sense of the word. A 10-Watt difference in power consumption thus won't weigh heavily on my decision to use one system or another -- as long as it is just one such system.

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by bpye on Saturday January 20, 2024 @11:21PM (#39075526)
Up here in BC it is 0.0975CAD/kWh for the first 1350kWh/2 months and then 0.1408CAD/kWh after - and BC Hydro is publicly owned and almost exclusively hydroelectric.
Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by inferiorhuman on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:04PM (#39073948)
Yep. PG&E + EBCE/AVA runs around $0.52/kWh on the low end to $0.68/kWh on the high end out here. Generation is about a third of that, the rest is delivery. Using PG&E for both distribution and generation would add 5% to the total cost. PG&E got a 13% rate hike approved this for year, and they're asking for another hike in March.

As we race towards $1/kWh I wonder where the breaking point will be.

I'm on a time-of-use plan so the costs vary both on when and how much you use.

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by HideousKojima on Saturday January 20, 2024 @06:29PM (#39073627)
The most expensive states (except Hawaii) for electricity like Massachusetts and New Hampshire have electricity at about 18 cents per kWh. Hawaii has it at about 30 cents per kWh but they're an island so I imagine that complicates things. In most states it ranges from 9 to 14 cents per kWh.
Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by freeAgent on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:28PM (#39074140)
Connecticut and California really have some explaining to do regarding their electric rates. https://www.statista.com/statistics/630090/states-with-the-a...
Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by inferiorhuman on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:11PM (#39074408)
California will vary quite a bit. The municipal power companies are quite reasonable (in the Bay Area: Alameda, Palo Alto, Santa Clara?).

PG&E (the dominant player in northern california):

- lobbied hard against muni power

- spent its safety budget on executive compensation

- is recouping its maintenance costs and criminal penalties from its ratepayers instead of from its shareholders

- got Newsom to stack the regulatory body (CPUC) with PG&E sycophants

- is back to paying its shareholders dividends

- has one of the most influential California politicians (Willie Brown) on their payroll

Yes, it's obscene that in a climate as mild as the Bay Area, $400+ utility bills are the norm. Short of some major revolt, rates are set to go up in March as well.

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by tonymet on Saturday January 20, 2024 @08:52PM (#39074675)
You're right to account for TCO. It's another good reason to try to sleep devices, use WOL.

also minding the cpu power state of the device , making sure it's running efficiently and going to sleep whenever possible.

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by evanreichard on Sunday January 21, 2024 @09:27AM (#39078704)
That’s wild. I’m right outside DC and last month I used 2066kWh for a total bill of $258.85. So, 0.13c/kWh.

I’m all electric heat pump. That ran for about 300hrs last month, so accounts for around 800kWh.

Re:The Orange Pi 5 Plus by korhojoa on Sunday January 21, 2024 @11:26AM (#39079878)
I don't understand how hours run equates to your calculation unless it was always pulling 2,7 kW. Is this some 30 year old setup that doesn't have an inverter-driven compressor?

Also, wow your electricity is really cheap.