News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by jerf on Sunday April 29, 2012 @02:17PM (#3906572)
A classic substitution, substituting an argument that government should exist for an argument that a government should get a given bit of money. It's not the same question, and following that substitution to its logical conclusion leads to the government needing 100% of the money. (And I do mean logical conclusion, not extreme conclusion. This is a fallacious argument.)

Those libertarians he references are strawmen.

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by skore on Sunday April 29, 2012 @03:27PM (#3906781)
I disagree. From what I understand, he is not talking about government needing the money, but society needing the money (in his example, which is, after all, the central reason for his post, he talks about him taking in money for a group of people to organize an event for everybody).

This maps well to his addressing those "strawmen" libertarians. Most libertarian rhetoric builds on the fact that people have been made suspicious of government and are suggested to think of government as "the other". Likewise, you seem to try to force his argument on its head - Nobody argues whether government should exist and you suggesting it makes me wonder how closely you've read the post.

"The Government" is the subgroup of society who have been elected by the rest of society to invest part of societies resources to the advantage to everybody. The basic math being that society will be better off having spent the money in that way than had it kept the money. Whether or not you agree that that is happening, that is the basic plan.

Tims post simply says: If we want to be a society, that comes at a cost and somebody has to pick up the tab at the end of the night and the system to make that happen is called taxation.

Claiming that this in itself "fallacious argument" because you actually know what his argument is seems ambitious, but I simply have no idea where you take that from. Let's argue the reverse: Since you don't seem to disagree that a government in itself is a good concept, who do you think should pay the price for it?

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by jerf on Sunday April 29, 2012 @04:33PM (#3906991)
"If we want to be a society, that comes at a cost and somebody has to pick up the tab at the end of the night and the system to make that happen is called taxation."

Your own summary simply repeats the fallacy. That someone must pick up the tab does not imply that the tab must be larger than it is today, or that the tab must be paid for by this particular chunk of money. It does not follow. It is not a logical argument.

It isn't even about libertarianism. It doesn't even rise to the level of an argument against libertarianism, because it isn't well-formed enough to even be called a proper argument. "We need a thing" and "We need more of a thing" are two completely different arguments, and you shouldn't allow one argument to be substituted for another without noticing.

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by skore on Sunday April 29, 2012 @05:02PM (#3907106)
Well, that's another thing that nobody is arguing. Maybe that really is where you misunderstand Tim's position: He does not say we need more taxation, he says that there are actors in the game that do not pay their fair share.

You're doing your own argument a disservice by trying to modify the position of your opponent. That's not how discussions work.

The position that Tim (and I) argue is simple: There is X amount of money that it costs to run society. While, yes, we constantly have to figure out what that amount is, there is no question that it should be paid by everybody in that society. And that the stronger players (who both benefit most from a well funded society and who have the most to give) should be decent enough to step in appropriately.

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by carbocation on Sunday April 29, 2012 @05:42PM (#3907225)
Were you 'decent enough' to pay more in taxes than you owed this year? Of course not. Why should anyone else feel compelled to do so?
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by skore on Sunday April 29, 2012 @05:51PM (#3907251)
Phew, I'm not sure whether I even have to respond to that non sequitur.

Obviously I'm not a big corporation and obviously we're talking about tax loopholes here, not paying extra taxes on top of what you owe.

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by tedunangst on Sunday April 29, 2012 @05:59PM (#3907262)
What is a loophole, if not something that reduces the amount of tax you owe?

Concretely, how do you propose Apple calculate how much tax they owe if "the amount the law requires" is not the correct amount?

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by vacri on Sunday April 29, 2012 @06:30PM (#3907324)
I'm sure it was the intent of the framers of tax law that large corporations should funnel a third of their income to a different country as part of "the amount the law requires".
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by tedunangst on Sunday April 29, 2012 @09:51PM (#3907698)
Apple is a company, not a mind reader. How are they to know where to funnel the money except where the law tells them?
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by vacri on Sunday April 29, 2012 @10:12PM (#3907755)
I think you'll find the law does not say "US corporations should funnel their money to Ireland". Apple (and other corps) hire people to find edge conditions in law that they can exploit - they are not the doe-eyed innocents 'complying with the law' that you're painting them as.

They are dodging tax laws using technical loopholes, not complying with the spirit of the tax laws. Stop being an apologist.

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by tedunangst on Sunday April 29, 2012 @11:07PM (#3907862)
How hard would it be to write a law that says "don't funnel your money to Ireland"?
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by vacri on Monday April 30, 2012 @12:10AM (#3907997)
If you think it's that simple, try writing to your representative with your solution to the problem.

But ultimately the issue is you painting them as innocents in this, 'they're not mind-readers', when the main article suggests that they were actually aggressive pioneers in finding ways to dodge the spirit of tax laws.

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by skore on Sunday April 29, 2012 @07:07PM (#3907406)
Precisely. I really don't get how anybody can try to force a red herring on this about "let's nitpick down to the nickel whether or not taxes are cool as they are" when we're talking about corporations who literally employ people to figure out ways of being taxed in a completely different country.
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by jimmyvanhalen on Sunday April 29, 2012 @06:28PM (#3907320)
The corporate and personal tax rate in other countries such as Germany and Belgium are higher than the US.

I heard Germans and Belgians are "more decent" than Americans. ;)

Who's more "decent"?

The company that pays taxes, pays dividends to shareholders (pension/retirement funds, universities, charities,etc.), created 500,000 jobs in the US (which in turn pays income tax), spends billions in R&D, donates to charities, etc.

or

The big government with massive deficit that overspends on useless government programs, wars, etc..?

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by skore on Sunday April 29, 2012 @07:04PM (#3907402)
Yes, I like to think we are quite decent over here in Germany ;-)

But I don't think getting into a pissing match about who is or isn't decent and extending this so far that the conversation breaks ("And squirrels! Are they decent!?") does any good.

If there is a corporation that has most of its business in your country but plays tricks to be taxed in another, that's a problem, plain and simple. Whether or not they have other good qualities adds nothing to the discussion.

Also - I thought the trickle-down "but they create jobs!" argument was thoroughly debunked by now?

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by jimmyvanhalen on Sunday April 29, 2012 @10:32PM (#3907797)
s/trix/perfectly legal tax laws
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by skore on Monday April 30, 2012 @05:05AM (#3908532)
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by jimmyvanhalen on Sunday April 29, 2012 @04:30PM (#3906983)
Everybody's favorite ad company is also doing the same thing btw.

Google 2.4% Rate Shows How $60 Billion Lost to Tax Loopholes

Google Inc. cut its taxes by $3.1 billion in the last three years using a technique that moves most of its foreign profits through Ireland and the Netherlands to Bermuda.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-10-21/google-2-4-rate-sho...

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by adventureful on Sunday April 29, 2012 @05:48PM (#3907246)
If only most of the taxes the government takes actually went to benefit society. At least then there could be a sympathetic argument made for where $6 trillion goes each year.

That's $30,000 per adult, per year, in taxes (local+state+federal). The equation: government == society, is false. Some governments are effective and efficient, some are not; some work for the people, some work against the people, and in varying degrees.

We take as much money out of the economy through all forms of taxation as nations such as Germany, but we don't have the results to show for it that they do. They have better roads, better healthcare, better infrastructure overall, and better education.

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by skore on Sunday April 29, 2012 @07:10PM (#3907418)
Oh absolutely. Being a German looking over the pond, I would be seriously pissed off about what happens in government if I was a US citizen.

What I don't like about these discussions, particularly when they are driven by US citizens, is the amount of proud apathy or downright confused resignation that is displayed. Surely a couple of corporations have spent a proper buck to make that happen - Confuse people so thoroughly that they start questioning whether this whole democracy and society-thing is worth it to begin with.

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by jimmyvanhalen on Sunday April 29, 2012 @10:44PM (#3907820)
How is your country doing with your high tax rates? Do you ever wonder why we are the center of the universe? Do you ever wonder why Apple, Google, Facebook, etc. were all started here in America?

In 1978 Congress for once did the sensible thing and slashed capital gains taxes: This resulted in the supply of venture capital exploding. By the start of 1979 a massive commitment to venture capital funds had taken place, rising from a pathetic $39 million in 1977 to a staggering $570 million at the end of 1978. Tax collections on long-term capital gains, despite the dire predictions of Keynesian big-spending critics of tax cuts, leapt from $8.5 billion in 1978 to $10.6 billion in 1979, $16.5 billion in 1983, and $23.7 billion in 1985. By 1981 venture capital outlays had soared to $1.4 billion, and the total amount of venture capital had risen to $5.8 billion. In 1981 the maximum tax rate on long-term capital gains was cut to 20 percent. This resulted in the venture capital pool surging to $11.5 billion. Astonishingly enough—to conventional economists, that is—venture capital outlays rose to $1.8 billion in the midst of the 1982 depression. This was about 400 percent more than had been out-laid during the 1970s slump. In 1983 these outlays rose to nearly $3 billion....In 1982 the U.S. General Accounting Office sampled 72 companies that had been launched with venture capital since the 1978 capital-gains tax cut. The results were startling. Starting with $209 million dollars in funds, these companies had paid $350 million in federal taxes, generated $900 million in export income, and directly created 135,000 jobs.

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by skore on Monday April 30, 2012 @05:50AM (#3908609)
As the country with the fourth largest nominal GDP [1], we are doing quite well, thank you, although we have to work a little harder to deal with all that "innovation" that came from the US before and in 2008.

Look, I'm not saying that the US is not wonderful - but there are a couple of areas where it just isn't wonderful at all.

I have no idea why you quote that text related to the Laffer Curve [2] (please learn to cite your sources). After all, it seems that Germany has adopted some of its principles [3] and numbers like that do not happen in a vaccuum as the text seems to suggest. But there is still nobody in this thread arguing for excessive or unreasonable taxation. It is still about companies being asked to pay their fair share.

That being said, I don't believe in money as much as I believe in human progress and quoting numbers like that isn't really helping - the social situation in the US and the impact that your "strong" corporate culture has on the world are areas that speak a much clearer language.

There are perfectly reasonable arguments why the US is the worst place to start a company in (Immigration Policy and Software Patents would be on the top of my list), but at 300m people compared to our 80m at a similar HDI, I just don't think that the two countries are that comparable. You won the war and it took us 40 years to reunite our own country, for crying out loud!

Everybody has their own set of challenges. It would be incredibly arrogant to respond to another person trying to suggest lessons that they have learned simply by parroting their challenges or solutions that simply don't follow the discussion. Then again, you start out by asking me how I like you being the center of the universe. Well - I like to understand myself as a citizen of the world and find little use in pissing matches.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nomin... [2] http://brookesnews.com/072409laffercurve.html [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve#Outside_the_United...

Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics by jimmyvanhalen on Monday April 30, 2012 @01:47PM (#3910368)
>I have no idea why you quote that text related to the Laffer Curve.

then our discussion is over.