Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics
by vacri on Sunday April 29, 2012 @06:30PM
(#3907324)
I'm sure it was the intent of the framers of tax law that large corporations should funnel a third of their income to a different country as part of "the amount the law requires".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics
by tedunangst on Sunday April 29, 2012 @09:51PM
(#3907698)
Apple is a company, not a mind reader. How are they to know where to funnel the money except where the law tells them?
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics
by vacri on Sunday April 29, 2012 @10:12PM
(#3907755)
I think you'll find the law does not say "US corporations should funnel their money to Ireland". Apple (and other corps) hire people to find edge conditions in law that they can exploit - they are not the doe-eyed innocents 'complying with the law' that you're painting them as.
They are dodging tax laws using technical loopholes, not complying with the spirit of the tax laws. Stop being an apologist.
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics
by tedunangst on Sunday April 29, 2012 @11:07PM
(#3907862)
How hard would it be to write a law that says "don't funnel your money to Ireland"?
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics
by vacri on Monday April 30, 2012 @12:10AM
(#3907997)
If you think it's that simple, try writing to your representative with your solution to the problem.
But ultimately the issue is you painting them as innocents in this, 'they're not mind-readers', when the main article suggests that they were actually aggressive pioneers in finding ways to dodge the spirit of tax laws.
Re:Tim O'Reilly's Reflections on Apple's Tax Avoidance Tactics
by skore on Sunday April 29, 2012 @07:07PM
(#3907406)
Precisely. I really don't get how anybody can try to force a red herring on this about "let's nitpick down to the nickel whether or not taxes are cool as they are" when we're talking about corporations who literally employ people to figure out ways of being taxed in a completely different country.