Japanese houses are pulled down and rebuilt from scratch every 20-30 years, and concrete buildings last 40-50 years before being torn down, which provides a deterrent from the housing being used as a nest egg. Then there are also cultural nuances where the Japanese people prefer new over old, hence holding on to an old house is uncommon. Property inheritance taxes are also substantial or sky high and make it unpallatable for most people to financially commit to a house long term to pass it on to an family member.
like avoiding obvious chronic health problems related to living in old, moldy wooden structures (as a good portion of the US does).
"Tokyo is one of the most expensive cities in the world. It made the number 10 spot on Deutsche Bank’s annual Mapping the World’s Prices report in 2019 and is the third most expensive city for expatriates on Mercer’s 2020 Cost of Living Survey."
https://blog.gaijinpot.com/how-much-is-the-average-rent-in-t...
> «However, you’ll often hear from people that Tokyo isn’t “that expensive,” which isn’t false, depending on your location and lifestyle. Indeed, the Deutsche Bank report lists the average price for a “typical” Tokyo two-bedroom apartment as US$1,903 (¥203,730)».
A random look through apartments in Shibuya-ku (https://apartments.gaijinpot.com/en/rent/tokyo/shibuya-ku), one of the most expensive wards in Tokyo, has turned up a 3 bedroom apartment for JPY 441,000 (~ USD3k) a month. This is less than the cost of a 2 bedroom apartment in the Sydney CBD today.
Most importantly, these are rental prices. My point remains – house prices in Japan are low, and the cost of living for an expat does not translate into local housing costs.
Also, you're not wrong with your comparison against Sydney. But are young families in Sydney having more kids? Or is it maybe just bad in both cases?
Yes, young families in Sydney are procreating, and quite successfully so. Two children are nearly a norm, three children is also common, and even four children is not that uncommon. Preschool enrollments are at an all time high.
Birth rates in the inner city areas and expensive suburbs is low.
Will Australia suffer if high priced lawyers and real estate moguls are not replaced?
If you reduce housing to affordable prices, for example by building lots of government-owned rental units like in Singapore, then the old generation who invested into housing is upset that you destroyed their assets.
If you keep housing an appreciating asset, then young people are too poor to raise kids on their parents' level, so they might delay/abandon having kids.