News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by gumby on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:43PM (#39061617)
Loathe as I am to be in any way sympathetic to Amazon, I have to ask: what's the right thing that should have happened?

It's pretty standard that in a fire you leave the building and assemble in some safe location. The only fire drills I've done have been in school, in clement weather, and we assembled in the parking lot away enough from the buildings that the fire wouldn't affect us, we wouldn't be in the way of firefighters and away from the road.

But when it's cold: what provisions should be made to ensure the assembly point is a "safe location"? It's reasonable to assume people will evacuate without jackets or anything.

I don't know the answer, but perhaps someone who's been in a fire drill in a cold climate can explain.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by impossiblefork on Friday January 19, 2024 @06:38PM (#39062931)
What would have happened here in Sweden is that if people weren't dressed for the cold they'd probably get shelter somehow-- maybe go home, enter a restaurant or other building.

-30 C is really incredibly cold. You just can't stand around in that without proper clothes.

I think the problem is that a lot of Americans are incredibly servile and will obey employers, authorities etc., even when it's harmful or dangerous. I especially remember a case where a woman was in court and was sexually assaulted by a marshal, right there with the judge ignoring it. But what I found very curious was how he was obeyed, and how the judge was obeyed.

Here in Sweden, neither judge nor marshal would have been obeyed.

I think the servility is probably caused by the experience that employers and authorities can get away with anything, and a fear that they will do worse if challenged or attacked.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by hacoo on Friday January 19, 2024 @08:06PM (#39063548)
Well, this took place in canada. That said, amazon warehouse employees have no leverage and are easy to fire, which I suspect leads to a culture of 'follow the rules or else'.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by randomdata on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:03AM (#39065131)
> employees have no leverage

Amazon's job ad for "Warehouse Team Member" at that location indicates pay 30% above minimum wage plus benefits. That suggests the workers have a reasonable amount of leverage. After all, why would Amazon pay anything more than minimum wage if the workers had no leverage? There is nothing to suggest that Amazon operates as a charity.

> are easy to fire

Not when one is being fired over taking necessary precautions to serve their health and wellbeing. Ontario labour law does not take kindly to that in the slightest. In fact, Ontario regulation requires employers to make that known to the employees, so it isn't even a case of "He didn't know." The, as summed up by the popular TV show based on the nearby town of Listowel, "When a friend asks for help, you help them" explanation is the most likely. It is the Canadian culture to be compliant when someone asks something of you.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by Alpha3031 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:38AM (#39065270)
There are proposed microfoundations for efficiency wages that do not necessary imply a significant level of bargaining power for an individual worker.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by randomdata on Saturday January 20, 2024 @02:00AM (#39065355)
Even if that were true, individual bargaining power is irrelevant here as the workers share a collective agreement that clearly asserts that Amazon will not terminate employment for reasons related to safety.

Logically, the workers knew there was no onus for them to leave their cars. But when your friendly coworker comes along "I know it is warm in there, but can you please come outside with the rest of us who don't have the same luxury?" it is hard in Canadian culture to say no. Rather you get "Sorry. I'll be right there."

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by sleep-grenade on Friday January 19, 2024 @07:20PM (#39063264)
it somehow feels like a lot of middle-managers explain it to themselves that they also just have no choice but to do what they're told from above and boss people around..

.. but imagine if you were that manager that had told people to stand around in the freezing cold and then someone just dropped dead.

or the person above them

.. well i guess they probably don't think about this kind of stuff at all

i'm just having a hard time putting myself in one of those people's shoes

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by randomdata on Friday January 19, 2024 @08:36PM (#39063762)
> -30 C is really incredibly cold.

Environment Canada shows that it was -19ºC (ambient) at the time. The article asserts it was -22ºC with the windchill. Still very cold, but I find it interesting that -30ºC has shown up in the comments more than once. Where does that come from?

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by andreasley on Friday January 19, 2024 @09:08PM (#39063957)
The article says "-22" but does not specify if that's °C or °F. When (incorrectly) assuming that Canada is using the Farenheit scale like the U.S., this would convert to -30°C.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by KennyBlanken on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:35AM (#39065260)
We're "incredibly servile"? Seriously? Go soak your head.

We're "incredibly servile" because of the lack of social safety net programs, healthcare being tied to employment, and wages being so shit compared to CoL that most Americans are about a paycheck or two from being broke. And there's little we can do about it thanks to Citizens United.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by randomdata on Saturday January 20, 2024 @02:31AM (#39065473)
> healthcare being tied to employment

He said America, not United States of America. America refers to the combined area of North, South, and Central America. Of which Canada is a part, and, as it happens, Canada is where this took place. Healthcare is not tied to employment in Canada.

> We're "incredibly servile" because of the lack of social safety net programs

All employees in Ontario are covered under a collective agreement that asserts employers will not terminate employment for reasons related to health. Employees who stayed in their cars had no reason to fear for their job. However, they probably did have good reason to fear the mob of people who had nowhere warm to go.

Remember, this warehouse is in the middle of a farmer's field. The nearest settlement is several kilometres away, and the nearest settlement with any reasonable public place to shelter in is tens of kilometres away. There would be no other practical place to go to stay warm other than a car, but not everyone would have a car available to go to. There are other ways to get to work that don't leave you with a personal space heater at your beck and call.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by ihattendorf on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:34AM (#39090528)
> He said America, not United States of America. America refers to the combined area of North, South, and Central America. Of which Canada is a part, and, as it happens, Canada is where this took place. Healthcare is not tied to employment in Canada.

Sorry, what? The user they're replying to said American, and also referenced a case in court with a Marshal which IIRC don't exist in Canada. They were clearly referring to the US. Which 99% of users who aren't needlessly obtuse would understand with the word American which in English typically refers to someone from the US and not North/South/Central America.

Obviously the article is talking about Canada, but many people in this comment section don't appear to have noticed that and think it happened in the US.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by impossiblefork on Saturday January 20, 2024 @03:01AM (#39065582)
Yes, it has causes, but the second case I mentioned can't be caused by the healthcare stuff, but is actually strict authority obedience, which I think has its origin in impunity for authorities.

The marshal and judge simply would not have been obeyed. Rather they would have faced physical resistance, and possibly have been beaten up or worse, and no one would have been punished for it-- certainly they would have been disarmed.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by euroderf on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:26AM (#39068477)
In Helsinki we had a fire in the attic of the apartment building. Seriously cold outside. The city sent a bus for people to stay warm in. My cat appreciated it, and I too.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by gumby on Saturday January 20, 2024 @02:04PM (#39071068)
> I think the problem is that a lot of Americans are incredibly servile and will obey employers, authorities etc., even when it's harmful or dangerous.

I agree with this observation but will temper it somewhat: I know in the school case, and I imagine in the warehouse case too, there’s a person responsible for checking who’s out so they can tell the fire brigade “everybody’s out of the building” or “all but three people are accounted for” which is super important. This is hard to do when people just scatter.

None of which excuses what happened to this poor man.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by pests on Friday January 19, 2024 @05:44PM (#39062376)
Just like we have requirements for fire extinguishers and fire ladders / suppression systems, there should be requirements on providing protection from the elements in situations like these as well.

Outside heaters, emergency blankets and ponchos, chemical warming packs, etc.

This is a workplace. We already take precautions against fire and chemicals and whatnot, this isn't asking for much more.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by KennyBlanken on Friday January 19, 2024 @07:21PM (#39063271)
Their cars.

Which they were told not to enter, probably with the threat of being fired.

Because Amazon fears that someone will pocket some inventory during the fire alarm, and then stash it in their car.

So for the risk of the world's richest man losing maybe a grand or two in stolen inventory - someone died.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by infamouscow on Friday January 19, 2024 @08:42PM (#39063802)
I don't think Bezos is the one that came up with these idiotic corporate policies.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by mofosyne on Friday January 19, 2024 @09:58PM (#39064223)
Wether or not he decided it or not. He is still the prime beneficiary of a culture of explotation and fear.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by infamouscow on Friday January 19, 2024 @10:50PM (#39064479)
He's the primary reason why 1.5 million people have jobs.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by RobRivera on Friday January 19, 2024 @11:25PM (#39064660)
Both statements can be true
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by randomdata on Saturday January 20, 2024 @12:27AM (#39064967)
Yes, no doubt the supervisor(s) feared that if they let it happen their job would be on the line. But how warranted was that fear? Would Bezos actually fly up to YXU and personally fire the management team over a worker sitting in their car? Or was it completely imagined?

From my unattached outsider's perspective, I am almost certain Bezos would do no such thing. In fact, it is almost guaranteed that he would have never known about it, assuming it would have saved this person's life. In my experience with small business, I wouldn't even be able to keep track if any of the workers there were sitting in a car during a fire drill unless I watched it happen. There is no way someone in a business of millions of people is keeping such tabs.

I can appreciate the imagining, though. I'm guilty of such things myself, finding out later the person I thought would draw ire wasn't thinking about me at all. I'm not sure that is cultural. It seems to be a basic human trait. In fact, our culture tries to remind people that nobody is thinking about you.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by kozd on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:04AM (#39065138)
It's not like this is some isolated incident and Amazon's culture is otherwise healthy. The fish rots from the head.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by randomdata on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:30AM (#39065240)
I suppose you have a point that warehouses don't exactly attract top talent. Ontario labour law is abundantly clear that employers must not terminate employees over matters related to protecting health and wellbeing. It even requires employers to ensure that the workers are well aware of that fact. This is going to cost Bezos a fortune when the government finds out what happened. But when the head shows up rotten, what can you do? I expect a sharp mind like yours would never even entertain the thought of working there, right?
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by kozd on Saturday January 20, 2024 @02:19AM (#39065434)
Maybe dial back the snark. You seem to have forgotten to make any sort of coherent reply to what I actually said.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by randomdata on Saturday January 20, 2024 @02:41AM (#39065506)
I recant the sharp mind question. You are clearly struggling.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by kozd on Saturday January 20, 2024 @03:11AM (#39065621)
This is not a reddit thread. Give the tired responses a break and read the HN guidelines.
Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by randomdata on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:56AM (#39068143)
I do wonder how far off-topic you are prepared to go here?

I’m around if you ever reach a point where your ego allows you to get past the earlier error. It is okay that your comment wasn’t thought through. Nobody cares. For the sake of kindness, I will continue to partake in this diversion therapy if that’s what you need to get through it, but know that I’m more interested in the original topic.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by KennyBlanken on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:58AM (#39065344)
You think he isn't aware of the policies? Or their effects?

This death isn't the first. They've had so many problems with heat exhaustion the company hires private ambulance services so there's no public record of EMS being dispatched to their warehouses.

This also isn't the first time they've had people end up outside the warehouse in freezing cold.

Then there were the warehouse deaths caused because staff weren't allowed to shelter from a tornado.

The list goes on and on.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by randomdata on Saturday January 20, 2024 @11:42AM (#39069412)
> You think he isn't aware of the policies?

With millions of employees there is no way he is able to say on top of the policies the workers are putting in place, no. Hell, I've spent enough time in small businesses to observe workers creating boneheaded policies behind the stakeholders' backs, only seeing them come to light when the stupidity caused itself to become known. How are you going to know? Nobody is going to tell you until it is too late.

> Or their effects?

Yes, most likely he is now aware that someone died as a result of another worker doing something idiotic. Now what? He can command to the workers to stop being idiots. I expect he already does that on a daily basis. But do you think that will really work? If you have ever worked with other people in these types of "low rung" jobs you will know that the worker always thinks they know better.

Perhaps that is difficult to fathom from the tech "ivory tower"? Indeed, in tech – and I expect other "high prestige" careers – workers are generally more willing to think things through and search for the best possible solution.

Re:Amazon employee in Ontario collapses, dies after fire ala... by randomdata on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:39AM (#39065277)
> Which they were told not to enter

Forget to read the article? "staff who tried to warm up in their vehicles were told by supervisors to get out of their cars."

> So for the risk of the world's richest man losing maybe a grand or two in stolen inventory - someone died.

Because they thought if they told anyone who may have stolen inventory to get back out of their car, the thieves would bring the inventory back with them? These supervisors who subjected the workers to prolonged cold exposure when an alternative was available may not be the sharpest tools in the shed, but that's really pushing it.