And by replication studies I mean "take this paper, try to replicate, write a paper on it".
Every singular paper can be wrong, that's why you're supposed to replicate them - that's at least what was taught in psychology, which many consider "social science of less rigour" - well, it was probably the course most hardcore about experimental design in my education and ability to replicate a study...
>And by replication studies I mean "take this paper, try to replicate, write a paper on it".
You don't necessarily need to perform a straight-up "replication study" in order to do some useful sanity checking on published results. It can be done as part of another novel study that builds upon prior work. That's basically what happened with the fraudulent UCLA political persuasion study several years ago [1]. Some Berkeley researchers wanted to extend the ideas in that earlier published paper, reused similar methods under the assumption that the UCLA folks were correct, and couldn't get anything reasonable within the ballpark of what was published.
[1] https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-two-grad-students-u...
Conservatively 90%? Bullshit. The real numbers are already terrible so why use unintentional hyperbole to make the argument it just weakens it.
Anyway, jumping from "50% of papers will probably fail an absolute bare minimum test" to "90% of papers are garbage" is subjectively reasonable to me.
If 90% seems shocking to someone, I suggest they skim a bunch of papers and develop their own feel for how bad the situation is.
Back to the main subject Vertasium has a related video:
Is Most Published Research Wrong https://youtu.be/42QuXLucH3Q?si=p9M0ZOAdHuowD30n
Even if i agreed with your "subjectively reasonable" idea, the issue is that non-STEM science encapsulate a lot of different fields.
I feel like my position is fair for any field publishing papers with falsifiable claims based on evidence?
the preliminary estimation phase predicts like 50% rates of replication
let's be real, the average social science paper is not good
edit: there are lots of garbage papers in every field, the culture of academia is deeply flawed, the low standards are just even lower in some fields