News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by Silhouette on Saturday April 28, 2012 @06:07PM (#3904273)
I don't think the Internet is the problem. Rather, it is an unfortunate catalyst for certain negative effects and serves to amplify others.

One such effect is that many political and legal systems in the West are broken. The general population is apathetic because their voices are so readily ignored by those in power, and special interest groups call the shots. That results in things like an excessively burdensome intellectual property regime, which instead of promoting the development of new ideas and the creation of new products and services by those with meaningful contributions to make, often serves to defend the dying business models of entrenched old players against competition from new players, while in practice offering little benefit to those new players in return because they lack the resources to exploit any advantages they might theoretically have.

Then you combine the resulting culture of resentment by consumers with technology to share creative works instantly, and you not only have a recipe for promoting piracy rather than providing the market with more constructive alternatives that reward the people whose hard work produces things we value (but not enough to bother paying for them, apparently), you also create an over-reaching sense of entitlement in society.

Another negative effect is the kind of education system that we have in many places today where the idea seems to be that no child can be seen to fail, yet it is considered somehow elitist to single out children at the top end of the academic bell curve for any kind of special treatment that would help them to take advantage of their gifts. Here in the UK, for example, we've seen an obvious reduction in the breadth and rigour of exams for at least a generation, and there is a kind of inverse snobbery about selective schools or, worse, schools that charge fees. Of course, those private schools can also use their greater financial resources to employ better educated and trained teachers, provide teaching in smaller groups, and otherwise exploit opportunities to offer a better education to their pupils, but we're supposed to ignore that because if we can't educate all of our children to that standard then damn it we're not going to educate anyone to that standard. Naturally, instead of recognising the obvious flaws in all of this and doing something about it, successive governments and educational institutions seem more concerned with being apologists for the situation, defending this year's school leavers and graduates, and pretending they only tolerate academic high-fliers.

So now we have 50% of the population going to university and, ignoring the significant but still relatively small proportion who now drop out before graduating, every other person has at least a bachelor's degree, and then when they leave university they expect that the same kinds of jobs will be waiting for all of them as were waiting for graduates a generation ago when perhaps 5-10% of the population got the same qualification. The reality is more likely to be a crash course in customer service management with practical training provided in a fast-moving environment (or flipping burgers, as we used to call it). This breeds further resentment, complaints about the high unemployment rate, and so on. Oh, and it also means that many children whose gifts are not academic but who might have made excellent tradesmen or carers or artists or any number of other socially valuable (and often quite financially lucrative, too) roles are pressured into getting certificates that will never be of any real use to them and working 9-5 (sorry, 8-5 or 9-6) in a dead-end office admin job. Did I mention the resentment problem?

There's a whole load more: raising at least one generation with very little respect for anything, the rapid erosion of privacy, the paranoia of governments about anything that might even resemble a possible threat to national security like studying physics, chemistry or engineering, and the list goes on. But this is already a very long post so I won't go into any more areas in detail.

We know these are problems. Our political and legal systems are broken. Our education systems and childcare are broken. Everyone knows these things are broken, and a lot of people have a very clear idea about why, but the system works to prevent those people from getting into positions where they can fix it. And so, instead of encouraging the people with the big ideas to share them, and the people with the practical talents to design better tools and build great new things, and the people with social skills to co-ordinate and encourage all of this, we are breeding new generations who have no concept that anything worth doing requires hard work and commitment, and whose total career aspirations are to climb the middle management ladder as fast as possible (or just to stay alive and out of jail, depending on the luck of the draw).

The Internet didn't cause these problems. It just makes it easier than ever for us to see them, and it provides a stronger incentive than ever for vested interests to clamp down on anyone innovative enough to pose a threat to their bottom line.

The one comfort I have is that the Internet is almost certainly also the way those vested interests will also be brought down eventually. The Powers That Be have all kinds of resources to throw at problems they don't like to make them go away. In contrast, we're only just learning to use grassroots activism, collective funding models, the ability to share knowledge and ideas freely with like-minded people all around the world, and the ability to share educational resources crafted by the smartest educators on the planet, on the kind of scale that the Internet allows. It will take time to understand these things, and to fix the problems that are getting in the way of progress, but there are always going to be enough smart and interested people in the world to sow the seeds of change, and while they may not rise to prominence in politics or business this year or next, in the Internet age there are other ways to get things done. We just haven't learned to get the right people to use them yet.

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by healsdata on Saturday April 28, 2012 @08:15PM (#3904595)
> we are breeding new generations who have no concept that anything worth doing requires hard work and commitment, and whose total career aspirations are to climb the middle management ladder as fast as possible

Bull. It's a common problem for older generations to besmirch younger generations for exactly the same stunts they pulled.

There are still soldiers, Olympians, prodigies, single parents, and many more examples of young people doing things that require a ton of dedication. Every week, Undercover Boss manages to find young people working their tails off to pay for school, medical bills, and work towards their dreams. Last night's episode featured a young man who wanted to be a choreographer but knew he needed schooling to make it; thus he was hauling huge carts of pretzels all over Philly every day to pay for classes.

And yes, there are people who hope to get to middle management as soon as possible. They have tons of motivations but they're no different than the last generation's ton of people who wanted to get stable union jobs. Most of them want to make a decent living to provide a roof and food for their children. The path to doing that has changed generation over generation, but it's still the same idea.

Certainly we can do things to help lift them up and help them innovate, but we're not going to make any progress by calling the next generations lazy.

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by notJim on Saturday April 28, 2012 @09:28PM (#3904771)
There are small parts of this comment that I could nitpick, but overall, it really resonates with me.

I've been thinking a lot about how the internet can influence politics in a democratic society more directly. I suspect that there are enough people online organized around various communities to have a measurable impact, but the way voting and candidacy systems are a) not online, and b) tied to geography make it difficult to move into the real world.

Additionally I feel that attention spans on most internet communities is so short that backing something like a real movement or political change isn't really possible. In fact, most of the people I've met who actually care and are willing to make real changes also explicitly reject the internet due to perceived shallowness. They may be right or wrong, but I think the reality is that we have to convince people like that to care, because they're the ones that power movements.

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by chipsy on Saturday April 28, 2012 @11:07PM (#3904949)
I have a slightly different feeling of what the internet is doing for politics. It's a subtle change, but one which I think has outsized long-term effects.

Basically, my thesis is that we are generating more collective wisdom in the past. There are more "raw stories," and scandals are almost impossible to cover up once they're leaked to the public. Representation for all sides of an argument can be found whenever desired. The rabble-rousers of comment sections everywhere are always willing to debate, even if they usually aren't very good. As all age groups start to contribute, it becomes easier to get a "long view" of society now vs. in the past. And at the bare minimum, we have Wikipedia's record of reality, which may not be perfect, but on matters of political importance, is usually wrung dry of fallicious statements very quickly.

While this doesn't change the human condition - we're still going to act in dumb self-interest and get swayed with a lot of the same old tricks - a collective change in perception is a major factor for subsequent changes in action. Everyone says the voting public should be well-informed...and increasingly, they are!

But we're still in the "catch-up" phase. Although there are many obvious problems with society as we know it, that doesn't mean we've found answers yet.

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by notJim on Sunday April 29, 2012 @01:01AM (#3905155)
I am nowhere near as optimistic as you are. One of the biggest problems I see with the way we interact online is that there are very few places* where people with differing viewpoints interact at a level of trying to learn from or understand one another. The result is that politics are even more fragmented than ever, and everybody feels more righteous and mistakenly better-informed, because they've never had to read and seriously and honestly consider an opposing viewpoint.

* Honestly HN is the closest I can think of, and it's skewed pretty heavily liberal with a touch of libertarian.

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by UK-AL on Sunday April 29, 2012 @06:26AM (#3905643)
To anyone who doesn't know what his referring to when talking about selective education(UK). In the uk there used to be 11+ (you did it at 11) test, you passed the test you want to grammar school. You failed the test, you went to secondary modern, you learned metal work, plumbing, or typing for girls. Roughly 20% were selected for grammar education. Secondary moderns were badly funded to compared to grammar schools. This caused various problems, sometimes secondary moderns kids ended up doing better(Academically) than grammar school kids. So no one knew if it was actually any good for choosing schools or just socially divisive. It was a good indicator of future social class, pass and your middle class, don't and your working class.

Turned out the whole thing was based on the slightly dodgy research of cyrill burt(http://www.indiana.edu/~intell/burtaffair.shtml and http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/tripartite_education.ht...) on his work on the inhertbillity of iq. Basically he thought it was unlikely for working class kids to become middle class. So why bother?

As someone who goes still lives in a council who keeps grammar schools, but not secondary moderns. It is true that grammar kids are highly tutored for the 11+, that's what my parents did for me. That's how I got in. A lot of friends did too. As result it almost entirely composed of middle class kids who can afford to be tutored for the 11+.

Naturally there is a lot of lobbying by the middle class to bring back grammar schools across the country, because it is effectively free private school as long as you tutor your kids for the 11+.

When I refer to the middle class, I refer the UK definition of it, not the American. In the UK "middle class" roughly refers to upper middle class.

In my opinion it is basically a way for the middle class to divert funds to their own kids, from working class kids in a zero sum game for the education budget.

And trade work isn't financially rewarding, that's a myth. The average wage of a plumber or electrician is 27k, bang on average wage. The only places they get 50K+ is in areas of shortage. I.e Rural Areas.

For more information see

http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/tripartite_education.ht...

and google it.

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by teyc on Monday April 30, 2012 @12:29AM (#3908034)
Come to Australia. My plumber charges $90 per hour.
Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by Silhouette on Sunday April 29, 2012 @11:03AM (#3906129)
You're quite right that the 11+ was a system that could be gamed, and people with lots of money would pay tutors to do it. One could make a similar argument about university admissions. However, it's also possible to pass the 11+ or get into Oxbridge or whatever academic "elite" measure you wish to use based on merit.

And it's not just about whether the school has more money. There have been plenty of government programmes over the years where schools could change their status in financially beneficial ways, and most if not all of them had nothing to do with being selective.

My concern is that academic ability tends to fit a bell curve. Most children will be somewhere near the middle, and will be able to progress at a similar pace. Towards either end of the bell curve, that stops working, and you need a more individually tailored approach to help each child maximise their potential. That's important to help children who have learning difficulties that can be at least partially overcome with one-on-one tuition, and it's just as important for children who are academically gifted but won't be able to take advantage of it or will even get bored and drop out if they aren't challenged at school. In recent years, there has been a lot of emphasis on special assistance for children with disadvantages, but it seems there's some sort of backlash against also trying to help children with advantages to make the most of them.

If you want a good way to stifle innovation within a society, holding back the smartest kids seems like a safe bet to me.

(In the interests of disclosure: I did go to grammar school and then study at Cambridge, and I did it without paying funny money to anyone. But I'm not really talking about me here, I'm thinking of a couple of friends who were far smarter than I ever was and who joined my school at 16. They had never really been challenged at their previous schools, perhaps because they were likely to get straight As anyway and there was no league table advantage in spending further resources on them. They caught up once they were working with teachers who were used to working with smart kids, but I've always wondered how many other kids didn't get in at either 11 or 16, never grew as much as they could have, never made it into the university they could have, and ultimately never received the education they deserved.)

Edit: Sorry, I forgot to address your other point:

And trade work isn't financially rewarding, that's a myth. The average wage of a plumber or electrician is 27k, bang on average wage. The only places they get 50K+ is in areas of shortage. I.e Rural Areas.

I think you're making my point for me there: in a generation when nearly half the population are coming out of education with a degree, a decent tradesman can still earn a comparable wage.

Also, since the trades are valuable practical skills, there is the chance to earn much more. There's a builder who's been buying up old places near where I live, knocking them down, rebuilding them with his mates, and then selling the new places for a very healthy price. The guy our landlord sends to do maintenance work from time to time runs a couple of businesses doing different things, and from what he's said if he bundled everything in together they might have to register for VAT. The threshold for compulsory registration is something like £77k at the moment, and while that's based on revenue before taxes etc. are paid on it, it still translates to a very respectable salary. When we had an electrician out a few months ago, the cost for him and his apprentice to so some basic work came out at a higher hourly rate than I've ever earned but was consistent with what others had quoted for the job.

Not everyone in the trades is going to get rich, to be sure. But there are plenty of people in the trades who are earning a relatively good wage based on their practical skills. As long as they're doing a good job, I have no problem with that at all, by the way. But why mess around pushing them to study academic subjects they might have little interest in, when they could instead work as an apprentice learning a trade they enjoyed and were good at? How is a degree in some dubious subject from a new university going to help someone like that more than a couple of years working jobs with a more experienced partner and then maybe getting some industrial qualifications so they can take on more demanding (and better paid) jobs in their field?

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by UK-AL on Sunday April 29, 2012 @01:55PM (#3906512)
Considering the average wage is also includes part time work, and lots of non-skilled jobs, AKA student jobs which drag the average down. I should hope a skilled full time worker, would earn significantly more than the average wage considering they have to support a family.

There are tons of dodgy plumbing and electrician scam schools(http://www.plumbing-school.co.uk/), which perpetuate the myth of 50K+ wages. It's in their interest, and it's entirely false. You end with a crappy nvq and no work but they get government grants to train you. I wish people would actually do the research.

You also have to separate wages, and profits when talking about this. Wages are what you can sell your labour for, to other companies relatively risk free. However profits require risk. Most of these high achieving plumbers money comes from the profit his company makes and not via his wages. That's why they always mention their self employed.

What this means, you have to run business and take a lot of risk in order to get that sort of money as a plumber. You could end up bankrupt, and that would not happen via wages. While educated people can obtain a lot of money with relatively little risk via wages. For example the barclay brothers took on enormous risk in order to get where they were. While someone who went to oxbridge and then into a Investment banking graduate scheme doing underwriting took on relatively little risk. They will probably never be at risk of having their home taken away, and being declared bankrupt. However the barclay brothers had to use massive amounts of leverage(Mortgages, Business loans etc) and risk to come from home decorators to owning a business empire.

I also have to mention intelligence is fluid - http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-15369851. Trying to work out who's smart and who's not is difficult. Achievers may end being terrible, dumb kids may end up being pretty smart over the course of a lifetime.

I know lots of people who went to new universities, who have very good jobs(At my work place). Some of them went onto old universities to complete MSc and MBA degrees and ended up with distinctions. Don't be so small minded, it's like you've been reading right wing tabloid press.

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by Silhouette on Monday April 30, 2012 @04:52AM (#3908509)
Please remember that you brought the distinction between wages and other forms of financial benefit into the discussion, not me. All I'm saying is that someone skilled in a useful trade can make a decent living without being pushed down the academic route. Of course those who go into business for themselves will have to risk more but can achieve higher returns; that's true in almost any industry. And of course there are snake oil salesmen offering worthless "training" or "credentials"; that's true in almost any industry as well. But high incomes for freelance tradesmen aren't the myth you claim them to be; multiple people who've done work on my home within the past couple of years are an existence proof of well-compensated tradesmen, and others were quoting similar rates.

As for fluid intelligence, perhaps things do change at different times for different people, but I don't think I'm going to set aside the general expectation that smart kids will do better if they are challenged at school based on one study of about 30 kids where a few of them moved significantly in one direction or the other between the ages of 14 and 18. I don't see why the two hypotheses are incompatible anyway.

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by Superpig on Sunday April 29, 2012 @11:06AM (#3906139)
I agree that a very large number of the problems are social, but I disagree that they're not being solved because "the system works to prevent those people from getting into positions where they can fix it."

I mean, hell, just strike up a conversation at the pub and you'll find people who "have a very clear about why" everything is broken. Everyone has a pet theory that they're sure is correct. And in that sense the system is doing exactly what we want it to do: it's keeping out the infallibilists, the people who will advance their pet theories in spite of people on all sides pointing out the problems with it. No matter how well-intentioned those people are, it's a very bad idea to hand them the Big Stick of Government if they're going to keep wielding it when we want them to stop. And it's particularly bad if they intend to make sweeping changes - if we're going to be futzing with such powerful structures, we should be taking baby steps!

It's much safer for us to keep the government populated with vote-seeking politicians, and instead to turn out attention to where it should be, which is getting the solutions into the culture. If the electorate all want a particular change, then the politicians will make that change. And if they don't all want a particular change then we shouldn't be imposing it on them. And if they don't care, we should persuade them to - "X doesn't affect you directly, but it will help us make Y cheaper for you" can be effective. If the change really does make a better world for everyone - and not just advancing the interests of one group at the expense of another - then it should be possible to show them that.

I mean, heck, in the US there's an oil billionaire who funds billboards that just advertise "being confident" or "having perseverance." How cool is that? As cultural engineering goes it's pretty crude, but it's a damn good start.

And if your response to this post is "but changing culture is practically impossible," then, well. I think you just found your lack of innovation ;-)

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by Silhouette on Sunday April 29, 2012 @11:47AM (#3906230)
I mean, hell, just strike up a conversation at the pub and you'll find people who "have a very clear about why" everything is broken. Everyone has a pet theory that they're sure is correct. And in that sense the system is doing exactly what we want it to do: it's keeping out the infallibilists, the people who will advance their pet theories in spite of people on all sides pointing out the problems with it.

Of course if we're going to get anywhere we have to distinguish strong, uninformed opinions from strong, well-informed ones. But consider the problems with dumbing down the education system. It's not as if the people recruiting new graduates into the professions and complaining that they immediately have to send them for remedial training these days are making it up. There's nothing in it for universities to complain that new students arriving to study the sciences don't have enough maths to complete their first year any more. Every year, schools and government ministers trot out the same kinds of argument about better teaching methods and pupils working harder to justify the ever-rising percentages of candidates receiving top grades. They look pretty foolish next to a critic holding up an 'A' level exam paper that pupils used to take before leaving school at 18 in one hand, and a first year university exam paper taken at 19 from a decade later with essentially the same question on it, or the equivalent with an old 'O' level paper that kids would have taken at 16 a generation ago with more demanding questions than an 'A' level paper kids take at 18 today.

You can only bury your head in the sand for so long before bad things start to happen, but successive governments who want everyone to be seen to succeed have been pushing the education establishment in this direction for a long time, and most of the teachers who knew better have retired by now. The only victims in this will be the children, and to some extent the new generation of teachers who are doing their best and perhaps do have some genuinely improved teaching methods to offer, yet who are perpetually vilified for being part of a system that is not their fault.

It's much safer for us to keep the government populated with vote-seeking politicians, and instead to turn out attention to where it should be, which is getting the solutions into the culture. If the electorate all want a particular change, then the politicians will make that change.

Unfortunately, the corrolation between vote-seeking behaviour and doing what the people collectively want isn't very strong in the current system. Here in the UK, we've been to war for a decade, a war that everyone saw coming and that brought literally millions onto the streets in protest, a war based on false evidence given by political leaders who have suffered little if any adverse consequences personally and who show no remorse for their actions. That's about as serious as it gets.

Of course, it's also against the law to sing "Happy Birthday" to your child in public, drive at 75mph on a completely clear motorway on Christmas morning, or smoke a joint in the privacy of your own home. I realise that the anti-Happy-Birthday lobby is a strong one, but that's going a little far. (And when the government did consult on fixing copyright, and close to 100% of the responses received from the public came down the same way on copyright term extension, Sir Cliff won anyway.)

There is a reason that "campaign finance reform" or whatever you call it locally is always on the political agenda but never gets anywhere. When all you have is an election every few years, and between elections there is no power of recall or ability to force a referendum on a single issue or other strong check on government authority, money talks louder than any concerned individual because a good campaign will win over enough less concerned individuals to make a bigger difference. And that's before you even get to our special kind of politics in Europe where if something isn't palatable to the national electorate you just kick it over to the unelected guys in Brussels, let them push through what you want, and then claim that the EU made you do it.

Did I mention that a lot of people are politically apathetic these days, because they don't feel their votes make a real difference? :-)

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by Superpig on Sunday April 29, 2012 @01:20PM (#3906417)
But consider the problems with dumbing down the education system. It's not as if the people recruiting new graduates into the professions and complaining that they immediately have to send them for remedial training these days are making it up. There's nothing in it for universities to complain that new students arriving to study the sciences don't have enough maths to complete their first year any more.

Absolutely, but they're a tiny force compared to the parents who all want to send their children to top universities and will vote for any government measure that claims to guarantee that. If a party proposed outlawing university entry requirements, the vast majority of parents would vote for it in a heartbeat and begin making plans to send their kids to Oxbridge or wherever. They don't understand that such a thing would cause those universities to no longer be top universities - at least from a career prospects point of view.

And that's my point: for successive governments to want "everyone to be seen to succeed," the electorate needs to be complicit in that. They have to see such things as success. If they didn't see University as inherently better than the alternatives - the result of thinking that more education is always good, and that formal institutions like universities are the only way to get more education - then they wouldn't consider a policy of increasing university intake to be valuable.

The only victims in this will be the children

The victims in this aren't the children: the victims are everyone. We all suffer from the system being broken. Some more directly than others - being unable to find competent workers is probably less upsetting than being pushed into enduring 3-4 years of timewasting - but everyone to some extent. And yes, that includes the politicians who, at the end of the day, want to buy quality products and to work with competent people, just like the rest of us.

Unfortunately, the corrolation between vote-seeking behaviour and doing what the people collectively want isn't very strong in the current system. Here in the UK, we've been to war for a decade, a war that everyone saw coming and that brought literally millions onto the streets in protest, a war based on false evidence given by political leaders who have suffered little if any adverse consequences personally and who show no remorse for their actions.

Hold on, there. We're talking about whether the government does what the people want or not; if it manipulates them into wanting something in particular, that's a separate issue, so the false evidence point isn't relevant here; many groups manipulate the public, not just the government. And "millions of protestors" do not make for a collective stance on an issue: the largest single anti-war protest was 1 million people in February 2003 - 2% of the population - but a month later YouGov were reporting that 50% of their survey group supported the war. Public opinion was at best divided - it was certainly not united behind one course of action while the government took another.

Anyway, one contentious counterexample does not a correlation make. Can you show a substantial trend of the government acting against majority polling figures across many issues?

Of course, it's also against the law to sing "Happy Birthday" to your child in public, drive at 75mph on a completely clear motorway on Christmas morning, or smoke a joint in the privacy of your own home.

Sure. But so what? They're not enforcing those laws. It's not ideal that they're on the books, but changing the books is expensive and it's better to spend the resources on making changes that are actually connected to the rest of the system. Considering purely what's statutory is taking things out of context.

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by J3L2404 on Saturday April 28, 2012 @06:25PM (#3904324)
Bullshit. This utopian claptrap shows how out of touch nerds have become with reality. Everyone is being tricked into liking things - they like them, you don't, get over yourself, there is no conspiracy.
Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by Silhouette on Saturday April 28, 2012 @06:32PM (#3904343)
The thing is, not everyone is being tricked into liking things. In fact, opinion polls consistently show that most people don't like a lot of the factors I mentioned. The problem is that the people who supposedly represent the rest of us often don't behave in a way that truly reflects what the general public wants, because the inherent pressures in today's political and media complex push them in other directions.
Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by loup-vaillant on Sunday April 29, 2012 @05:00AM (#3905545)
The only "conspiracy" I saw spoken of was about the "Powers that Be" clinging to their position of power, using a bit of collaboration (such as lobbying, contracts, or collusion). People talking to each other in order to preserve the enormous amount of power they already have. That's only natural. Calling it "conspiracy" doesn't make it go away.

Or did you have something else in mind?

Re:When Will This Low-Innovation Internet Era End? by seanp2k2 on Saturday April 28, 2012 @08:07PM (#3904575)
Keep calm and carry on; everything is obviously fine.