News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Willow Protocol by black_puppydog on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:38AM (#39029186)
Huh? I'd understand your phrase "protocol generator" to be the equivalent of "higher order protocol" in the same way that a "higher order function" can be seen as a "function generator"...
Re:Willow Protocol by smaudet on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:12PM (#39030499)
The difference would be that a function, order non-withstanding, is (a) callable (site). "Higher order", merely means one that takes/returns other functions, but they are still fundamentally, functions (callable sites).

A protocol has the property that it is implementation independent, but that it has a defined interface (i.e. it is immediately usable).

This is neither (not a defined interface, implementation dependent). If it doesn't share either property with a protocol, then you can't claim that it is truly a protocol, "higher order" or otherwise.

This confused verbiage is what should be cause for concern - note that I can claim a "higher order" protocol with JSON or gRPC - its all the basic building blocks for a protocol, just both sides need to implement the same stuff!

Except, neither JSON nor gRPC are crazy enough to claim to be a "higher order" protocol, which to me puts this in the rubbish bin of over-complicated technologies looking for a problem, like SOAP, JavaBeans, OSGi - all of these could also be claimed to be "higher order" protocols as well.

The term is meaningless, and so I assume, is this project.

Re:Willow Protocol by jazzyjackson on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:37PM (#39030840)
its wild to me that you would dismiss a project as meaningless because you can't immediately understand it
Re:Willow Protocol by smaudet on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @12:45PM (#39030939)
Oh I might read their specs: "Willow is a family of specifications:" https://willowprotocol.org/specs/index.html#specifications

This part looks useful.

But is it useful to be a "willow" family of protocols? Probably not.

Their claims on the front page are extraordinary. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and heading the page with nonsense is not a good start.

Re:Willow Protocol by mplewis on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @02:42PM (#39032418)
Pretty rude to dismiss a project without reading any of its documentation.