News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Space Solar Power Demonstrator ends first in-space mission by IshKebab on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @08:48AM (#39027602)
The point I was trying to make is that fusion makes sense, the only issue is actually doing it.

In contrast solar roadways and space based solar don't make sense. Sure you could build them. But it would never make sense to do so because there's always a better way to spend your money. It's never* going to make sense to build a solar panel into a road than just on a field. And it's never going to make sense to build space based solar rather than just Earth based solar + batteries.

*standard HN pedantry disclaimer

Re:Space Solar Power Demonstrator ends first in-space mission by epistasis on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @10:13AM (#39028797)
And my point is that it's never going to make sense to do fusion to replace any current energy generation method. There's always going to be a better way to spend your money than fusion.

This is inherent to the way fusion is even being developed. It's always assumed that the fusion part is going to be more expensive than the equipment to convert thermal energy to electricity, which is why it makes sense to make it as energy dense as possible, and therefore more cost efficient.

But from that very starting point, it's clear that there will always be better ways to generate electricity than fusion: solar and wind combined with batteries.

We have much more reason to be optimistic about the cost case of extraterrestrial solar than the cost case for fusion.

Re:Space Solar Power Demonstrator ends first in-space mission by hutzlibu on Wednesday January 17, 2024 @07:20PM (#39035631)
"But from that very starting point, it's clear that there will always be better ways to generate electricity than fusion: solar and wind combined with batteries."

I am 100% for renewable energies and would not wait for fusion - but I am very hesistant to use the word always here. If there is a breakthrough in handling the plasma - and recent developements indicate that this might be possible - it could make fusion very cheap. So when you have a cheap, compact and reliable energy source - most people would favor it over something unstable that takes a lot of space.