Re:On being listed as an artist whose work was used to train...
by JeremyNT on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @03:16PM
(#39018513)
> There is nothing that can be done short of terminating the global internet. Sure you could ban it in the US and Europe, but you can't in China, et al. You can't ban it everywhere. You can't ban open source.
Ah yes, the Nirvana Falacy. [0]
Microsoft, Google, etc are corporations that operate within a legal framework. You can quite readily claw back some of their profits from such ill-gotten gains and redistribute them to the creators who they currently intend to put out of work.
"Oh, but some pirate will do it! Oh, but China will do it! So why not let those poor megacorporations do it, too!"
So what. The megaorporations who nominally answer to and respect the rule of law are the lion's share of this problem. They can be made to stop. Solve them and you're 90% there, don't get bogged down in the other 10%.
Ah yes, the Nirvana Falacy. [0]
Microsoft, Google, etc are corporations that operate within a legal framework. You can quite readily claw back some of their profits from such ill-gotten gains and redistribute them to the creators who they currently intend to put out of work.
"Oh, but some pirate will do it! Oh, but China will do it! So why not let those poor megacorporations do it, too!"
So what. The megaorporations who nominally answer to and respect the rule of law are the lion's share of this problem. They can be made to stop. Solve them and you're 90% there, don't get bogged down in the other 10%.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy