i have half a dozen backups of all the ssh keys i use because i am scared to loose them. the chance that someone gets access to one of those backups is probably more likely than them breaking into my email. ok, they would still have to find the password for the ssh keys. my point is that the risk to loose something that i can't keep in my head is greater than such a breakin. when i set up 2FA for github or gitlab i am going to plaster that 2FA app on as many devices as i possibly can to mitigate the risk that i would loose one of those devices which could permanently lock me out.
how likely is it that an attacker can take over my email?
they would have to break into my laptop, and take over my browser and break into my mail server. or they would have to spoof the DNS for my email domain.
are there any threats i am missing?
This is the case for the service that I am about to release. It makes it very convenient for users that forget their passwords. I know many instances of users not using services, because they forgot the passwords, and the services make it difficult to reclaim their accounts (Google, for instance).
Too much security can be a killer, for many applications. We don't need Fort Knox security for many apps.
In our case, we make sure that we don't require any user data, beyond a simple email address (and have Apple's private relay enabled, for those that want a bit more security). For many app developers, keeping so little user data is anathema, as they are actually PID harvesters.