Re:Japan ANA Boeing 737-800 flight turns back due to cockpit...
by Dylan16807 on Saturday January 13, 2024 @02:25PM
(#38983574)
> 737 MAX IS 737, lengthened.
That wasn't under dispute. The question you responded to is whether they had to use the 737 brand.
And personally, I think that once you lengthen it and move the engine, it would not be weird at all to give it a different number. Even just 738 would give it better distinction than "MAX".
Re:Japan ANA Boeing 737-800 flight turns back due to cockpit...
by Retric on Saturday January 13, 2024 @01:39PM
(#38983053)
The point is they could have called it “Blueberry” instead of “737 MAX” and have it still share the same type rating as the 737.
Which is perfectly reasonable as changing the branding alone isn’t particularly meaningful from a safety, airworthiness, or training perspective.
Re:Japan ANA Boeing 737-800 flight turns back due to cockpit...
by zirgs on Saturday January 13, 2024 @04:49PM
(#38984941)
> But introducing new major system would require re-certifying pilots so the hid the fact, downplayed importance of it.
Is it typical to hide critical systems from pilots in the aviation industry? Or is only Boeing doing that?
Re:Japan ANA Boeing 737-800 flight turns back due to cockpit...
by throwaheyy on Saturday January 13, 2024 @07:37PM
(#38986227)
No, what parent said is true: they could have changed the model number if they so chose to, and kept the same type rating. The 757 and 767 have the same type rating for example.
Whether they call it 737, 737 Max, 73Seven, 838 or whatever else is just marketing and has no bearing on keeping training compatibility. Only the type rating matters for that.
And the story of the MCAS is that Boeing needed this system to make 737 MAX to behave in entire envelope. But introducing new major system would require re-certifying pilots so the hid the fact, downplayed importance of it.