News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by BenFranklin100 on Saturday January 13, 2024 @12:33AM (#38977605)
I HATED classes taught on a blackboard. I learnt nothing. Blackboard and chalk pedagogy is a technological artifact from the days it was economically infeasible to provide students with printed handouts.
Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by jacobolus on Saturday January 13, 2024 @01:15AM (#38977743)
The blackboard is a much more democratic, transparent, two-way tool: everything the teacher does the student can directly see and imitate. Watching someone reason with a writing implement in hand is an incredibly valuable learning exercise, since effective technical problem solving is largely done that way in practice. Students should also be practicing solving problems directly at the blackboard, with the teacher and other students as an audience. (Writing on an overhead projector or some kind of projected ipad screen or something could be an alternative, but these are higher-tech for no real advantages in an in-person lecture context, and make it much harder for multiple people to participate together. Writing on paper is an okay substitute if there are no more than about 3–4 students per teacher.)

A handout or slides or video is an opaque one-way tool, a prepared polished document that students can see but typically have no easy way to imitate. It affords the lecturer more chance to put effort in up front into making a clearer document, but robs students of the chance to witness their teacher doing some of the work in real time, and ultimately leads to a relative loss of basic problem solving skills involving writing/drawing, trading them away in favor of immediate gratification. Sometimes this trade-off is worth it (e.g. Grant Sanderson's work largely couldn't be replaced by blackboard lectures https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYO_jab_esuFRV4b17AJtAw ), but when the school's entire pedagogy moves that way, the loss is tremendous in my opinion, an erosion of some core tools of a centuries-old mathematical/scientific culture.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by lisper on Saturday January 13, 2024 @01:41AM (#38977845)
> Watching someone reason with a writing implement in hand is an incredibly valuable learning exercise, since effective technical problem solving is largely done that way in practice.

I vehemently disagree. Classroom lectures almost always present results that are already in the bag. I can't remember a single class where a professor actually walked us through the process of figuring something out. The closest I've ever seen is 3blue1brown, and he obviously doesn't use a chalk board.

Nowadays technical problems are often solved by writing code, which is almost never done on a chalk board outside of job interviews.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by jacobolus on Saturday January 13, 2024 @01:48AM (#38977864)
Even when chalkboard lectures present material that was prepared in advance, there's a significant difference vs. prepared material presented in slides or a typeset document or a video. Writing imposes a speed limit on the lecturer, and forces them to verbalize the whole reasoning process. In slides it is much easier to skip past the meat of the work, and much harder to be responsive in writing/pictures to questions and discussion.

> can't remember a single class where a professor actually walked us through the process of figuring something out

This can't really be blamed on the tool of the chalkboard. I promise you this does happen in some classrooms. It certainly happens all the time in informal discussion between professionals. In my opinion schools should strive much harder to induct students into a problem-solving culture than teach specific content trivia. A blackboard is an invaluable tool for the former.

> often solved by writing code

Writing code is a narrow and constrained tool with much less freedom than writing on paper, and thoughts made first in code are substantially blinkered in my experience compared to thoughts worked through on paper. Many of the best programmers I know do their most important work on paper (sketching, planning, doodling, drawing diagrams, ...) before ever touching the keyboard. And that is far more true still for mathematicians, physicists, etc.

What is true is that many programmers are not very effectively taught to use paper to its full advantage as a tool for thought, and either never learn or largely figure it out on their own. Our typical computer science pedagogy is frankly terrible at this, and professionals' on-the-job training isn't much better.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by lisper on Saturday January 13, 2024 @10:55AM (#38981070)
>> can't remember a single class where a professor actually walked us through the process of figuring something out

> This can't really be blamed on the tool of the chalkboard.

That is true, of course, but that was not the point. The point is that blackboards do not necessarily produce, or even encourage, good pedagogy. The two things are largely orthogonal.

> Writing code is a narrow and constrained tool with much less freedom than writing on paper

Yes, I think this is a feature, not a bug. It enforces a certain amount of rigor that blackboards don't.

Of course, the language in which the code is written matters a lot.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by WalterBright on Saturday January 13, 2024 @03:35AM (#38978207)
> I can't remember a single class where a professor actually walked us through the process of figuring something out.

I'm sad for you. All my professors did that in every lecture. I'd copy it down in a spiral notebook as he'd describe it step by step. Later, when reviewing the notes, it would bring back the lecture in my head.

This was before the days of videotape, but I still regret not taping the lectures with a cassette recorder.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by lisper on Saturday January 13, 2024 @11:12AM (#38981251)
Just to be clear, they did walk us through the process of solving the kinds of problems that would be on the final exam. But the starting point was always a set of equations that were simply given as gospel with no motivation nor justification nor hint as to how they were arrived at. It drove me nuts.

You can see this happening today. My favorite contemporary example is elliptic curves, which are a hot topic. Most introductory materials on elliptic curves will tell you that an elliptic curve is defined by an equation of the form: y^2 = x^3 + ax + b. Where did that come from? Why is there no x^2 term? How did anyone ever figure out that this particular equation would be good for cryptography? What other polynomial equations might be good for cryptography?

And then one day you learn about Montgomery curves, which do have an x^2 term but no x^0 term. So was the whole x^3 + ax + b thing a lie from the beginning? What about a complete cubic equation with all terms included? Is that an elliptic curve? Is it useful for cryptography?

Maybe my brain is just wired differently from most people, but those kinds of questions just pop up naturally for me, but I hardly ever see them either asked or answered. And this is true in every technical field I have ever studied, and I've had a very long and diverse career.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by abdullahkhalids on Saturday January 13, 2024 @04:09PM (#38984595)
Those are very valid questions, and as a (former) professor, I know that most smart (and many 'not smart') students do ask those questions. Lecturers should do their best to set up the motivation for each topic. This can fail because

- There is not enough time. Unfortunately, formal courses have a fixed time, and the lecturer has to cover a certain amount of content in that time [1].

- Sometimes, its not actually possible to answer the 'why' questions with the amount of background that students have (or the lecturer has).

The above is also true for books/written down notes as well. For instance, in your example of elliptic curves, the answer to your questions about "why the form y^2 = x^3 + ax + b" requires students to understand algebraic geometry first, where such curves are defined in general (over arbitrary fields etc), rather than over the real field as you have. If you read such a book, you will see why in the general setting, its completely natural to define such curves. I don't know exactly why elliptic curves are good for cryptography, but I would hazard that the reason is perhaps only apparent when you study them in the abstract - hence why you don't see this explanation in your resources. The writer might not even know themselves.

[1] Yes yes, this is broken as well. In my ideal university there would be no semesters. Courses will be as short or as long as necessary to naturally end at an appropriate location.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by bayindirh on Saturday January 13, 2024 @06:27AM (#38979029)
> Nowadays technical problems are often solved by writing code, which is almost never done on a chalk board outside of job interviews.

Nope. They are solved by either formulating a solution in maths or drawings or verbally, then it’s transformed to code step by step. Code is just your intention or solution distilled for a much more constrained machine, and is the very last step.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by lisper on Saturday January 13, 2024 @11:14AM (#38981268)
Maybe in your field, but in over 40 years of work in a pretty wide variety of technical fields I have never seen a single person write an equation on a board as part of doing actual work.
Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by bayindirh on Saturday January 13, 2024 @12:09PM (#38981952)
Interesting, because I find myself writing formulae to my notebook all the time. It's not differential equations all the time, but I'm generally making sure that something is scaling correctly, or the things I'm doing are the ones I really want.

I would love to have a board at office, but instead I have tons of notebooks which I finish, scan, shred and recycle.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by BenFranklin100 on Saturday January 13, 2024 @05:37AM (#38978751)
What are you going on about? There is no ‘reasoning’ or ‘problem solving’ going on in real time. The professor is transcribing an already prepared lecture, oftentimes literally with the prepared notes in one hand and the chalk in the other. Real problem solving is a tedious, nonlinear exercise with many dead ends and start overs. There is nothing in a prepared lecture for a student to imitate.
Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by andrepd on Saturday January 13, 2024 @06:07AM (#38978926)
Well it's silly to assume that these are mutually exclusive methods of teaching. As you well point out, prepared material on a computer can show things that you simply can't on a blackboard, things like visualisations, graphs, schematics, or other things that are either too tedious or impossible to write down on a blackboard and copy to a page.

My rule of thumb is: screen for exposition, blackboard for problem-solving.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by amadeuspagel on Saturday January 13, 2024 @06:14AM (#38978960)
If you want to learn writing, wouldn't it be much better to see someone write in a word processor, to write with the same tools that you will also use?
Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by jacobolus on Saturday January 13, 2024 @12:42PM (#38982420)
No, a word processor is a very poor tool for reasoning through the solutions to technical problems, compared to paper or a blackboard. You need to be able to draw, doodle, make tables and charts, write with whatever symbols you can imagine, etc.

Once you have a solution in hand, you can use computer drawing tools to make a polished version for publication. But that's a different problem than the original reasoning.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by hyperluz on Saturday January 13, 2024 @06:14AM (#38978963)
Since there is no space inside my house, to put a decent sized blackboard and I don't have free access to one, maybe blackboards aren't so democratic as one would wish.
Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by broscillator on Saturday January 13, 2024 @11:02AM (#38981153)
I think a blackboard is cheaper than any device that lets you view PDFs
Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by jacobolus on Saturday January 13, 2024 @12:36PM (#38982332)
I have known people who lived in a run-down studio apartment or just a bedroom in a shared house who had a sizable blackboard or whiteboard. So this is clearly more of a personal choice about your space than anything inherent about the tool. But if you are by yourself or with 1–2 colleagues (not trying to explain to a group) you can certainly do the same work on paper. Reasoning through a problem on paper becomes unworkable when you try to show more than a few other people at a time, which is where the blackboard comes in.
Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by abdullahkhalids on Saturday January 13, 2024 @06:16AM (#38978971)
To positively add to your viewpoint, my experience as first a student and later a professor is that many students prefer slides/notes to blackboard because the former often gives them the perception that they learn more.

Slides/notes are fixed content. It's also finite content that you have to learn. If you learn all that content, you have mastered the course. So, it's quite easy to assess how much you have learned. But slides/notes don't teach skills well, and teach even more poorly on how to think in the course domain. Books also do poorly at this. The only way to learn skills and ways of thought is, as you say, by imitation. The imitation happens on the blackboard, where a good lecturer thinks out loud, gets the students to think out loud with him, and hopefully transfers the rhyme and rhythm of the discipline to them.

The 'problem' is that you can't really nail down concretely from a blackboard lecture what you are supposed to learn. Moreover, no matter how much you read the book, and master the content, you will always feel like you aren't thinking as well as the lecturer was. So you feel bad. Of course, if you let the pain drive you, you continue on your path of learning. If you don't, then blackboard courses feel horrible [1].

[1] A huge percentage, I would hazard, majority of lecturers are not of sufficiently good quality. Teaching is incredibly difficult. So, many blackboard courses, as do many notes/slides courses fail because the lecturer was just bad.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by BenFranklin100 on Saturday January 13, 2024 @02:30PM (#38983617)
I guarantee 75% of your students got lost along the way at some point, and — having lost the train of reasoning — are simply waiting for the class to be over so they can review the textbook and try to make sense of the subject matter. At least for difficult classes like physics and mathematics, which require uninterrupted thought and reflection to achieve understanding.
Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by bayindirh on Saturday January 13, 2024 @05:30AM (#38978706)
I don’t understand the rationale behind assuming everything old is worse than today’s methods, technology.

I still get my pens and paper when I design a software or study something that I want to learn, and it works trillions times better than watching a video or going through some slides.

I still produce my notes & documentation from books or existing material, and retain that knowledge almost indefinitely.

There’s mounting evidence about both people have learning differences, and using pen and paper exercises the brain in a completely unique way.

Ignoring this is pretty counterintuitive from my perspective.

Re:The Magic of the Blackboard by Tomte on Saturday January 13, 2024 @05:43AM (#38978783)
Blackboard and chalk are an artifact of a time when students came to classes prepared and could follow.