News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by ipaddr on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:31PM (#38975042)
The average person is better off with higher wages and more job opportunities. The wealth class is poorer. Big multinationals are poorer.
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by acdha on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:43PM (#38975185)
Do you have any sources for that claim? The credible estimates have a net loss on the order of 4-7% over a few years, and there’s no expectation that will reverse in the foreseeable future.

https://obr.uk/box/the-outlook-for-household-income-and-cons...

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by ipaddr on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:54PM (#38975288)
That's for the country. Then they divide by population and claim everyone is $1,000 poorer. The elite class would reap the benefits and the poorer class would have wages kept even lower.

If everyone including corporation's wealth were equally shared then yes you are correct. But in reality it's the opposite.

If the rich could import unlimited people wages would go to almost nothing. The economy would grow because the country as a whole would grow. But it makes the average person worse off.

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by acdha on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:03PM (#38975352)
They’re calculating real household income - even the richest only count as one of those, unlike a simple GDP/population calculation.

In any case, feel free to provide your alternative analysis.

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by ipaddr on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:24PM (#38975555)
Cheaper services benefit the rich averaged across everyone it's 1,000. For example saving $10,000 on lawncare means 9 poor families can not benefiting and the headline is still correct. In reality they save 20,000 and those poor families are 1,000 worse off.
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by acdha on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:51PM (#38975758)
The figure I provided shows real household income dropping significantly. That’s not the simple averages you’re trying to distract with.
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by ipaddr on Saturday January 13, 2024 @08:49PM (#38986623)
Real household income is just income adjusted for inflation. It doesn't adjusted for any other reason.
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by dspillett on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:44PM (#38975197)
I'd love too see some well researched stats to back that up. Otherwise I'm calling that complete bunkum.

Increasing prices, even before the inflationary pressure caused by outside forces in the last year or so, have more than eaten any increase on average salary. The extra jobs vacated by EU citizens we've made officially less welcome are mostly jobs people don't want so instead of increased employment we've got seasonal work & other "unskilled" work not being done, and low paid but high stress jobs (nursing care etc.) also going unfilled. Other vacant jobs are in areas we have not yet made up the skills shortfall in (have you tried to get a plumber in recently?).

The wealthier "class" is doing perfectly fine and knew they would be, that is why so many of them told big porkies to convince others to vote that way.

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by ipaddr on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:02PM (#38975344)
Jobs no one wants? These are the jobs that the average person still needs (nevermind wants). I have been a plumbers assistant, a plumber's job is a job that could give the average person a goodlife. The problem is the rich want to pay someone as cheap as possible. Those farm workers don't even get minimum wages and live like modern day indentured slaves. Give them a FAANG salary and work culture and you will get millions applying
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by dspillett on Friday January 12, 2024 @07:21PM (#38975992)
You have conflated two of my points on jobs incorrectly.

Plumbers and other such jobs are some that we currently lack the skilled people to sufficiently fill. Still. This many years after brexit.

And while the working conditions of many seasonal jobs are far from good, sometimes blatantly illegal, where the jobs have been filled it is more expensively (one of the factors, a number of them due to the effects of brexit, fuelling those price rises that counter any wage rises that have happened), and where they haven't crops have gone unharvested causing waste and, surprise, fueling price rises this time due to lack of supply.

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by piva00 on Saturday January 13, 2024 @10:23AM (#38980742)
Plumbing is not a job no one wants. Picking strawberries is. Being a bin man is.

> Those farm workers don't even get minimum wages and live like modern day indentured slaves. Give them a FAANG salary and work culture and you will get millions applying

Where will the money for paying those salaries come from?

Of course the problem is the rich class wanting to exploit workers, that's something we know since before Marx, hence why he wrote Das Kapital...

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by CydeWeys on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:37PM (#38975118)
Brexit has lowered wages and killed job opportunities, though.
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by mwagstaff on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:35PM (#38975086)
Are you able to share any data to support that?
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by ipaddr on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:46PM (#38975214)
People with lower education level have a smaller pool of jobs available. Those overlap with people traveling for work from places with a lower economic standard. A lack of migrant workers means higher wages and more opportunity.

It's why few on here get projects from upwork. A select few can specialize and demand US market rates while most compete with individuals happy to make $5 US an hour.

Growing the economy doesn't mean it is going to trickle to the poorest. Often a country with a high growth rate has a large divide between rich and poor. Often a slower growth country funnels that wealth to the lowest in society.

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by ortusdux on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:50PM (#38975249)
So, no?
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by ipaddr on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:27PM (#38975587)
I'm accepting funding for this new study you are requesting.
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by dspillett on Friday January 12, 2024 @07:43PM (#38976167)
Either there is good information out there to back up your position already, in which case just link to it and we'll check it out, or you are very confident in your position without information to back it up, in which case we don't have any compulsion to believe you to be correct.

Statements that can be made without good evidence can be rightly dismissed just as easily.

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by ipaddr on Saturday January 13, 2024 @08:50PM (#38986630)
There is no counter data or study provided. What side are you choosing to believe?
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by dspillett on Sunday January 14, 2024 @08:51PM (#38996509)
You have given us nothing to counter? At least nothing but vague hand-wavey rhetoric.

Costing the UK overall $178bn is going to harm us all in the long run, so the initial article is your starter for ten.

If you want us to give a reasoned counter to your position, you first need to properly describe your position. Spouting “well you haven't cited sources either” when we ask you to cite sources is playground stuff, in a similar vein: show us yours and we'll show you ours. If you make claims and refuse to substantiate them, then complain that a counter isn't sufficiently substantiated, it isn't us that looks like they don't know how to properly discus things.

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by Supermancho on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:56PM (#38975304)
There are conflicting reports of increases ([1]or decreases, like this one) during the pandemic. Most show a net growth since 2019.

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/933075/wage-growth-in-th...

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by acdha on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:09PM (#38975410)
From that page:

> While wages are currently growing at a relatively fast pace, high inflation is currently cancelling this growth out, leading to the negative growth in real terms throughout 2022 and early 2023. Although it is likely that UK inflation peaked in October 2022, at 11.1 percent it has yet to fall below double figures as of March 2023. Forecasts from the Spring 2023 budget predict that the annual UK inflation will average out at 6.1 percent in 2023, before falling to 0.9 percent in 2024. Falling wages is just one of the aspects of the current Cost of Living Crisis, which has led to the steepest fall in living standards in a generation

Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by tonyedgecombe on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:35PM (#38975096)
Not in real terms, adjusted for inflation the median wage has fallen.
Re:London mayor says Brexit has cost UK over $178B so far by mberning on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:38PM (#38975135)
This is like a “sun rises again” story. Of course the mayor of London still hates brexit. Just like the rest of the ruling class and their lackeys in the media.