News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unity's Open-Source Double Standard: The Ban of VLC by torstenvl on Friday January 12, 2024 @01:12PM (#38971676)
So no case law.

You've pointed me to two sections of the license, but neither directly says what you're claiming. Why don't you help us understand what your argument would be? I.e., explain how you would apply the rules in the license to the facts of iOS distribution to reach the conclusion that distribution on iOS is a per se violation?

Re:Unity's Open-Source Double Standard: The Ban of VLC by kelnos on Friday January 12, 2024 @02:21PM (#38972635)
There is -- for better or worse -- precious little case law on the GPL and LGPL. All we have to go on is the advice of lawyers and our own judgment.
Re:Unity's Open-Source Double Standard: The Ban of VLC by ajross on Friday January 12, 2024 @01:48PM (#38972174)
> explain how you would apply the rules in the license to the facts of iOS distribution to reach the conclusion that distribution on iOS is a per se violation?

That's analysis is exactly backwards, and I cited the specific text in the license that calls it out. You can't distributed copyrighted works without permission, period.

Apple can't ship my code, whether it be directly or in a Play Store app, unless I let them. The LGPL specifies the terms of that permission. They're clearly in violation, since I can't download a Play Store app and modify it.

Again, we all agree to ignore this. But it's true nonetheless.

Re:Unity's Open-Source Double Standard: The Ban of VLC by torstenvl on Friday January 12, 2024 @01:53PM (#38972261)
I'm sorry, but "issue-rule-application-conclusion" is the standard analytical framework for questions of this nature. You may feel that it's "backwards" but it is, objectively, simply how this works.

There is no text in the license that discusses the issue of app stores. You have every right to jump to the conclusion without any analysis of how the text of the license applies to these facts. However, you'll of course understand that—by doing so—you aren't likely to convince anyone who doesn't already agree with you.

Re:Unity's Open-Source Double Standard: The Ban of VLC by ajross on Friday January 12, 2024 @02:06PM (#38972433)
> I'm sorry, but "issue-rule-application-conclusion" is the standard analytical framework for questions of this nature.

Do you, heh, have any case law to that effect? No, that's silly. "You're shipping my code and have to stop" is an open and shut case. That no one has bothered to prosecute such a case against an iOS app is notable, but not proof of anything but inertia.

Re:Unity's Open-Source Double Standard: The Ban of VLC by torstenvl on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:20PM (#38973425)
See, e.g., Licea v. Caraway Home Inc., 655 F. Supp. 3d 954, 968 (C.D.Cal. 2023) ("Indeed, at no point does Plaintiff bother to explain why any of his cited authorities are relevant to the instant action or how they should apply. Every law student is taught a variation on the 'issue, rule, application, conclusion' (IRAC) method for legal analysis.").
Re:Unity's Open-Source Double Standard: The Ban of VLC by Kim_Bruning on Saturday January 13, 2024 @12:35AM (#38977612)
Hacker news is not a court of law, and I don't think it's fair to make up an arbitrary rule from outside hacker news and then try to apply it here.

Try to meet other people in the middle?

Re:Unity's Open-Source Double Standard: The Ban of VLC by torstenvl on Saturday January 13, 2024 @12:12PM (#38982001)
HN is for intellectual curiosity. As a result, if you want to discuss legal analysis with a lawyer on an article about a legal topic, I suggest you listen and learn, rather than insisting that others meet you in the middle on fundamental tools of analysis. And in particular, criticizing those frameworks as "arbitrary" or "made up" is dishonest and completely inappropriate.

In this case, after several days of back and forth, nobody has offered any argument for why the terms of the LGPL are incompatible with iOS apps. At this point it's pretty obvious that all of you are just trolling.