News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by bluGill on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:50PM (#38958857)
What choice do they have? Airplanes wear out from metal fatigue over time, so airlines must replace their airplanes regularly. It isn't safe to keep operating the same airplanes for decades. (this very much depends on what the plane is made of - so some airplanes from the 1950s are still safe while others from 2000 are not). Sometimes airplanes are scraped by selling to some "third world" airline that keeps operating the airplane long past the safe date - engineers are very conservative about max life of an airplane but eventually the wings will fall off an old plane in the air.

Because of this all good airlines won't operate old airplanes. The few bad airlines can't operate very well because any country with a functional government will not allow you to fly an expired airplane. And so Boeing and Airbus have long order books to replace planes as they hit end of life. Of course airlines are limited to airplanes still in the current catalog, so they often cannot order the model that was working great for them 20 years ago.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by boppo1 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:45PM (#38961308)
>eventually the wings will fall off an old plane in the air.

Has this ever happened for an airliner?

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by justinclift on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:36PM (#38962382)
There's also stuff like this, where a bad repair 20+ years ago eventually leads to structural failure:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_Airlines_Flight_611

This one only took 7 years from a bad repair until catastrophic failure though:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japan_Air_Lines_Flight_123

So "repair stuff properly" seems to be the important thing there. ;)

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by dpe82 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:49PM (#38961352)
Not the wings and not recently, but there has been major failure due to metal fatigue: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aloha_Airlines_Flight_243
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by AdrianB1 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:09PM (#38962154)
Nope, but all the A-10 Thunderbolt II attack plane wings had to be replaced recently due to cracks and Concorde planes were retired due to cracks (micro-cracks, to be more precise). Aluminium does that a lot.
Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by AdrianB1 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:07PM (#38962137)
> It isn't safe to keep operating the same airplanes for decades.

Me, crying while flying a 50 year old Cessna 172.

Oh, luckily you are wrong this time: most planes at top airlines are replaced with more competitive ones, not because they depleted the airframe. The rest is replaceable - airplanes replace engines more often than some people change their socks and everything else is either regularly checked or replaced based on a strict schedule.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by dralley on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:22PM (#38963263)
Unlike a 172, an airliner is in near constant use, and subject to much more serious stresses, like heavy turbulence, storms, the temperatures at 35k feet, and pressurization.

Replacing the airframe with a more competitive one is part of it, but part of the competitiveness is that you reach a point where you're having to do much more inspections and maintenance than a new plane.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by WalterBright on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:02PM (#38963538)
A Boeing airliner is designed for 62,000 flying hours. After that, the airframe will no longer be reliable. Fatigue damage is pretty hard to detect. Also, corrosion creeps in.

For comparison, a car's life expectancy is maybe 3,000 hours or so. Airframe quality is way, way higher than car quality.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by kelnos on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:21PM (#38963694)
Airframe life is rated in hours of flight, not in years. So your 50 year old Cessna might still have plenty of hours left in it; I bet planes like that aren't in the air as much as commercial airliners.

Also note that the GP pointed out that it depends on what the plane is made out of, so older construction from 50 years ago can have more longevity in a way that more recently-built planes will not.

Re:Did a 1997 merger ruin Boeing? by AdrianB1 on Friday January 12, 2024 @12:33PM (#38971128)
I responded to someone who said it is not safe to fly airplanes for decades. I don't think they meant "decades equivalent of flight hours", but the decades since manufacturing date.