News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by tcbawo on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:50PM (#38942901)
This is nice to see. However, one aspect of the green energy push that puzzles/irks me is the tendency to outsource carbon pollution. Citizens of Hawaii might be carbon neutral for energy production, but they are importing goods and services produced by carbon emitting countries/states. We are lucky that economics of green energy vs fossil fuel-based energy are continuing to look better and better. A climate change win is a climate change win. But I guess we just can’t let ourselves become complacent and say that we’ve already done our part because we let other countries do our polluting for us.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by jakewins on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:01PM (#38943071)
This is true and important - but subtle and easily misunderstood as simply outsourcing emissons .

There is a fundamental pollution that occurs in a coal plant: its purpose is to combine carbon and oxygen to produce heat and CO2.

There is no such fundamentals in producing a lithium cell or a solar module.

We are bootstrapping this carbon free energy system from our existing energy system - so of course, emissions abound - but once bootstrapped, it perpetuates without fossil fuels.

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by mckn1ght on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:12PM (#38943229)
My mind goes to the question of what chemical byproducts come out of the manufacture of batteries or PVs. Maybe it’s not CO2, but something else. Maybe it’s easier to deal with. And maybe it’s a good tradeoff, or just in certain quantities, but if so what is that tipping point? I don’t know where to look for this kind of information.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by standeven on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:52PM (#38943783)
One way to measure this is energy stored on energy invested (ESOEI). It answers how much energy is stored over the lifetime of the device compared to the energy required to build it. Lithium batteries come in at around 32.

This isn't bad, but pumped hydro is way better (704). And both options are way better than the ongoing drilling and mining and combusting required for fossil fuels.

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by owlstuffing on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @05:42PM (#38944489)
>way better than the ongoing drilling and mining. . .

Lithium isn’t mined? Producing large/scale lithium batteries involves large-scale pollution.

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by PaulKeeble on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:33PM (#38945140)
It doesn't have to however. There is nothing inherent in the mining of lithium that requires CO2 emission, we already have electrical replacements for the industrial vehicles that do the mining in some mines already and its simply a matter of time to replacing the rest. All the solar companies in China run off their own panels and cover their own power needs so the actual emissions are dropping all the time.

Just because an EV being charged emits CO2 today when charged from the grid does not mean that emission wont be reducing over time, it will as the grid power comes increasing from renewable sources. So it is with the production of batteries, PVs and wind turbines a lot of these companies take this as a bootstrapping exercise you have to burn fossil fuels to make the transition but once you do you use the green power to make the next versions with considerably less impact.

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by owlstuffing on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:13PM (#38960906)
If trends persist, we will deplete the planet’s available Lithium far before the bootstrap process is over.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by bluGill on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:48PM (#38943722)
If you burned the oil in a wind turbine you would get enough electric to make up for not having that wind turbine for about 10 hours. Similar for the blades, if you burned the inputs you have days of power. The turbine is expected to last for 20 years and so while it isn't zero environmental cost compared to alternatives it is so much better we may as well call it zero.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by irrelative on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:24PM (#38943381)
While I'm sure some chemical byproducts come out of that, it's important to note that hydrocarbons assuredly make some really nasty stuff along the way [1]. I also wish there was a way to more easily compare these things, but the misinformation around environmental data is really next level. General, consider thinking about renewable infrastructure as more of a stock that accumulates vs fossil fuel usage which is a flow.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancer_Alley

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by marcosdumay on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:27PM (#38943423)
If it makes people happy, it must be destroying the planet!

I have no idea what kind of destruction it does. But it's an alternative for making people miserable to the point where it's an stochastic genocide, so it must be bad somehow.

Yeah, I see lots of people saying exactly the same, completely seriously, both online and live. What goes on those people head is beyond my capacity to comprehend.

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by brucethemoose2 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:54PM (#38943808)
I think there's a lot of institutional skepticism in general. Like the game is rigged, and alternative things are secretly nasty and fueled by ulterior motives. This is not surprising, perhaps it's even warranted.

What's really irks me is the other side of the coin, the things that get a "free pass," like (for instance) fossil fuels and their entire production chain. I see a lot of squabbles about the negatives of various energy tech, and somehow the order of magnitude difference between that and fossil fuels is brushed over, not to speak of oil companies' clear manipulation of public opinion.

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by mckn1ght on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:48PM (#38943713)
> I have no idea what kind of destruction it does

This is really all you had to say, but since it doesn’t really add to the discussion, my recommendation would have been to avoid replying at all, especially considering the rest of the content…

> genocide

IME, the people that throw out buzzwords like this about every issue they come across are some of the most likely to perpetrate it, given the opportunity.

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by aziaziazi on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:11PM (#38943203)
Not really: batteries and solar need to be replaced more often that coal plant. The current and foreseen material sourcing, production and logistics for solar and batteries rely on a ton of steel which needs… coal! Coal-free steel already exist but is much more expensive, and will very probably remain expensive for a long time.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by breischl on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:45PM (#38943674)
> Not really: batteries and solar need to be replaced more often that coal plant.

The design lifetimes are on the same order of magnitude, and the components of the coal plant need overhauls/replacement as well. It's not that different.

And notice that the coal plant needs a continuous supply of fuel, whereas battery/solar are one-time costs. That's a big difference anywhere, and any even bigger one in Hawaii where you have to ship the coal in.

>production and logistics for solar and batteries rely on a ton of steel

Totally unlike coal plants, coal mines, and coal shipping.

> Coal-free steel already exist but is much more expensive

If we can't do everything, perfectly, right now, then we should definitely do nothing at all. That's much better, and totally how all technology development works. /sarc

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by slashdev on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:14PM (#38943248)
The quantity of carbon emitted here matters
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by bluGill on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:57PM (#38943871)
What the "production and logistics for" for coal need? I used to live near a coal power plant, there were several long trains per hour of coal going to that plant. Now I live near a wind farm, and while in construction it had a few semis per hour - maybe as much as trains to the coal plant - but that wind farm is complete and will run for a few more decades with very little traffic, while the coal power plant had that many trains per day every day for all the time it was in operation. (it is now shut down)
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by tourmalinetaco on Thursday January 11, 2024 @12:31AM (#38948132)
Carbon emission is a poor and (purposefully) misleading idea of pollution. Lithium batteries may produce less carbon emissions over their lifetimes, but mining that lithium and producing the batteries is still incredibly ecologically damaging.[0]

Companies, in particular, adore the carbon-centric pollution angle because it allows them to ignore the physical pollution they cause every day, while profiting off of ESG. Microsoft alone will have caused an estimated 240,000,000 PCs to have been junked.[1]

[0] - https://www.instituteforenergyresearch.org/renewable/the-env... [1] - https://www.tomshardware.com/software/windows/microsofts-dra...

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by thom_thumb on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:59PM (#38943043)
It would be nice if the whole world would transition away from fossil fuels all in lockstep, but that's just not realistic. The energy transition is going to be/already is very uneven. It's going to happen first in the places that have a strong desire to lead and the financial and the natural resources (e.g. abundant sun) to enable that. Hawaii happens to fit all those criteria.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by matthewdgreen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:09PM (#38943187)
The country leading the renewables transition right now is China. Since they’re also the country that (not coincidentally) builds everything, outsourcing goods manufacturing to them seems like an okay bet, for the climate at least. (And yes, I know they’re building coal, but their emissions are still set to peak because they’re building more renewables than industry can consume while paying to idle coal plants.)
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by graemep on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:45PM (#38943676)
Why are they building coal plants if they are not going to increase their coal fired output?

My guess is that their motive for moving to renewables is more to reduce their reliance on imported oil and gas (vulnerable to blockade in the event of war). Maybe they will reduce oil and gas and increase both coal and renewables use?

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by matthewdgreen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:24PM (#38945040)
It is entirely reasonable to believe that China is transitioning away from fossil fuels in the medium term and that they're freeing themselves from vulnerable oil+gas supply lines in the short term, in preparation for a possible Pacific conflict. What alarms me (for both reasons) is that the US and its allies are not doing the same thing. (*Yes, I know the US itself has plenty of domestic oil, but plenty of our critical allies are equally vulnerable to blockade.)
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @05:06PM (#38943995)
Theyr rebuilding, newer, cleaner, more flexible plants as in the Chinese system the coal plants need to perform the same role as gas plants in areas with easy access to gas i.e. running intermittently at low capacity factors.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by Qwertious on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @10:25PM (#38947134)
>Why are they building coal plants if they are not going to increase their coal fired output?

Because 30% of their GDP comes from construction - building coal plants creates jobs. And as a marginal benefit, they even get a spare coal plant at the end. They've been building all sorts of infrastructure projects that don't make sense to build, coal isn't special here.

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by defrost on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @10:36PM (#38947222)
Or, more rationally - China has closed way more coal plants (small, inefficient, old technology) than it has built new coal plants (larger, new filters, scrubbers, adjacent to fresh coal fields with better grades of coal), in addition to having expanding demand for power.

Currently in China new nuclear construction is slightly below new wind+solar addons, and nuclear+wind+solar are together still a small fraction of total power due to coal.

Yes, China is phasing out coal - but it's a beast.

In the meantime old sulphur filled coal field are being retired, new fields are being opened, and new plants with cleaner burning technology is built next to new fields in order to minimise transport costs (and associated C02 from transport).

Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by davidw on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:14PM (#38943261)
Something I see so much in local politics is that things don't all happen in a nicely coordinated fashion like one might want. Say, building some denser housing with more transit. But people telling you to wait until everything lines up 'just so' most likely want neither. Things happen in fits and starts in the real world.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by bluGill on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @05:01PM (#38943930)
I find it interesting that places like Iowa, Texas, and Kansas are leading the transition in the US despite none being places anything thinks associated with environmentalism. While states you might expect to care are way behind. Hawaii has had expensive energy all along and was an early installer of wind, but somehow is still way behind.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by hot_gril on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:21PM (#38947549)
Easier to build in places like Texas, I suspect.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by kabanossen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:54PM (#38942974)
True but we should also celebrate successes like this. If we wait acknowledging progress until all emissions are replaced we miss the good deeds that happen.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by bryanlarsen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:07PM (#38943155)
I assume the batteries came from China. In 2023 China installed more solar energy capacity than the rest of the world combined.
Re:A battery has replaced Hawaii's last coal plant by dralley on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:07PM (#38943156)
Unless Hawaii was mining their own coal beforehand, I doubt they're losing anything here.