Physically, weight-loss is utterly trivial. Literally everything that people say works, does. Eat less calories, eat less sugar, cut out snacking, cut out liquid calories, cut out processed food, reduce carbs, literally any and all of those work, choose whichever is most appealing to the individual.
The challenge to weight and diet in America is mental and cultural. Obese people remain obese because they have unhealthy relationships with food and eat addictively or emotionally, using food to soothe anxiety, depression, loneliness, disappointment, etc and because cultural norms and advertising have normalized obesity-causing diets.
Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.
The science of body metabolism is hard. But the rules for weight loss are simple: move more, eat less. For some people it's just "Move more, eat the same".
"Eat less" means "less calories", volume can be the same - really helps.
PS chips are a crime against humanity
Changing when you eat is a factor too.
I noticed that carbs such as bread or pasta really help with food satisfaction, unlike fat-intence or protein foods.
Remove sugar in secondary things: tea, coffee, soda. Understand the calorie count in carbs such as chips. East to the mild calorie deficit. Compensate with moderate excercise. And so on, setup new dietary habits one by one.
It doesn't have to be painful!
Agreed; but it is work. And for a great many people, that is an issue.
My journey to effective body weight control was 10 years long. Misinformation is everywhere these days...
But... it doesn't have to be hard. For me gamification of the calorie couting game and step counting worked surprisingly well.
You can't say this on HN, where weight loss is a myth and the only way out is to take a crazy life-altering medicine. Exercise? PFFT. I walked a flight of stairs once, and did not lose a single gram.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/030646...
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/(SICI)1098-1...
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07315724.1999.10...
Your initial statement is completely misleading and shockingly you have provided hard evidence against it.
A 5% weight loss for a 200-pound person equals 10 pounds. Anyone can achieve this by following a fad diet for a week or two.
> Permanent weight loss of more than ten pounds is nearly impossible from a scientific standpoint. The success rate after 5 years of weight loss is somewhere around 0.1%.
Your sources indicate that your initial statement was wrong by a factor of ~100 at least.
The majority of these studies consider a weight loss of 10 pounds over two years to be successful. If you start with 100 pounds or more, that is almost nothing.
Many of them consider anyone who starts at 300, loses 100, and gains 80 back in five years to be a huge success. Is it really?
In healthcare, an obese person is typically considered successful if they lose more than 30% of their body weight permanently. This is extremely unlikely to happen without surgery or medication.
A good diet and exercise routine can have wonderful results, even in the long-term. The percentage of success in losing significant weight with those methods is far, far above 0.1%, and I think people should be aware of that.
It doesn't take more than restricted calorie intake and moderate excercise (walking, gym, etc). After a few cycles of gain/loss it becomes easier food consumption habits change
https://www.hubermanlab.com/episode/david-goggins-how-to-bui...
Permanent weight loss of more than ten pounds is nearly impossible from a scientific standpoint. The success rate after 5 years of weight loss is somewhere around 0.1%. You'd think that if it was as easy as everyone claims, more people would succeed. Heck, many people who have had gastric bypass surgery regain a significant amount of weight, even if their stomachs have been reduced to the size of a ping pong ball.