Carta and Pulley, etc. do a solve a valuable concern here for non-executives who are compensated with stock options and want to keep track of stock vesting, exercises, and shares in a transparent way, I’d say.
(And yes, Carta/Pulley are often portcos of those VCs pushing you to use them)
This is largely a result of how long each product has been available, i.e. the older products are more mature. Hopefully Pulley and AngelList continue to catch up so there is a diversity of good options available.
If you think about it if a company acts in a way that makes you no longer want anything to do with them, the best thing is a vague blog post bragging about how much money they make doing other stuff
https://sfstandard.com/2023/10/25/carta-san-francisco-lawsui...
My company is still taking our business away from Carta, and I don't think anyone's plans should change because they repented after being caught. Things might be different if the CEO stepped down, but he hasn't yet.