News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by yetihehe on Sunday January 07, 2024 @10:47AM (#38902159)
It would help because we have too much CO2 in atmosphere now. It accumulated. If we stopped putting CO2, plants and all the other earth chemical loops would take out that excess carbon.

> CO2 feeds plants to grow, which in turn provides more food and habitat for more life.

Yeah, unless they can't synthesize it because it's too hot and they didn't had a chance to adjust to new temperatures yet. It takes some time and will happen, but we pump CO2 a little too fast.

> In this scenario with China doing the opposite to the rest of the world, there are exactly zero gains for CO2 reduction - far outweighed by the increase in CO2 production.

Oh yeah, someone litters on the street, let's all litter and get rid of the trash cans. Alternative solution: we should stop buying from them so they will not generate that co2.

Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by loceng on Sunday January 07, 2024 @11:48AM (#38902706)
Saying we have "too much CO2 in atmosphere" isn't evidence and historically there was much higher levels, and much more life.

And yes, there will be a delay as part of evolutionary process for when plants and wildlife can adapt - for plants that are better adapted or capable of adapting to hotter temperatures-different climate will adjust - so indeed at minimum reducing the pace at minimum can be useful; and deploying technologies to slow down the increase we have arguably bumped up at least a little bit [remember the distance that Earth to the sun we are is the biggest factor of temperatures, and where are we in that 1000s of year cycle at the moment?] will help, but we could also prepare to pollinate and manage new growth areas with plants/life we know can adapt; the US policy makers on the side of believing climate change is a life-or-death urgent consideration want to spend $40+ trillion "fighting" it - so getting simply helping the Earth adapt, which is what we should be doing because it's unknown exactly how much our changing CO2 levels will actually impact things, is a no-brainer to do regardless - to create more life, to maximize it; and I also believe Elon is correct that Earth can sustain another 10x the current human population - however that will require succeeding in battle against industrial complexes and authoritarian wannabes who're involved in regulatory capture.

"Alternative solution: we should stop buying from them so they will not generate that co2."

Absolutely a good strategy to stop rewarding that behaviour, if that's the best course of action to not destabilize the world too much - which may not be a good idea to potentially force the CCP-China's hand into highly aggressive or bad-harmful behaviour.

But do you think the inflationary policy, money borrowing, $34 trillion in debt, and people currently struggling in the US and West in general will be able to handle the massive increase in costs of goods that will happen if that happens?

Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday January 07, 2024 @11:57AM (#38902817)
Folks often try on these arguments: it'll cost too much (to save all our lives). Or 'it got terribly hot before so somehow it's natural and ok'.

We may survive as a species. But our civilization will not survive the destabilization it causes.

E.g. folks depend on fish for a large part of the planet, from coastal waters. Kill the reefs (which we've made a good start on), the coastal ecosystem collpases (california crab anyone?) and not thousands, not millions but hundreds of millions of people starve.

Then what? Some kind of global rescue effort? Not hardly. Look at the last wave of 10,000 refugees, how every European country was winging about 'we can't accept a thousand! It's too much!'

Now add four zeroes to that number. Get the picture?

Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by loceng on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:13PM (#38904701)
"Folks often try on these arguments: it'll cost too much (to save all our lives). Or 'it got terribly hot before so somehow it's natural and ok'."

This is a straw man argument. I didn't say it costs too much, I was stating options for how and where money may be better spent.

And if you haven't observed yet that the free market - save for regulatory capture - is far more efficient than government at most efficiently distributing resources where needed, then "you" aren't paying enough attention.

Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday January 07, 2024 @04:31PM (#38905339)
The free market is crippled by 'the tragedy of the commons' when it comes to anything whatsoever that isn't simple self-interest. "Somebody else should do that" is typical, or more likely "If I spend anything on a social good, I will be less competitive and go out of business"

Solving problems like this are precisely where government, with all its flaws, is essential to doing it at all.

Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by loceng on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:55PM (#38907717)
It goes one step further than you're thinking though: the government will become corrupted by the worst of the worst for-profit tyrannical bad actors, which is precisely why it's the free market - people en mass - who must actually address these common issues and right the ship.

It starts with industrial complexes forming an unfair advantage, leading to regulatory capture that selfishly sets up rules to benefit the industry's profits at the cost of people, society, the environment. As part of that regulatory capture the industries lobby to get politicians of their choosing into positions of decision making, those politicians progressively are more clever-deceptive and more authoritarian. These two sides of the same coin is fascism.

Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by JoeAltmaier on Monday January 08, 2024 @11:32AM (#38914448)
Got to admit, reading that, I thought it was describing the free market failure to 'right the ship'. The bad actors are not actually bad; they're just responding to market forces. They cannot choose to do otherwise, else they simple go out of business because they are uncompetitive.

The namecalling and villain-choosing is pointless. It's a system that must be designed, one that works with rules and forces in a useful direction.

Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by loceng on Monday January 08, 2024 @01:32PM (#38916068)
"The bad actors are not actually bad; they're just responding to market forces."

You seem to be assuming, and wrongly assuming who I'm including in my referencing bad actors.

Where did I name call? Saying bad actors isn't name calling, firstly, and where the terminology to differentiate who exactly I'm referencing isn't clear enough - and you want to just jump to designing a system, but you need to base that design on who is either forced to into certain behaviour to maintain competing vs. those who are doing far more than just forced into certain behaviours, let's say a scenario where politicians are assassinated in worst case scenario - or where prior to that the bad actors fund politicians who will do exactly as they say if/when elected.

Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by yetihehe on Sunday January 07, 2024 @11:53AM (#38902775)
> Saying we have "too much CO2 in atmosphere" isn't evidence and historically there was much higher levels, and much more life.

We will have more life, but less humans and probably our civilisation will not survive. Apart from that, earth will be fine, so we should do as we please and put as much pollution as we want to?

Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by Kerb_ on Sunday January 07, 2024 @01:31PM (#38903766)
Well, a bunch of the other dominant species would die too, but "life" referring to the construct of individual contained chemical reactions sustaining themselves will surely continue, which is basically the same thing
Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by amanaplanacanal on Sunday January 07, 2024 @02:31PM (#38904355)
You seem to be ignoring the human cost, or maybe you just haven’t thought about it. Under your scenario, millions will die and millions more become migrants destabilizing the governments in the temperate zones. Maybe you are fine with that, a lot of us are not.
Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by loceng on Sunday January 07, 2024 @03:18PM (#38904746)
Huh? How under my scenario do millions die like how you stated? What assumptions did you insert in order to conclude with an ad hominem straw argument?

If you're willing to implement policy that increases the cost of energy then you're also in support of killing off the poorest, right? Jordan Peterson has regularly brought this up in this argument points against the current strategy of CO2 taxes, etc - which are actually worse for the environment because then people can't afford the less polluting energy sources, and then they burn wood - worse for environment for pollution, worse for their own health, and it destroys forests.

Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by Tadpole9181 on Sunday January 07, 2024 @07:00PM (#38906534)
Oh, good, we're citing Jordan Peterson now.
Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by loceng on Sunday January 07, 2024 @09:57PM (#38907731)
Oh, good, HN is showing it's ideological-uncritical side - smearing/attacking individuals rather than argument points. Good job!
Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by amanaplanacanal on Monday January 08, 2024 @05:20AM (#38910161)
Your claim that people will switch from fossil fuels to wood rather than electricity needs some evidence, not just a theory from some random talking head. It’s possible that some people might, but how many?
Re:First tunnel to a magma chamber could unleash unlimited e... by loceng on Monday January 08, 2024 @08:50AM (#38911863)
Firstly, this "random talking head" theory is based on basic-foundational economics: when costs go up, less people can afford those costs - and if it's survival related, they will cut down trees if that is available for heating and cooking.

There also is legitimate research showing that once people earn "$5,000" per year minimum then they are able to actually start caring about non-selfish, holistic-society wide problems - otherwise survival rightly has them concentrating on themselves; which I hope logically makes sense to you, and you don't require me to dig up the link(s)?

Second, what source(s) are acceptable-authoritative to you, e.g. what source(s) will you actually believe?

Do you also think those people are properly or correctly accounted for?

It's why we should work from first principles of logic, and where zero or very near zero people (and I don't mean millions of lives being an acceptable number) are ; do no harm.