Re:Comics I Loved in 2023
by NPC82 on Sunday January 07, 2024 @04:56AM
(#38899916)
Very interesting and extensive list. I now absolutely plan to buy Shubeik Lubeik in arabic for my SO who I just realized owns zero books in Arabic even though they speak, read and write arabic.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Sounds interesting. Now, one last question to those who red it. Does it have the whole problematic panarabic silence of "colonialism was okay when it was us doing the colonialism" woven into its themes? Because, I found that a ton of "antiimperialist" art and writing turned out to be mostly anti-todays empire, pro-old empire by omission.
Re:Comics I Loved in 2023
by ycombinete on Sunday January 07, 2024 @08:18AM
(#38900949)
History begins at roughly whatever time suits the beholder.
Re:Comics I Loved in 2023
by walidthedream on Sunday January 07, 2024 @01:11PM
(#38903528)
I read it. I think you’re talking about two things that have little in common … you re comparing middle age military conquests with 19th / 20th century colonialism. Arab conquests had no racial basis, they did not establish « colonies » in the 19th/20th century sense, they did not subdue the population, kill or banish their intellectuals except at specific and limited religious extremist times, segregate ethnies, and siphon the economy deliberately. which probably explains the arabization process and the fact that 90 percent of modern berbers consider themselves as Arabs because Arab is a culture, it’s not a race or an ethnic belonging.
Maybe a fairer comparison would be with the Ottoman era imperialism and I can guarantee you there are plenty of writings and arts in the Arab world that depict it in critical ways.
So racism is a pre requisite to imperialism? How do cultural imperialist societies (China, Russia) with decorated racism (everyone outside the main area is a bumbling backwards peasant) but a multi ethnic setup into this definition? This whole uniqueness of the western colonialism seems rather flimsy.
Please don't start flamewars. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38899916.