A lot of "index fund" folks criticize shorting and other "gambling" tactics, but it's probably worth noting that the argument for the soundness of index funds hinges on there being a class of traders who identify bad businesses and try to drive their price down. Otherwise, you're just pumping money into a snapshot of the market with no regard for the health of the constituent businesses, and it eventually ends in tears.
Black-Scholes delta hedging (more fancy called "replication of theoretical option prices") relies on it. Shorting for Black-Scholes also has two facets: one where your loss is limited, when you buy a call then delta-hedge by shorting against it. And another one where the market is up to get you, selling a put and hedging by shorting. Works in theory but in practice you get funked and there's little to nothing you can do against it when it happens. I suspect most "betting against Tesla" shorters were actually institutional put sellers. Case when they weren't "betting" at all but hedging.
There are certainly ways to use short selling as a hedge for other positions. But in those cases, loosing money on the short is typically good because it (hopefully) correlates to making more money on your main investment.
The people shorting really just miscalculated how long the meme can carry on.
Active investors, for their part, need to either maintain enough of an edge over freeloaders to justify their pay, or serve a niche market with concerns other than "line go up" (this is where the "hedge" in "hedge fund" comes from).
If every participant is an index investor, then no one is doing the actual work, so the entire system crumbles.
Tesla could be seen as a less extreme example of the same. Unlike Gamestop, it's a very successful company with a lot going for it. But was it ever really worth more than every other car company combined?
https://www.visualcapitalist.com/charted-teslas-unrivaled-pr...
Or what about rapidly growing revenue every year, which no other car company is currently able to do?
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSLA/tesla/revenue
Teslas revenue growth is rapidly slowing. Growth contracting by 50% each year since 2019
Tesla has .66x the revenue of GM but 18x the market cap.
Even at todays rate of growth, teslas market cap today is valued at like 100 years in the future.
Disclaimer, I didn’t even do napkin math because teslas valuation is utterly absurd and claiming it’s proper in comparison to other companies in the same segment is completely ludicrous.
You have an odd view of how investing or trading works. Why should the only choices be "this will go up" or "im gonna sit this one out". What's wrong with the equally valid scenario of "this is overvalued and will go down"?
Were they incorrect? Sure. But that doesn't mean believing that something will go down is inherently wrong or invalid behavior.
Getting back to being serious, "believing" is pretty much what betting is about. Synonym that is. "jecroisque" / "io crecă" trading system, rofl again :)))) . jecroisque = Je crois que.
Maybe you're getting confused with normal trades where you hold onto your stock and hope it goes up in value (like with any other investment)?
The problem with short selling is that you're actually borrowing.
That all said, I'm not saying I disagree with your point either. It is hard to make an ideological argument when this is really more just different shades of grey. Personally I'd say all investments are a form of gambling. Some investments are just riskier than others.
And of all gambles, shorting is the worst. By all I mean "long or short", so I guess there isn't much variation left when you leave shorting out. But with going long on a company at least you can buy and forget. Maybe it bounces back up. Not today or this year but eventually.
With shorting though, it's pure loss. On top of the interest the lender is charging you for the stock that they loaned to you (some 2% last time I checked, when reference rate was pretty much zero). Unlike long where you earn interest (dividends).
So unless you got a really really good reason to short (insider knowledge, some solid stat arb reasoning)... don't do it. Or if you do it, I won't weep for you when you lose.